IF I DIDN'T KNOW BETTER
luther's Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

I think sometimes I can read your mind
When you make things up I can tell you lie
I see the things that your man can't see
And I wonder what kind of man is he
The one who you say is your lover
Who you insist takes care of you under the covers
And who is there for you and loves you like no other
Then you kiss and tell me that you love me like a brother

[Chorus]
If I didn't know better
I'd think that you were mine, you're with me all the time
If I didn't know better
I'd swear we're more than friends, you're touching me again
If I didn't know better
I'd think we were in love
Girl, do you want to tell me something
Oh, oh, oh
I could be wrong about the things you say
But I don't rub up on my friends that way
You tell me that you've always been a flirt
But if it goes wrong, I could get hurt
But no, you insist it's harmless playin'
It's just a part of who you are, that it's just your nature
And that it's fine
You know I'm a friend, it's really nothing
You say that I'm just like a
That I'm just like a brother

[Chorus]

My idea of a friend is when you
Do a lotta things together and have a lotta fun
But my definition of love is different
You touch and hold each other
And you only want to be alone clinging to each other
Like you and he should be, but like you and I are
Well, I know it sounds crazy but

[Chorus]

Overall Meaning

In Luther Vandross's song "If I Didn't Know Better," the lyrics present the story of a man who suspects a woman he is close to of having deeper feelings for him, despite being in a committed relationship with another man. The opening lines suggest that this man has an almost psychic intuition about the woman's thoughts and feelings, certain that she is lying to her partner but not to him. He is able to see things in her that her partner cannot, which leads him to question the other man's ability to care for her properly. Despite this, she repeatedly insists that he is just a friend, like a brother to her.


In the chorus, the man reveals that he is grappling with his feelings for her and that he thinks they might be more than just friends. He acknowledges that he may be misinterpreting her behavior, but he is confused by the way in which she touches him and seems to always want to be near him. He is torn between the idea that he might be wrong about her intentions and the warning that he could get hurt if he continues to invest emotionally and physically in their relationship. The final verse compares how the man understands the distinctions between friend and lover, emphasizing that love requires touch and intimacy, whereas friendship does not.


Overall, the lyrics of "If I Didn't Know Better" are a painful exploration of unrequited love and the blurry line between friendship and romance. It speaks to the ways in which affection between friends can shift and evolve over time and the sometimes disastrous consequences of misreading those signals.


Line by Line Meaning

I think sometimes I can read your mind
I feel like I understand you so well that I can anticipate your thoughts and actions.


When you make things up I can tell you lie
I'm able to sense when you're not telling the truth, even when you aren't transparent about it.


I see the things that your man can't see
I notice aspects of you that your partner overlooks or fails to appreciate.


And I wonder what kind of man is he
I question the worthiness of your significant other, given that he doesn't seem to recognize your true value.


The one who you say is your lover
I'm referring to the person you claim to be in a romantic relationship with.


Who you insist takes care of you under the covers
You maintain that this guy is great in bed and provides you with emotional support.


And who is there for you and loves you like no other
You assert that he is the only person who truly loves and cherishes you.


Then you kiss and tell me that you love me like a brother
Despite your supposed loyalty to your partner, you've demonstrated romantic/sexual feelings toward me in a way that contradicts your initial statements.


If I didn't know better
If I were naive or oblivious to your true intentions,


I'd think that you were mine, you're with me all the time
I'd assume we were a couple, due to the amount of time we spend together.


I'd swear we're more than friends, you're touching me again
I'd conclude that our relationship is more than platonic, especially since you've initiated physical contact.


I'd think we were in love
I'd believe we're romantically entangled, even though I'm aware that you have a partner.


Girl, do you want to tell me something
I'm giving you the chance to be honest about your true feelings toward me or your partner.


I could be wrong about the things you say
I acknowledge that there's a possibility that I'm misunderstand your motivations or intentions.


But I don't rub up on my friends that way
I don't engage in physical contact with my friends that could be interpreted as romantic or sexual.


You tell me that you've always been a flirt
You've explained that you behave in a flirtatious manner with many people, not just me.


But if it goes wrong, I could get hurt
However, if your flirtation turns into something more significant, I may suffer emotional harm.


But no, you insist it's harmless playin'
Despite my concerns, you assure me that your actions have no deeper significance and should be interpreted as benign.


It's just a part of who you are, that it's just your nature
You suggest that you cannot help yourself and that this form of expression is simply part of your personality or character.


And that it's fine
You tell me that there's no issue with your behavior and that I should not be concerned.


You know I'm a friend, it's really nothing
You emphasize that I'm a strictly platonic connection in your life, and that our interactions are inconsequential.


You say that I'm just like a
You are comparing me to someone else who is important to you (but leave it unfinished).


That I'm just like a brother
You conclude that I am like a close relative or family member in your life, but this seems to contradict your earlier behavior.


My idea of a friend is when you
I'm defining my vision of a healthy and fun friendship - one that doesn't have elements of romantic attraction or sexual tension.


Do a lotta things together and have a lotta fun
Friendship, to me, involves shared interests, activities, and good times, but does not necessarily progress past this point.


But my definition of love is different
In contrast, my opinion of love is more emotionally and physically intimate.


You touch and hold each other
Love involves physical contact, such as hugging, holding hands, or cuddling.


And you only want to be alone clinging to each other
Individuals in love seek privacy and seek to cling to each other, wanting to be together as much as possible.


Like you and he should be, but like you and I are
You and I seem to display traits of a romantic couple, even though you are in a relationship with somebody else.


Well, I know it sounds crazy but
I acknowledge that my beliefs may seem strange or unlikely.




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management, Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC
Written by: EZEKIEL LEWIS, LUTHER VANDROSS, REED PHILIP VERTELNEY

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions