The Miracles (known from 1965 to 1972 as Smokey Robinson and the Miracles) … Read Full Bio ↴The Miracles (known from 1965 to 1972 as Smokey Robinson and the Miracles) are an American rhythm and blues group from Detroit, Michigan, notable as the first successful group act for Berry Gordy's Motown Records. The Miracles went on to become one of Motown's signature acts of the 1960s, during which time their original lead singer and founding member Smokey Robinson became one of the most successful songwriters and record producers of all time.
During their nineteen year run on the American music charts, The Miracles charted over fifty hits and recorded in the genres of doo wop, soul, disco, and R&B. Twenty-six Miracles songs reached the Top Ten of the Billboard R&B singles chart, including four R&B number ones. Sixteen of the Miracles' songs charted within the Top 20 of the Billboard Hot 100, with seven songs charting within the Top Ten and two - 1970's "The Tears of a Clown" and 1975's "Love Machine" (Part 1) - reaching number-one.

Original members:

Ronald "Ronnie" White (1955–1978, 1980–1983, 1993–1995 (died 1995)
Warren "Pete" Moore (1955–1978) (died 2017)
William "Smokey" Robinson, Jr. (1955–1972)
Claudette Robinson (1956 - 1972, 2005 -2011)
Marvin "Marv" Tarplin (1958 - 1973) (died 2011)

Who
The Miracles Lyrics

Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴

When I had you here
I treated you bad
And wrong my dear
And since
Yeah, since you been away
Dontcha know
I sit around
With my head hangin' down

And I wonder
Who's lovin' you

I, I, I, I, I should have never ever
Never never made you cry
And since
Girl since you been gone
Dontcha know
I sit around
With my head hangin' down
And oh, I wonder
Who's lovin' you

Life without love
Is oh so lonely
I don't think that I
I'm gonna make it
All my life
All my life, yeah
Belongs to you only
Come on and take it girl
Come on and take it

Because
All, all I
All I can do, all I can do
Since you been gone is cry
And it's you, you, oooh

Yeah I wonder
And worry about what I do
Don't you know I
Sit around
Oh, with my head hangin' down
And wonder

Who's lovin' you
(Who's lovin you)

Overall Meaning

The Miracles' song Who is a heart-wrenching ballad about lost love and regret. The lyrics tell a story of a man who mistreated and took his lover for granted, causing her to leave him. He now realizes the error of his ways and yearns to know who is loving her now that she's gone. He laments about how lonely his life has become without her and that all he can do since she left is cry. He implores her to come back and take his heart because it belongs to her only. The repetition of the phrase "I wonder who's loving you" adds to the melancholic vibe of the song.

The lyrics of "Who" are full of pain and remorse, and the vocal performance by Smokey Robinson adds to the emotional intensity of the song. The slow, soulful melody with a prominent bassline and harmonious backing vocals also conveys the sadness and longing expressed in the lyrics. The song was very successful and helped establish The Miracles as an R&B powerhouse in the early 1960s.

Line by Line Meaning

When I had you here
When we were together

I treated you bad
I didn't treat you well

And wrong my dear
I did things that hurt you

And since
Ever since

Yeah, since you been away
Since you left me

Dontcha know
Do you know

I sit around
I spend my time

With my head hangin' down
Feeling sad and hopeless

And I wonder
I think about

Who's lovin' you
Who's giving you love now

I, I, I, I, I should have never ever
I should never have

Never never made you cry
Made you sad

And since
Ever since

Girl since you been gone
Since you left me, girl

Dontcha know
Do you know

I sit around
I spend my time

With my head hangin' down
Feeling sad and hopeless

And oh, I wonder
And I think about

Who's lovin' you
Who's giving you love now

Life without love
Not having love in my life

Is oh so lonely
Feels so empty and sad

I don't think that I
I'm not sure if I

I'm gonna make it
Can survive this

All my life
Everything I have

All my life, yeah
My whole life

Belongs to you only
Is meant for you alone

Come on and take it girl
Come back to me

Because
The reason is

All, all I
All that's left for me

All I can do, all I can do
All I am capable of doing

Since you been gone is cry
Is crying

And it's you, you, oooh
It's all about you

Yeah I wonder
I think about

And worry about what I do
And worry about my actions

Don't you know I
You should know that I

Sit around
Spend my time

Oh, with my head hangin' down
In sadness and despair

And wonder
And think

Who's lovin' you
Who's giving you love now

(Who's lovin you)
(Who's giving you love now)

Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group
Written by: MARK RONALD HOLDEN, SHAUN IMREI, VANESSA JOY AMOROSI

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind

To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

TRACKS

Genre not found

Artist not found

Album not found

Search results not found

Song not found

Most interesting comments from YouTube:

@elizabethsnyder_baldonado39

A beautiful little girl named Bri'Anna sang this song on "Ellen" 2day...
I dang NEAR hit the floor over her astonishing performance.
I HOPE Smokey Robinson gets to hear/see this, somehow.
This young lady is PHENOMENAL!!!!!!!!!
God bless her...& her mama cried...I cried...even the ChihuaRat who owns me cried.
It takes a LOT 2 make Melina cry...💙😚💕🐕💚....
ME...NOT a lot.😭
But this child.
Just...
😀Wow.😍

@marthals89

4y↑2

When I (when I) had you (had you)
I treated you bad
And wrong my dear
And girl since
Since you been away
Dont'cha know I
Sit around
With my head hangin' down
And I wonder
Who's lovin' you

I, I, I, I
Should have never ever
Ever made you cry
And girl since
Since you been gone
Dont'cha know I
Sit around
With my head hangin' down
And I wonder
Who's lovin' you

Life without love
Is oh, so lonely
I don't think
I don't think
I'm gonna make it
All my life (all my life)
All my life, yeah (all my life)
Belongs to you only
Come on and take it girl
Come on and take it
Because
All
All I can do
All I can do
Since you been gone is cry
And you, oooh
Will never wonder
And worry your pretty little head
About what I do

Dont'cha know I
Sit around
With my head hangin' down
And I wonder
Who's lovin' you

All comments from YouTube:

@cathy1098

12y↑50

in the words of Smokey "I couldn't believe a lil kid could sing that song with so much emotion! It was incredible for me, as a songwriter, to see my song performed so well"

@bryani2449

3y↑23

Yes this is the original and props to it and Smokey's voice is just absolutely amazing, But little Michael Jackson omg he sang it with so much more soul

@beverlyharris9859

51w↑3

Thank you Smokey Bill. SENSATIONAL BEAUTIFUL HEAVENLY AWESOME!!!!

@hdclark09

13y↑63

from what I understand. Smoky said that he thought Michael did a great job, for someone who had never experienced that kind of love...But I am a firm believer that you can look at kids sometimes and see that they have an old soul...I think Michael had such a soul...

@juliantarango7579

3y↑1

Good argument Ma'. Now that I know of and I will not disagree.

@hermanjr47

3y↑3

I second that notion to smokey

@misaelramirez7550

3y↑1

Really good argument.

@TyeArtisik

😌

@marcellusclay354

35w↑2

It's amazing the contributions that just One Person can make on the world..Smokey Robinson has inspired Millions with His Art..Mad RESPECT

@JoseSalazar-lq1fl

3y↑7

Going through a divorce listening to Smokey’s amazing words keep me strong. I cannot wait until my 3 sons grow bigger and I can show them this music and educate them on real music that means something deep in the heart and soul. God bless anyone on here 🙏

@madblurb

12y↑28

Smokey Robinson is the boss. This song gives me chills.

@rudolphbradshaw6124

39w

This was 1961 and I was 17 years old and in love with Bettye from Houston who was visiting Waukegan, Illinois on Christmas vacation

@hippiehighpriestess

13y↑13

God, I love Smokey Robinson...he's such a genius...

@mistycat57

12y↑21

you have to remember that smokey, is one of the best song writers ever.

@harborviewoperations6291

5y↑4

Smokey allowed Michael to sing his song. He once said in an interview "This kid is singing my song better than me"

@ItiyahIsrael

14y↑7

Thank you for posting this ORIGINAL! Todays youngsters are unaware of the fact that Smokey wrote this and recorded it with the Miracles before they became known as Smokey Robinson & the Miracles. Smoke tried to inform people at MJ's memorial when he said ,"I wrote the song & thought I sang it".....remember? Yes, this is Smokey's song people!

@Injectz

2y↑5

This is the epitomy of soul music....

@shahidahhenderson4022

10y↑30

IMO, Absolutely no one can slide in and out of falsetto as well as Smokey.

@arriafemi

13y↑60

Even Smokey admits that Michael killed this song.

@paperairforce2689

6y↑4

Thanks for the original song. I had to do a Google search to find out who wrote it.

@KingsOfSpins

3y↑6

This song has had three lives 1. The Miracles (& Smokey), 2. Michael Jackson, 3. EnVogue as the intro to their first debut, career making hit "Hold On". Who's next ?

@Tpeele88

16w

4 temptations

@jojosaylor8996

5y↑1

💋💋💋 Smokey Robinson always have a way of making you feel every single song.
YouTube have thousands of covers and karaoke singers but they never get this classic song correctly

Smokey Robinson
Michael Jackson
David Ruffin
These three gentlemen are the only voices that have that soul , confidence and conviction to create this classic hit.

@chairman6652

3y↑3

America's Greatest Poet : Bob Dylan said about Smokie Robinson .👌

@davidcoxon4710

All the comments on here argue which is better, the original or the J5 cover and then this comment 🙌🤣

Awesome my man.

@allstatelegs1

14y↑5

U R right, it is my opinion and that's what makes the world go around. Smokey lived what he sang, Mike a little boy at the time, he knew nothing about being in love but Mike did a masterful job on the song. Peace

@jerryj920

7y↑3

Early Miracles....pre-Smokey Robinson & The Miracles....classic song; both The Temptations and The Supremes covered this cut as well as The Jackson Five...Motown covers Motown...so much music, so much talent. Thanks for the upload, PerryCoxPF93. Blessings

@mrhawk1924

5y↑1

I never knew SR song this song.. MJ did fabulous job.. anybody still listening in 2919

@TheHiphopgems

3y↑1

I'm sure they will be listening to this song in 2919 😄 Motown is forever

@allstatelegs1

9y↑5

Damn, sing the song Smokey. I fell in love w/my hubby. MJ did a dynamite job on this but the original still goes to Smokey. To hear MJ sing this it took me out but my main coverage on this still belongs to Smokey. You hear Claudette's voice at the end, come on people this is the classic . Your biggest fan Smokey. Sandie C

@francescocusato

9y↑1

Ecco un'altra perla, mi piace riascoltare questi capolavori ogni tanto, poi però ho voglia di suonare! Ecco questo dice tutto...

@71L40H

12y↑4

Smokey, I love this song. So much soul. You're the master of song writing!

@timmy841212

12y↑12

I heard when the Miracles did this song onstage, it knocked the house down, as would the Jackson 5's version years later. I'm as big a Michael fan as anybody but I wished people were more aware of the Miracles' original.

@Martel4

8y↑5

Have always loved this album cover.

@jamone669

6y↑52

Michael killed this song and made it his own.... a lot of people forget that this is origanally a Smokey Robinson song...Smokey even said his self he just stopped performing it cause every one would always say you did a good job doing that jackson 5 song and he would always be like no thats my song lol

@williamg2552

4y↑4

This is a MIRACLES song . You can't and shouldn't give SMOKEY sole credit on a song that ALL of THE MIRACLES recorded. I hear BOBBY RONNIE PETE and CLAUDETTE'S incredible HARMONIES on this song. I hear MARV'S incredible guitar riffs. THIS is clearly a MIRACLES song*....and ALL of them contributed to it...so it's wrong and unfair to give credit solely to SMOKEY . Motown's *First and Most Important Group deserves *BETTER*.

@stevebrindle1724

4y↑1

Unfortunately i cannot listen to Jackson, i cannot get past the fact he was a child mollester!

@solmarcos2104

@@stevebrindle1724 lol he was not

@eric.dangerfield

4y↑2

willcat that matters maybe but considering Smokey WROTE it. It’s HIS song

@molarguy

4y↑1

PLEASE !!!! DO NOT SEND ME ANY MORE PICTURE WITH A GUN ON IT AND YOU TRYING TO TELL ME SOMETHING.... THAT FINE IF YOU HATE ME ..... K

33 More Replies...

@Pekiitthah

12y↑3

Hermoso nada mas que cerrar los ojos y disfrutar de esta grandiosa cancion <3

@victoriajessup4838

7y↑10

Love this version by the Miracles

@chrish1489

5y↑5

This is the original. All others are "versions" :-)

@cassandramuhammad4127

3y↑1

Yeah Michael killed it but nothing can erase the the memories of slow dancing with your crush at the house parties on this song...Smokey was killing it then.

@Sweetalking666

3y↑2

I'm here only because MJ; and yes, he improved it.

@brandonabdullah6780

5y↑2

Yes no disrespect to Michael Jackson, but Smokey Robinson & the Miracles were the originals! This is a beautiful song! Remains me of my now deceased brother he loved this record so much🙏

@maekae8433

I L❤️VE SMOKEY forever! No one sings like him!

@Manderley

4y↑4

Para mi, es la mejor versión de este tema

@kawaiirintaro

12y↑6

Smokey is one of the greatest genius in the world as Mozart

@keithdukes5990

You cannot beat the original!!! The Smoke sings this better than any cover including Michael Jackson! Period!!!

@evansmack9352

8y↑16

Temptations did a pretty damn good cover of this song.

@kelvinblankenship1218

the Jackson's cover of this song's similar ton Temptations

@leeshalee

12y↑1

Willie Hutch kicked it back in the day as well as so many others male artists.

@fabriceragma4144

11y↑31

This is amazing! But the jackson's 5 version is better for me!

@lacurronec3815

then why are t=you here?

@dottie66103

6y↑5

Michael was good,, but THIS is pure heaven!!!!!

@rogermeadowstaylor3256

@@dottie66103 nah nigghha mj bad and murdered it

@jp3813

3y↑1

@@lacurronec3815 How else would he determine which one he likes better?

@amu.s.an_

3y↑1

@@lacurronec3815 because he said this version was amazing? smh come on

@danielnarvaer4013

8y↑2

Super great song,and only Smoky can sing this right.

@juliantarango7579

7y↑24

Let's make this clear once & for all to acknowledge. This is Smokey's song. And because he wrote it from his own experience his voice is the only one that matters in expression & emotion. Everyone else is just doing a cover of the song, no matter how well, good, or great anyone thinks those other versions are. Yes there's situations where a writer puts out a song & it's not as good as someone else who covers it, but that's not the case with Smokey. He was & still is the greatest! BarNone!

@gloriousjohnson9679

7y↑2

Julian Tarango: Say it again!💋

@kelvinblankenship1218

5y↑5

Smokey wrote and recorded this song somewhat as a disposable song never intended for airplay as it was a b-side selection for Shop Around, his first million seller. The song, written in 1959, was recorded at a time when Motown operated on a shoe string budget. If you listen carefully, you'll hear there's only a basic rhythm band accompanying the vocals. By the time the Jackson 5 recorded it in 1969, Motown was a $100 million dollar company(source: Black Enterprise) able to afford the best musicians, arrangers, and recording technology in the industry. But the ironic thing about this song was it was the flip side of Smokey's first million seller and also the flip side of the Jackson 5's first million seller, I want You Back. Of all Motown Songs including My Girl, also written by Smokey, this song has stood the the test of time and has transcended the baby boomer era into generation x and also into the Milleneals. Smokey is an absolute genius blessed by God when it comes to song writing.

@kurtadams3021

5y↑1

PREACH the truth

@8176morgan

5y↑1

This song reminds me a lit bit of "I've Been Good To You" which was also a B side that was recorded around this time. I like that one even better than this, although it was never a hit and I don't think very many people ever covered it. Only Smokey could really sing that song well.

@TheHiphopgems

True but Michael Jackson was an ancient alien that's how he was able to do it better

3 More Replies...

@williamg2552

12y↑19

THE MIRACLES did the ORIGINAL. All later versions, (Jackson 5, En Vogue, Terrence Trent-D'arby, Temptations, Brenda & The Tabuations) , are simply COVERS of THE MIRACLES' ORIGINAL.

@lewis72

Obviously but I prefer Terence Trent-D'arby's version !

@NYRyder1983

3y↑1

Of course the legendary Smokey Robinson wrote the song.

