Red Is the Rose
Tommy Makem Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Come over the hills my bonny Irish lass
Come over the hills to your darling
You choose the road love and I'll make a vow
That I'll be your true love forever

[Chorus]
Red is the rose that in yonder garden grows
Fair is the lily of the valley
Clear is the water that flows from the Boyne
But my love is fairer than any

It's down in Killarney's green woods that we strayed
When the moon and the stars, they were shining
For the moon shone its rays on her locks of golden hair
And she said she'd be my love forever

[Chorus]

It's not for the parting with my sister Kate
It's not for the grief of my mother




It's all for the loss of my bonny Irish lass
That my heart is breaking forever

Overall Meaning

Tommy Makem & Liam Clancy's song "Red Is The Rose" is a romantic and sentimental song that expresses a deep love and longing for an Irish girl. The song starts with an invitation to the girl to come over the hills to meet her lover. He promises to be her true love forever if she chooses to do so. The chorus of the song compares the beauty of nature around them to the beauty of the girl. Red is the rose that grows in the garden, fair is the lily of the valley, clear is the water that flows from the Boyne, but the girl is fairer than any of these. The lyrics celebrate the beauty of Ireland's nature and culture, but make it clear that it is the girl who truly captures the heart of the singer.


The second verse of the song recalls a romantic walk they took together in Killarney's green woods, under the shining moon and stars. The girl's golden hair shone in the moonlight, and she promised to be his love forever. The song paints a picture of a beautiful, romantic and nostalgic moment, although we don't know why they are separated or if they have the chance to reunite again.


In the last verse, the singer reveals that he is heartbroken, but his sadness is not because of the loss of a family member, but of the girl he loved. The song clearly conveys the deep affection and longing that he feels for her, and how much he is suffering from her absence.


Line by Line Meaning

Come over the hills my bonny Irish lass
I urge you to traverse these hills and come to me, my sweet Irish lady


Come over the hills to your darling
Journey towards your beloved; I am eagerly waiting for you to arrive


You choose the road love and I'll make a vow
You can choose any path you wish, my love; I promise to always be true to you


That I'll be your true love forever
I pledge to love you faithfully for eternity


[Chorus] Red is the rose that in yonder garden grows
The rose in that distant garden is crimson in hue


Fair is the lily of the valley
The delicate flower known as the lily of the valley is beautiful


Clear is the water that flows from the Boyne
The river Boyne possesses crystal clear water


But my love is fairer than any
However, you, my beloved, surpass all of these other beauties in grace and charm


It's down in Killarney's green woods that we strayed
We once promenaded through the lush forests of Killarney


When the moon and the stars, they were shining
It was during a night when the skies were illuminated by celestial bodies


For the moon shone its rays on her locks of golden hair
The moon's light illuminated the soft golden locks of her hair


And she said she'd be my love forever
My darling promised to love me eternally


[Chorus] Red is the rose that in yonder garden grows
The rose in that distant garden is crimson in hue


It's not for the parting with my sister Kate
The reason for my sorrow is not due to parting from my sister Kate


It's not for the grief of my mother
Nor is it because of the pain caused by my mother's suffering


It's all for the loss of my bonny Irish lass
The devastation in my heart is solely due to losing my lovely Irish lady


That my heart is breaking forever
My heart is shattered and will never fully heal




Lyrics ยฉ O/B/O APRA AMCOS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comment from YouTube:

@j.s.connolly8579

WOW! YOU Sound like You are from Milwaukee or something? I've not only seen them MANY MANY Times at our Milwaukee Irish Fest, but My parents and I got to meet them at Irish Fest of 1983. I had JUST Graduated High School that year and Things were SO GOOD back then!
Over the years I got to be friends with them and was ALWAYS Greeted with a Hug and Kiss and Smiles!

The Year my Mom passed away... The Clancy Brothers and Tommy came to Irish Fest. My dad didn't want to go because he was in SO MUCH PAIN!
But I said, "Dad... Mom would want us to go and have fun and remember her. SO this weekend is on ME! ALL OF IT! Food, Drinks EVERYTHING!"
We also called my brother Kevin up and asked him to join us and to OUR Surprise he did!
My brother is kind of "Stiff" when it comes to family stuff!

Well when I said that he broke down and cried... but agreed. So we went. And as Always I had my Bodhran in hand and My Dad had a few of his FAV Harmonicas with him! My second oldest sister had died in August of 1985. So it was doubly painful that year!

On the Saturday Night of Irish Fest, We ran into Liam and Tommy and they as I said greeted us with Hugs and Kisses and smiles. But then asked were mom was and we told them what happened with both her AND my sister, and both got very choked up! So They said, "Well then Lads... PLEASE Come and Join us and my brothers at the Park East Hotel tonight and we will Raise our Glasses and Voices to the their memory!"

Well we couldn't refuse THAT Invitation! So we went... And JUST LIKE On an Album cover... THERE THEY WERE! In a Snug in the corner of the "Piano Bar Floor" and when Liam saw us he Invited us over and Introduced us to Pat and Big Tom Clancy! And in no time at all... it was like being with family!

We were Singing and Playing and drinking and laughing and crying and doing it over and over again! It was an AMAZING NIGHT!

We Sang and Drank and Played until about... 2 or 3 in the morning. When the glasses were almost empty and everyone was tired... I had my glass still half full of Guinness and I stood up on a chair and said a toast to my Mom and my two sisters who were gone. Then I started to sing "Will Ye Go Lassie Go" and then Finished with "The Parting Glass"! It was the PERFECT ENDING to a PERFECT NIGHT!
So we said our good byes and looked forward to seeing them the next day at their shows and for the "Scattering"!

Well... seeing as I drank MUCH Less then my Dad or brother did, I drove us home, and the entire way home they BOTH couldn't stop thanking me for the "good idea of going".

That was a BEYOND INCREDIBLE Night as I had grown up with The Clancy Brothers and Tommy Makem and My Dad and I would play their albums Not JUST On St. Patrick's Day but other times too. And until My Dad discovered The Chieftains and other Great Traditional Celtic Music THAT WAS "IRISH MUSIC" in our house! It was ONLY JUST Before "Irish Fest" started in 1981 that we had our "Irish Music" culture expanded and thankfully it has continued since!

But THESE LADS... Will NEVER EVER BE FORGOTTEN!!!

EVER!!!

UP THE REPUBLIC!!!

Slante.

Joe Connolly
Jefferson, Wisconsin



All comments from YouTube:

@cliffbortmes4573

Love this song, Iโ€™m 67 years old and have been listening to the Clancy Brothers and Tommy Makem since I was about 12 years old.

@theinfinit1529

I'm 14, but have been listening to their music my whole life. It's beautiful.

@MRMK24

We miss you boys, we miss you always, your music flows though every inch of our green land๐Ÿ’”๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ช

@garryflanagan5809

Respect

@garryflanagan5809

The Green Heart Will Never Be Broken

@cathgee704

@@garryflanagan5809 of

@Fpstup

I miss my home and my late mother ๐Ÿ˜ข

@MRMK24

@@Fpstup you should come back to visit, for old times sake ๐Ÿ˜Œ it'll always be your home, no matter where in the world you go.

3 More Replies...

@VictoriaBlogger

So beautiful and peaceful ... I really like the way Liam draws out the words in the phrase "Come over the hill, my bonnie Irish lass", rather than chopping off the word "lass" the way the High Kings do. It feels much more tender, more gentle. I love all the rowdy songs, but when Makem and Clancy start singing these sweet love songs, I just get all mushy inside!

@jamesdolan4042

Bob Dylan held Liam Clancy in high regard as a singer of ballads, and as a nine string guitar player, so you are in good company and your views are entirely valid.

More Comments

More Versions