A Good Song
Valdy Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

I am not a free man
But neither am I chained
I am not a wise man
But neither am I rearranged
I am not a new man
But neither am I old
I am not a rich man
But neither can i be seold

I am one
You are another
I have a family
You have mother

And I am not a good man
But neither am I cruel
I am not a learned man
But neither am I a fool
I am not an ordinary man
But neither am I strange
I am not your man
But that can all be changed





No, I am not your man
But that can all be changed

Overall Meaning

The lyrics to Valdy's song "A Good Song" are a reflection of the complexity and duality that exists within each one of us. The artist talks about how he is not a free man, but neither is he chained. This could mean that he acknowledges that he has responsibility and obligations, but at the same time, he has the freedom to make decisions and actions that can shape his life.


The artist also says that he is not a wise man, but neither is he rearranged. This could mean that he is not perfect, but he has also not lost himself in the quest for knowledge or validation from others. He is comfortable with who he is and does not need to change himself to fit into any mold.


Valdy goes on to say that he is not a good man, but neither is he cruel. This line speaks to the fact that we all have flaws and that no one is inherently good or bad. Valdy acknowledges this and puts forth that he is not a learned man, but neither is he a fool, reflecting that he has knowledge but has not let it define who he is.


The artist then talks about how he is not an ordinary man, but neither is he strange. This could mean that he is unique in his own way and he is not afraid to show it, but at the same time, he is not so different that he cannot connect with others. This line also highlights how we are all unique individuals with our own stories, struggles, and successes.


Finally, Valdy sings "I am not your man, but that can all be changed." Here, he acknowledges that he may not have a particular connection with the listener, but there is always room for that to change. This line also puts forth the idea that it is never too late to connect with someone or to change oneself.


Line by Line Meaning

I am not a free man
I am not completely unrestricted in my actions or decisions


But neither am I chained
But I am not completely restrained or imprisoned


I am not a wise man
I do not have exceptional knowledge or discernment


But neither am I rearranged
But I am not mentally disordered or unbalanced


I am not a new man
I am not recently formed or developed


But neither am I old
But I am not ancient or outdated


I am not a rich man
I do not have great wealth or resources


But neither can I be sold
But I am not easily influenced or controlled by money


I am one
I am an individual


You are another
You are a separate individual


I have a family
I have people who are related to me


You have a mother
You have a female parent


And I am not a good man
I am not morally excellent or virtuous


But neither am I cruel
But I am not deliberately harmful or malicious


I am not a learned man
I am not highly educated or knowledgeable


But neither am I a fool
But I am not an unintelligent or foolish person


I am not an ordinary man
I am not a common or average person


But neither am I strange
But I am not unusual or unfamiliar


I am not your man
I am not specifically committed to you


But that can all be changed
But my level of commitment to you can be altered or amended


No, I am not your man
No, I am not specifically committed to you


But that can all be changed
But my level of commitment to you can be altered or amended




Contributed by Jeremiah B. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@joshfarrell377

3 generations of my family have listened to Valdy, I have my dad's original Country Man album (now retired with the purchase of a replacement)the less seen one of him down on his knee. Great memories now my old man is gone. Get a lump in my throat hearing this song

@toddtrojek6521

One great thing about youtube are the numerous videos of Canadians we have in this great country. Also it reminds us folks of some talented people like Valdy I have myself forgotten the last few years. But! Valdy how could I forget him? Oh well! Cheers to Valdy!

@loumuzzin4422

I met Valdy at St Patrick High School in Ottawa in September 1964. I was 19 and just beginning university, he was leaving to go "out West" that week. We jammed, me playing the harmonica, he and several others playing guitars. I distinctly remember playing Four Strong Winds and Yellow Bird. About 25 years later our band opened a concert for him at the Tecumseh Corn Festival. He remembered the St Pat's jam and my friend Doug that brought me there. He was already a star and a legend by then but very friendly and approachable and a superb entertainer.
That jam in '64 and Valdy changed my life because I bought a guitar soon after that and Doug got me started playing it and now, 55 years later, I'm still at it and music is a huge part of my life. Thanks Valdy!

@marshawilson4338

One of my all time favourite songs! Valdy, you are the BEST!

@allan8371

Thanks Valdy. Been a fan for going on 45 years and will continue to be a fan. Peace.

@gerryyee2638

Absolutely timeless Music that puts me in a great mood even after these years. Thanks Valdy.

@MrLesonfireforGod

When I was a child and would visit my father at his house he had no TV in the living room and would play only a few of his albums while we were all working around the house. "Family Gathering" was one of them. I later bought a few Valdy albums of my own and saw him twice in the early 1980's. My two favourite Valdy songs are 'Renaissance' and one called 'Movie Scene', which was a b cut and not a radio hit. I just bought the Classic Collection CD and am listening to 'Hometwon Band' as I write this.

@terryanderson1488

beautiful man beautiful character beautiful song  I could listen to Valdy all evening... I love the fluent guitar work.

@barenakedonion

Love Valdy and he is a True Canadian. Underrated as far as the Canadian Music Industry goes

@dalem8332

Love this song! Love Valdys music! Had the pleasure of seeing him 5 times live over the years. Fabulous entertainer! Part of my life musically growing up. ♥️🎼🎶🎵🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦

More Comments

More Versions