The Plot in You have released one EP and four studio albums. Their EP Wife Beater was released in 2010, followed by their debut studio album First Born in 2011, and second studio album Could You Watch Your Children Burn in 2013. On July 17, 2015, the band announced their signing with StaySick Recordings and Happiness in Self Destruction was released on October 16, 2015. On June 15, 2017, they parted ways with StaySick Recordings and signed to Fearless Records while also announced their fourth studio album Dispose, which was released on February 16, 2018. Their fifth studio album, Swan Song, was released on September 17, 2021.
The Plot In You continue to move forward on their fifth full-length album and second for Fearless
Records, Swan Song. The Ohio quartet— Landon Tewers [vocals], Josh Childress [guitar], Ethan Yoder
[bass], and Michael Cooper [drums]—stare down years of negativity, soured friendships,
disappointment, and mistakes and flush it all away in the wake of hammering distortion, towering
melodies, cinematic production, and unapologetically cathartic lyrics. Ascending to the apex of an eight-
year grind, the band reached critical mass on 2018’s DISPOSE. The standout “FEEL NOTHING” exploded
with 28 million US streams, while the project eclipsed 55 million US streams. Billboard raved, “DISPOSE
is the band’s most polished and cohesive work to date,” and Alternative Press noted, “DISPOSE makes it
clear that TPIY challenge both the listeners and themselves more and more with each release.” Grading
the album “9.0-out-of-10,” Rock Sound predicted it “should finally – and deservedly – make The Plot In
You a name that everyone knows.” They supported the record by hitting the road with Underoath, The
Amity Affliction, Like Moths To Flames, Sum 41, and more. After racking up over 100 million streams and
receiving praise from Billboard, Rock Sound, Alternative Press, and more, the group wave off darkness
with unassuming confidence and clarity on Swan Song ignited by the single “Face Me.”
THE ONE YOU LOVED
The Plot in You Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
The night that I just spilled my soul?
I told you things about myself
Things that no one else should know
You see the thoughts behind my eyes
You try to ask but you don't pry
We feel the same but we don't speak
There's always some form of excuse
There's nothing left for me to prove
I try to hold on cause you know
I hate to lose
What happened to the one I loved?
Was the change in me not strong enough?
Was it something else?
'Cause I tried my best
What happened to the one I loved?
Was the sober me not good enough?
Is there someone else?
I can't get through to you
I can't get out of my head
Time with you is what I dread
When it's you and me, apparently
I don't seem to phase you, so I chase you
Just to be shot down, I never break through
All these fucked up restless nights
Always haunt my sleepless mind
Only trying to survive
But you won't even look me in my eyes
Always some form of excuse
There's nothing left for me to prove
I tried to hold on but I know
I need to lose
What happened to the one I loved?
Was the change in me not strong enough?
Was it something else?
'Cause I tried my best
What happened to the one I loved?
Was the sober me not good enough?
Is there someone else?
I can't get through to you
I start to think out loud
And with every sound, she breaks
With a shattered soul
She was the black hole when I roamed space
When I roamed space
What happened to the one I loved?
Was the sober me not good enough?
Was it something else?
'Cause I tried my best
What happened to the one I loved?
Was the sober me not strong enough?
Is it something else?
I can't get through to you
What happened to the one I loved?
Was the change in me not strong enough?
Was it something else?
'Cause I tried my best
What happened to the one I loved?
Was the sober me not good enough?
Is there someone else?
I can't get through to you
What happened to the one I loved?
Was the change in me not strong enough?
Was it something else?
'Cause I tried my best
What happened to the one I loved?
Was the sober me not good enough?
Is there someone else?
I can't get through to you
Is there someone else?
I can't get through to you
The Plot In You's song "The One You Loved" is about the complexities of a relationship and the struggles of trying to keep it alive. The song is an emotional plea from the singer, who is trying to figure out what went wrong and why the person they love is slipping away. The opening lines suggest that the singer had opened up to their loved one, revealing intimate details about themselves that no one else knew. Despite this vulnerability, the relationship seems to be faltering and the loved one is becoming increasingly distant.
The lines "We feel the same but we don't speak / And you cannot make up your mind" suggest that the singer feels like they are on the same page as their loved one, but there is a communication breakdown that is preventing the relationship from moving forward. The singer is trying to hold on, but it seems like their efforts are in vain. They ask "what happened to the one I loved?" and wonder if the change in them was not strong enough or if there is someone else in the picture.
The chorus repeats this sentiment and adds to it, asking if the sober version of the singer wasn't "good enough" and if there is "someone else" that is getting in the way of the relationship. The mood of the song turns more despondent towards the end with lines like "With a shattered soul / She was the black hole when I roamed space" suggesting the singer feels unhappy, unloved and is losing hope. Despite their pleas to understand what happened, the singer can't seem to get through to the loved one.
Line by Line Meaning
Do you remember what I said
Asking if the person remembers a conversation they had earlier
The night that I just spilled my soul?
Referring to a time when they were emotionally vulnerable
I told you things about myself
Sharing personal information
Things that no one else should know
Saying that the information was confidential
You see the thoughts behind my eyes
Implying that the other person can read their emotions
You try to ask but you don't pry
Suggesting that the other person respects their privacy
We feel the same but we don't speak
Both experiencing a similar emotion but not talking about it
And you cannot make up your mind
The other person is indecisive
There's always some form of excuse
The other person is constantly giving excuses
There's nothing left for me to prove
Feeling as though they've done all they can
I try to hold on cause you know
Trying to maintain the relationship
I hate to lose
Dreading the possibility of the relationship ending
What happened to the one I loved?
Questioning how the person they loved has changed
Was the change in me not strong enough?
Wondering if their personal changes weren't enough to keep the relationship going
Was it something else?
Questioning if there were other factors at play
'Cause I tried my best
Asserting that they did everything they could
Is there someone else?
Wondering if the other person is interested in someone else
I can't get through to you
Feeling like the other person is emotionally unavailable
I can't get out of my head
Caught up in their own thoughts and emotions
Time with you is what I dread
Not enjoying spending time with the other person
When it's you and me, apparently
Suggesting that the other person does not see the issues in their relationship
I don't seem to phase you, so I chase you
Feeling like they have to constantly pursue the other person's attention and affection
Just to be shot down, I never break through
Feeling like their efforts are always rejected
All these fucked up restless nights
Describing their emotional state
Always haunt my sleepless mind
Feeling like they can't escape their thoughts
Only trying to survive
Struggling to get through the emotional turmoil
But you won't even look me in my eyes
Feeling ignored by the other person
I start to think out loud
Saying things they've been keeping to themselves
And with every sound, she breaks
Suggesting that the other person becomes upset with what they're saying
With a shattered soul
The other person is emotionally broken
She was the black hole when I roamed space
Suggesting that the other person was the only thing holding them together
Was the sober me not good enough?
Questioning if the other person only likes them when they're under the influence
I need to lose
Understanding that the relationship is not working and it's time to move on
Is it something else?
Questioning if there are other factors at play in why the relationship is failing
Is there someone else?
Wondering if the other person is interested in someone else
I can't get through to you
Feeling like the other person is emotionally unavailable
Lyrics © BMG Rights Management
Written by: Josh Childress, Landon Tewers, Marlon Mathis
Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind