Black
Bonnie 'Prince' Billy Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

[Chorus]
Black, you are my enemy
And I cannot get close to thee
Our life is ruled by enmity
And I can't weaken that
The only way that I can see
Is to hold you close to me
To love you for it's meant to be
I weaken your attack

Everything was lucked and downy
What was good was up from under
Until black, that awful tender
Came and popped my sense of wonder
All at once all eyes turned at him
Leaving me an unwatched body
And it sagged, my body's rib cage
Out from under ogler's study
Black was decomposing quickly
This was found offensive to me
His disrespect for life's proprieties
Made me scared he would destroy me

[Chorus]

So I thought I'd try to cut him
Try to force him 'neath my level
The only way to equal to him
Would be hit him with a shovel
But to really rise above him
That would be the final evil
So instead I asked the sucker
If he'd care to see my rooms
And as a friend and as a comrade
And all the things that these implied
I made him leave what it was that he had
Used to keep us unallied

Black, you are my enemy
And I cannot get close to thee
Our life is ruled by enmity
And I can't weaken that
The only way that I can see
Is to hold you close to me
To love you for it's meant to be
I weaken your attack

Now black and I we are together
Fairly just inseparable
And in the terriblest of weather
Our bonds are incorruptible





[Chorus]

Overall Meaning

The song "Black" by Bonnie 'Prince' Billy is a melancholic reflection on the value of enmity and how it can be overcome by love. The chorus reveals the singer's inner turmoil and desire to hold on to something that is meant to be, but cannot be attained: "Black, you are my enemy / And I cannot get close to thee / Our life is ruled by enmity / And I can't weaken that / The only way that I can see / Is to hold you close to me / To love you for what it's meant to be / I weaken your attack." The song's main narrative revolves around the singer's reaction to a force called "black," which is presented in the first stanza as a destructive entity that has destabilized his "sense of wonder."


The second stanza shows the singer's attempts to neutralize black by cutting him or smashing him with a shovel, but ultimately he chooses to invite him to his home as a friend and comrade. This signifies his recognition of black as a part of him he cannot simply eliminate, but has to come to terms with. The last verse reveals that the singer and black have become inseparable in the face of adversity, suggesting that through love, one can overcome even the most powerful obstacles: "Now black and I we are together / Fairly just inseparable / And in the terriblest of weather / Our bonds are incorruptible."


Overall, Bonnie 'Prince' Billy's song "Black" is a poignant and introspective meditation on the nature of enmity, its pervasiveness in our lives, and the possibility of overcoming it through love and acceptance.


Line by Line Meaning

Black, you are my enemy
The singer considers black as their enemy


And I cannot get close to thee
The singer has an inability to get close to black


Our life is ruled by enmity
The relationship between the singer and black is governed by enmity


And I can't weaken that
The artist is unable to weaken this enmity


The only way that I can see
The artist sees only one way


Is to hold you close to me
The singer's strategy is to embrace black


To love you for it's meant to be
They intend to love black because it's destined to be


I weaken your attack
This strategy will weaken black's attack


Everything was lucked and downy
Life was comfortable and worry-free


What was good was up from under
Good things came unexpectedly


Until black, that awful tender
Until black appeared and ruined the singer's sense of wonder


Came and popped my sense of wonder
Black destroyed the artist's sense of wonder


All at once all eyes turned at him
Everyone's attention shifted to black


Leaving me an unwatched body
The singer felt ignored


And it sagged, my body's rib cage
The singer felt physically deflated


Out from under ogler's study
Out from under the scrutiny of onlookers


Black was decomposing quickly
Black was deteriorating rapidly


This was found offensive to me
The singer found this offensive


His disrespect for life's proprieties
Black's disregard for the rules of life


Made me scared he would destroy me
The artist feared that black would destroy them


[Chorus]
Repetition of the earlier chorus


So I thought I'd try to cut him
The artist thought of harming black


Try to force him 'neath my level
Trying to put black beneath the singer


The only way to equal to him
The artist believes the only way to be equal to black is to harm him


Would be hit him with a shovel
The singer thought of physically harming black


But to really rise above him
The singer considered rising above black


That would be the final evil
The singer felt that it would be unethical


So instead I asked the sucker
The artist took a different approach


If he'd care to see my rooms
The artist invited black to see their rooms


And as a friend and as a comrade
As a sign of friendship and camaraderie


And all the things that these implied
All the things that come with these relationships


I made him leave what it was that he had
The artist convinced black to leave his previous association


Used to keep us unallied
This association was keeping them apart


Black, you are my enemy
Repetition of earlier statements


And I cannot get close to thee
Repetition of earlier statements


Our life is ruled by enmity
Repetition of earlier statements


And I can't weaken that
Repetition of earlier statements


The only way that I can see
Repetition of earlier statements


Is to hold you close to me
Repetition of earlier statements


To love you for it's meant to be
Repetition of earlier statements


I weaken your attack
Repetition of earlier statements


Now black and I we are together
Black and the singer are together now


Fairly just inseparable
They are now inseparable


And in the terriblest of weather
They are together even in the worst of times


Our bonds are incorruptible
Their bond is unbreakable




Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group
Written by: Stone C. Gossard, Eddie Jerome Vedder

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions