So Says I
The Shins Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

An address to the golden door
I was strumming on a stone again
Pulling teeth from the pimps of gore
When hatched a tragic opera in my mind
And it told of a new design in which every soul is duty bound
To uphold all the statutes of boredom
Therein lies the fatal flaw of the red age
'Cause it was nothing like we'd ever dreamt
Our lust for life had gone away with the rent we hated
'Cause it made no money, nobody saved no one's life this time

So we burned all our uniforms
And let nature take its course again
And the big ones just eat all the little ones
That sends us back to the drawing board

In our darkest hours
We have all asked for some
Angel to come
Sprinkle his dust all around
But all our crying voices they can't turn it around
And you've had some crazy conversations of your own

We've got rules and maps and guns in our backs
But we still can't just behave ourselves
Even if to save our own lives
So says I
We are a brutal kind, whoa

'Cause this is nothing like we'd ever dreamt
Tell Sir Thomas More we've got another failed attempt




'Cause if it makes them money
They might just give you life this time

Overall Meaning

The Shins' "So Says I" is a song that tackles the issues of conformity, societal pressure, and expectations. James Mercer, the lead singer and the songwriter of the band, uses vivid and metaphorical imagery to convey the message of the track. The first verse sets the tone of the song, with the "address to the golden door" that symbolizes the American Dream, where every individual is supposed to have equal opportunities, but in reality, it is just a façade. He talks about strumming on a stone again, which is a metaphor for being stuck in a difficult situation.


The second verse talks about burning all the uniforms and letting nature take its course again. It highlights the natural inclination towards survival, where the big ones eat the little ones, and the whole cycle of life and death restarts again. The lyrics capture the inevitability of life's harsh realities and how it sends us back to the drawing board. Mercer then captures the futility of hope when he speaks of our darkest hours and how we wish for someone to come and sprinkle their dust around. He concludes that even in our desperation, we are unable to turn things around, and we are a "brutal kind."


The chorus is an indictment of the system that created and sustains us. The rules, maps, and guns symbolize the law and order enforced by the state, but even that cannot make us "behave ourselves." The song ends with a reference to Sir Thomas More and how the society he envisioned has been another failed attempt as long as money is the driving force behind things. Overall, the song is a powerful critique of society's ills that strip us of our humanity and our true potential.


Line by Line Meaning

An address to the golden door
A reference to a new opportunity or venture, possibly with great potential.


I was strumming on a stone again
Feeling stagnant and unproductive, lacking inspiration or purpose.


Pulling teeth from the pimps of gore
Struggling to extract something valuable or worthwhile from something unpleasant or undesirable.


When hatched a tragic opera in my mind
When a troubling or distressing idea occurred to me, taking on a dramatic or operatic quality.


And it told of a new design in which every soul is duty bound
The idea suggested a new paradigm or societal structure in which everyone has a responsibility to uphold certain rules or regulations.


To uphold all the statutes of boredom
To conform to a mundane, monotonous way of life or routine.


Therein lies the fatal flaw of the red age
This adherence to boredom and conformity is what ultimately leads to societal downfall or collapse.


'Cause it was nothing like we'd ever dreamt
What we ended up with was vastly different than what we had hoped for or envisioned.


Our lust for life had gone away with the rent we hated
Our desire to live passionately or fully had been replaced by the burden of financial obligations or struggle.


'Cause it made no money, nobody saved no one's life this time
The societal structure or system being followed failed to create financial success or save anyone from harm or danger.


So we burned all our uniforms
We rejected the system or roles we had been forced into.


And let nature take its course again
We allowed ourselves to be guided by our instincts and natural inclinations.


And the big ones just eat all the little ones
Those who have more power or success tend to dominate or exploit those who are weaker or less fortunate.


That sends us back to the drawing board
This realization forces us to reevaluate our approach or strategy.


In our darkest hours
During our most difficult or trying times.


We have all asked for some
We have all wished for some external force or intervention.


Angel to come
To come and provide guidance or relief.


Sprinkle his dust all around
To bring positive energy or influence to the situation.


But all our crying voices they can't turn it around
Our appeals or cries for help are not enough to change the situation or outcome on their own.


And you've had some crazy conversations of your own
You have likely experienced or contemplated similar difficulties or challenges.


We've got rules and maps and guns in our backs
We are controlled or oppressed by societal norms, regulations, and systems that are enforced through violent means.


But we still can't just behave ourselves
Even with these limitations and restrictions, we are unable or unwilling to follow them completely.


Even if to save our own lives
Despite the fact that following these rules could potentially save us from harm or danger.


So says I
This is what I believe to be true or accurate.


We are a brutal kind, whoa
Humans by nature are often aggressive, harsh, or unforgiving.


'Cause this is nothing like we'd ever dreamt
Once again emphasizing the discrepancy between our expectations and reality.


Tell Sir Thomas More we've got another failed attempt
Referencing the failed attempt to create a Utopian society in Thomas More's book 'Utopia', suggesting that our attempts at societal improvement are similarly doomed to fail.


'Cause if it makes them money
If a certain approach or system generates financial profit or success.


They might just give you life this time
There is a chance that those with power or influence will grant us success or survival if we follow their rules or expectations.




Lyrics © O/B/O APRA AMCOS
Written by: James Mercer

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comments from YouTube:

@coatzel21

An address to the golden door
I was strumming on a stone again,
Pulling teeth from the pimps of gore
When hatched a tragic opera in my mind,
And it told of a new design in which every soul is duty bound
To uphold all the statutes of boredom
Therein lies the fatal flaw of the red age

Because it was nothing like we'd ever dreamt
Or lust for life had gone away with the rent we hated
And becase it made no money nobody saved no one's life this time

So we burned all our uniforms
And let nature take it's course again
And the big onese just eat all the little ones
That sends us back to the drawing board

In my darkest hours
We have all asked for some
Angel to come
Sprinkle his dust all around
But all our crying voices they can't turn it around
And you've had some crazy conversations of your own

We've got rules and maps and guns in our backs but we still can't just behave ourselves,
Even if to save our own lives
So says I:
We are a brutal kind

'Cause this is nothing like we'd ever dreamt
Tell Sir Thomas More we've got another failed attempt
'Cause if it makes them money they might just give you life this time



@croutendo2050

"Our lust for life had gone away with the rent we hated"

and

"Tell Sir Thomas Moore we've got another failed attempt"

and

"We've got rules and maps and guns in our backs but we still can't just behave ourselves"

and I could go on, but honestly the song is full of gems lol, so I'd just be reposting the full lyrics



All comments from YouTube:

@makenziehofacker8378

Finally found this song!! Every time I heard it on Gilmore Girls I'd replay it over and over :D LOOOOVE IT

@natalyrodriguez350

Yesssssss

@MinjaSamardzicMusic

me too xD

@leilahojat6017

Makenzie Hofacker I am here for the same reason!!! 😍😍😍 I Adore it!!!

@roriesheets4403

S4:E17

19:29

@clairebear7936

Me too!

47 More Replies...

@bunnielovem3328

2022 still watching Gilmore Girls and loving this classic song!

@Carrilyyn

Yessss!!!!

@noiirrecleorr

i found it on gilmore girls too but todayyyy

@gabrieladuarte4311

thank you gilmore girls for introducing me to this good music

More Comments

More Versions