ThouShaltNot have built strong fanbases through their national tours and their work with acts such as The Dresden Dolls, VNV Nation, Alphaville and David J (of Bauhaus). Their club hits "Cardinal Directions," "Without Faith," "Last Comfort," and "Inside of You, In Spite of You," have been played at nearly every dark alternative and goth venue in America, while their more organic "True Love" and "When Everyone Forgets" have appeared to acclaim on high profile compilations that exceed the limits of genre.
ThouShaltNot's music, throughout its thoughtful subject matter, is hook-laden and complex in its emotional and intellectual architecture. With their latest releases, Land Dispute and the New World EP, ThouShaltNot is poised to change the way you think and feel about music.
The band consists of: Alex Reed (vocals, keyboards, guitars, programming, samples), Aaron Fuleki (percussion, programming, samples, guitars, backing vocals) and Jeremy David (guitars, backing vocals, piano, keyboards, programming).
True Love
ThouShaltNot Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
The door closing silent behind you
I smile and I offer you something to drink
In the hopes that a taste will remind you
That poison goes better with grenadine
That deceit's always lovely with lime
That bitterness can be so sweet when it's served
And we'll toast to a lifetime of happiness
And we'll catch up on mutual friends
And we'll laugh with good cheer and not mention that we're
Just a means to each of our ends
And by midnight you'll be so convinced
That all of our time apart was some mistake
Then I'll sigh and I'll stand and I'll hold out my hand
Once more for your memory's sake
I'll hold you, my love, and never let go
I'll hold you, my love, and I'll never tire
I'll hold you, my love, by the throat
I'll hold you, my love, over the fire
So breathe with me, love, only love will work now
Hold onto my love like it was stolen
I'll burn with your love like I was Birkenau
I'll conquer your love like you were Poland
I'll act on my love like Pontius Pilate
I'll give you my love like I was Brutus
I'll radiate love like Three Mile Island
I'll prove you my love like I was Judas
The lyrics of ThouShaltNot's song True Love speaks of a villain in a love story. The singer expresses deceit and bitterness towards his love interest by offering poison with grenadine and deceit with lime, indicating that their relationship has aspects of manipulation and dishonesty. Despite this, they toast to a lifetime of happiness, catch up on mutual friends, and laugh with good cheer while masking their true intentions.
As the night progresses, the singer plans to hold their love interest, both metaphorically and physically, by the throat over the fire. The lyrics take a dark turn as they reference Birkenau, Poland, Pontius Pilate, Brutus, Three Mile Island, and Judas to express the extent of their intensity and dedication to their love. The final lines suggest that the singer's love is dangerous, powerful, and ultimately destructive.
This song presents an interesting exploration of love that is not pure and genuine but rather manipulative and dark. It is a unique take on love as typically portrayed in mainstream media, highlighting the complexity and intensity of human emotions.
Line by Line Meaning
In walks the villain of this tale
Someone who is considered bad or evil has entered the story being told
The door closing silent behind you
The door shuts with no sound after the person enters the room
I smile and I offer you something to drink
The singer greets the person and gives them a beverage
In the hopes that a taste will remind you
The artist wants the person to remember something after tasting the drink
That poison goes better with grenadine
The person prefers things that are harmful to them and don't realize it
That deceit's always lovely with lime
Lies can be disguised and sweetened to make them more appealing
That bitterness can be so sweet when it's served
Negative actions can be more pleasurable when executed at the right time and place
And we'll toast to a lifetime of happiness
The artist raises a glass to congratulate the person on a happy life
And we'll catch up on mutual friends
The two will talk about people they know and haven't seen in a while
And we'll laugh with good cheer and not mention that we're
The artist and the person are having a good time together but don't acknowledge their underlying motives
Just a means to each of our ends
Both people are using the other to get what they want
And by midnight you'll be so convinced
Before the night is over, the person will be persuaded to agree with the artist
That all of our time apart was some mistake
The time they spent apart was wasted and they should have been together
Then I'll sigh and I'll stand and I'll hold out my hand
The singer will dramatically reach out to the person in a way to portray love and emotion
Once more for your memory's sake
The singer wants the person to remember the moment they shared and use it for future dealings
I'll hold you, my love, and never let go
The artist holds the person close and doesn't want to let them go
I'll hold you, my love, and I'll never tire
The artist will continue to cling onto the person with no end
I'll hold you, my love, by the throat
The singer will control and grip onto the person tightly
I'll hold you, my love, over the fire
The singer is willing to take risks and put the person in danger to keep them close
So breathe with me, love, only love will work now
The artist implies that the person has to follow what they say, in order for love to function properly
Hold onto my love like it was stolen
The person should hold onto the artist and not let go, as if someone was trying to steal them
I'll burn with your love like I was Birkenau
The artist's love is extreme and intense, like the emotions felt by prisoners in Birkenau concentration camp
I'll conquer your love like you were Poland
The singer wants control over the person's love, as if they are a country to be taken over
I'll act on my love like Pontius Pilate
The artist is willing to act cruelly or with violence in the name of love
I'll give you my love like I was Brutus
The singer's love is powerful and could cause harm or betrayal, similarly to Brutus' actions towards Julius Caesar
I'll radiate love like Three Mile Island
The singer's love is powerful and intense, like the radiation from the Three Mile Island nuclear accident
I'll prove you my love like I was Judas
The singer will do something extreme to prove their love, including betraying the person they love like Judas did to Jesus
Contributed by Christian C. Suggest a correction in the comments below.