@hollidayevery

8y↑27

My favorite version is the original... smoke was just a youngster when he wrote this... Some may think that some of the covers improved on the original, but I think that it's easy to recognize genius like Smokey's years after the fact, but the real genius was in creating this song from nothingness... Smokey did that... And the lovely Claudette at the end is another high point of this classic masterpiece!! THE MIRACLES! Motown's first Superstar group!

@stevieplez2

8y↑4

+hollidayevery I agree Smokey's falsetto , is the best version, no disrespect to Michael Jackson, but Smokey KILLED THIS!!!!

@Martel4

8y↑5

+Steven Pleasant I can actually go back and forth. I think I love both equally. It's a win win haha

@williamg2552

6y↑3

EXACTLY . The MIRACLES RULE !! If it wasn't for THEM, There'd BE no Motown !! Then , WHERE would Michael and all the OTHER acts have been ?? Singing in Karaoke Bars , of course !! (HA-HA)

@rogermeadowstaylor3256

@@stevieplez2 no Michael better

@ezerlenewatkins9644

2y↑1

Smokey's words to the songs that he wrote himself. Boy and the way he sings them ohoooo.I just wonder where he gets those words. Listen to cruising they put you in another world. The man is a master with words i'll try something new, happy landing baby baby i need you. A love she can count on. And the one that almost got me kicked out of high school and at the time i was almost out. My Girl just to name a few. I love me some smokey robinson.!

2 More Replies...

@cassandramuhammad4127

We didn't know anything about Michael back then!!!

@elizabethsnyder_baldonado39

@chariotwofilthy8374

Hi edagdwg thanks for sharing always love this song because losing your frist love hurts the most because might not come again Linda j peace love bug ❤️💯

@SuperJazzymusic

12y↑1

great song by smokey and i love smokey's voice but michael jackson put the soul in this song and it doesn't matter if he was a child and knew nothing about love because his voice is amazing on this song.

@1wonderfulmom

8y↑5

the temptation sing this song too..

@esolizh

7y↑3

Love The Temptations version.

@jerryj920

The Supremes sing this as well...early on. Classic song...many times Motown covers Motown...so many songs, so much talent. Blessings

@josephinelenoir1804

6y↑1

This’s Smokey, no one else but Smokey Robinson, that’s the end of it!

@rogermeadowstaylor3256

4y↑1

@@josephinelenoir1804 nah not the end of it.

@rollerchickable

I Love This Song And I Love For Michael Jackson To Sang This Song.

@marthals89

4y↑2

@janismikofsky1860

4y↑1

I love this song. I have the original album which Smokey autographed for me after a concert. I appreciate the time you put into posting the lyrics, but you probably got them off of one of those lyrics websites and they were probably using somebody's cover version. So there are lots of little mistakes. Maybe you could take the time to patiently play this original of the song so you can correct your lyrics and then repost with the actual original Smokey Robinson lyrics. That would be really cool.

@rogermeadowstaylor3256

@@janismikofsky1860 nah Mike killed it

@Martel4

12y

I freakin' love that picture!

@TheZeevik

7y↑3

smooth killer

@nahseemx7527

5y↑4

Yeah Smoke did his thang.... But i gotta go with Little Mike on this one

@willpsomiades

8y↑22

original great version before everybody who tries out for American Idol jerk it up and also give credit to Michael Jackson and never mention the author Smokey.

@willpsomiades

8y↑5

1961 to be exact

@sereneamani1713

8y↑2

flip side of shop around - 5th grade for me

@jameshayden2538

7y↑2

Yeah I Still Have The 45 Single

@leitocollado4800

Epic

@jerryscott4115

1y↑1

I admire Tammy/Terrell cause my name is sire Jerry Terrell Scott.

@diannedavis5443

I prefer this version to any other. Personal taste.

@mikandersen8632

Lennon/McCartney was listening carefully and ended up with the intro to All’ve gotta do🙃

@yumyumoh

13y

!!!!!!SERIOUS!!!!!!!

@allstatelegs1

14y

Micheal may have pulled if off as you stated, but there is no one like smokey singing this song. There is Mike's version and then there is Smokey's- I love Mike but smokey is the Man. Happy Holidays

@stevieplez2

8y↑27

Smokey's falsetto , is the best version, no disrespect to Michael Jackson, but Smokey KILLED THIS!!!!

@genesys184

+Steven Pleasant I do agree, he wrote it so no one can be better than the original... However I have to admit that Terrence Trent (aka) Sananda Maytreya in one of his concert did a wonderful rendition of this song.... Please can you watch him and give me some feedback about his voice... Thank you...

@stevieplez2

8y↑4

Oh yes Terrence Trent Darby Killed it too... I used to play back Smokey's version over and over visualizing me sing that and getting all the girls lol

@stevieplez2

I believe he sung falsetto on You can depend on me.. Not really on this one

@genesys184

8y↑2

Steven Pleasant Thank you very much for replying....I'm a BIG fan of great vocalist and real music (real instrument) and live performances by singers who can make you feel like "I don't want to breath" so I will not miss anything... I didn't know about his work and I think his music and songs are really good with a useful meaning and message...Thanks again and stay blessed.....

@stevieplez2

8y↑2

Yes indeed when I 1st heard WDAS radio station play all the Miracles music doing a tribute I felt like I was in heaven... really

10 More Replies...

@kurtadams3021

From the GENIUS of Smokey

@blancolirio

6y↑3

A Robert Plant interview brought me here...he claims this was the very B-side recording that changed HIS life...the first record he bought with his own money.

@davidcoxon4710

That's interesting. John Lennon loved it too. Must off been amazing to hear all this music coming out back then

@cleetus58

The Supremes is also a superb version

@posteador

I still like the original.

@1wonderfulmom

7y↑2

have any heard the temptation sing this song ? how did you like it. it sound real good to me.

@esolizh

7y↑1

I do like this version, The Temptations with David Ruffin on lead. Absolutely the best version.

@ebonieladi

Check out The Temptations Sing Smokey album.

@williamg2552

12y↑2

@GR4C3W Yes. THE MIRACLES did the original version.

@strandwolf

14y

@PerryCoxPF93 Right, and there were solid covers by Brenda Holloway, Brenda and The Tabulations, and other artists major and minor pre-Jacksons. That's Claudette, Smokey's wife at the time and a member of the group at the end of the song. See album jacket, and their Wikipedia page. Their "You Really Got a Hold on Me" is the fookin' dawg's bollocks.

@francescocusato

Questa è nel mio repertorio

@jhaeBANGS

12y

well i like both version.

@makantaun8351

6y↑1

Siapa yg Dtng Chanel ini.Gara2 Indonesia idol 👍

@leliuliana

6y↑1

gue wkwkwk

@bjclark1017

13y

@OriginalClydeAidoo Its funny how the 'now' generation have no idea about what communication was like when the Miracles did this song in the late 50's. . .people didn't even have color TV's then! There was no internet, there was no You Tube, there was no 'mass communication' for that matter. Michael sang the song great, Smokey sang it great--and, he wrote it. It is a different world now, and I hope that there is room enough to accept them both for what they 'are' or have been'.

@williamg2552

14y

@GR4C3W yep !!!

@leitocollado4800

In 2021

@romaroslaters7046

The tempts sang this song the best even though Smokey wrote it David perfected it just the raw emotion in each lyric he sang and the range Smokey sounds like he’s trying to hit certain notes but Ruffin sang it so effortlessly plus Smokey’s voice seems to soft and high even when he get raspy just listen to the David sing this with the temps and there’s no question Michael couldn’t even come close imo.
1. The temps
2. Everyone else lol

@TheHiphopgems

Nah Dave's is second best, dave was still trying to hit notes, little MJ hit all the notes effortlessly

@Donnymac

12y↑1

@06kkid YOU can match the tone in Mike's voice. I'd really like to see that.

@TomSmith-od8vd

10y↑1

check out the version by Brenda and the Tabulations

@mercedeswilkins9085

This Smokey and the miracles song. Smokey wrote it and record it first with his group the miracles. So Michael Jackson isn’t the first to sing it people.

@darrenmay4818

Terence Trent D'Arby put out a wicked version in 1987..............

@ezerlenewatkins9644

I just really like smoky and the miracles singing who's loving you. No disrespect to michael jackson. But see smokey just stir it up somehow. Could be that I was just in my teenage years and me and all my friends just thought the world of smokey robinson (i still do). But no one can beat him singing who's loving you. Well no one can beat him singing anything as far as I'm concerned. Michael jackson sang it pretty good. But Smokey!!!!

@VENUS.SE7EN

13y

@arriafemi Of course because he did just that.

@yolondamontes9549

Yes this is smokeys song❤

@strandwolf

15y

damn

@someonek6179

A com from Jackson verse brought me here

@emailnicholasleander

6y↑1

Siapa yang kesini gegara liat kimberly idol junior?

@leliuliana

gue wkwkwk

@febbyamalia5422

Gueh

@PSICK1234ikillallracistrolls

This is where Nas got his album cover from.

@williamg2552

13y

@GR4C3W Yes. THE MIRACLES recorded it first.

@williamg2552

15y↑1

If THE MIRACLES hadn't made it FIRST, the Jackson Five wouldn't have had anything to COPY. OTHER GROUPS MAY BE COOL.... BUT THE MIRACLES RULE !!!

@rogermeadowstaylor3256

Michael Jackson better

@toddgoza3522

The Jacksons 5 covered this song

@geldofpunk32

9y↑9

Dang it, I still like the Jackson 5 cover better. I also like the Beatles' cover of "You Really Got A Hold On Me" better than the original too. I think it's because I heard the covers first.

@dustee

9y↑2

Chris Marshall well that's Okay, but I beg to differ on both counts. :)

@Pax2sitoh

9y↑2

It's ok. Even smokey admitted the jacksons cover blew him away

@dustee

9y↑1

Manuel Loya Doesn't mean it was better. Of course I heard Smokey version first. LOL, let just agree to differ. When I hear Michael's version...I still hear a child singing. I was an adult back then. :)

@elwin38

I like Michael's/Jackson 5's version but i like The Miracles version of "You Really Got A Hold of Me".

@jonathanmacpac

6y↑1

You could make a case for the J-5 as the better version, but Lennon's pedestrian vocals on "You Really Got a Hold on Me" don't stand up to The Miracles. For a great Beatles Motown cover, listen to their version of Barret Strong's "Money".

@peteralger8486

7y↑3

KILLER> Peter

@12sapito12

5y↑4

I don' understand why I see credit for this wonderful song so often attributed to Michael Jackson, Michael Jackson??? This is SMOKEY ROBINSON'S Song, which he sang with the Miracles all the way back in 1960. Now if those attributing this song to Michael Jackson just 'cause he covered the song, could just do their homework and give credit where credit is due. Smokey, this is your Song, and, you're still Smoking after all this time.

@VENUS.SE7EN

13y

@PURE10RodrigoMercado Not originally.

@bluvandyke

13y

listen to terence trent d'arbys version??? make up your own mind

@utillisateurs

13y

Sorry, I prefer Jackson :D but it's nice too ;)

@chibababy

13y

@06kkid i disagree.nobody can copy smokey's version,and no one can copy michael's version.they may have tried copying michaels becoz it was more popular,but they only tried that doesnt mean they were successful.

@criss1789

12y

por que mierda naci en la era de las estrellitas de disney

@williamg2552

To me, The MIRACLES original version of WHO'S LOVIN' YOU is by FAR. the BEST*. Alternate cover versions by The Temptations, J-5, En Vogue, Terrence Trent-D'arby Lauren Hill, ETC. CAN'T TOUCH IT . Other artists, particularly MICHAEL and EN VOGUE, tried to use this song as a showcase for riffs and vocal acrobatics. But, in the PROCESS of doing that (being show-offs), they lost the WHOLE POINT of the song. This is a SAD, REMORSEFUL SONG sung by a HEARTBROKEN MAN. A MAN.... (not a pre pubescent KID)...who caused hurt, and is now experiencing it BACK,as payment for his own actions. It's a song that clearly conveys a MESSAGE: "You Never Know Just WHAT you've GOT...UNTIL YOU LOSE IT". NO SOLO ARTIST...and NO OTHER GROUP, conveyed those feelings BETTER than *Smokey, Bobby,Claudette,Ronnie,Pete, and Marv....The Miraculous MIRACLES!!!
P.S. : ANYBODY can sing somebody ELSE'S song. It happens in KARAOKE BARS every DAY !!! It's a tribute to the greatness of the MIRACLES' ORIGINAL that so many OTHER artists were emotionally moved to COVER it. That's a tribute to *THE MIRACLES*....not *THEM*.