They Always Knew
Jeffrey Lewis Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Art they made, didn't get paid
gig they played, nobody came
tape they mailed, test they failed
not accepted, drove and wrecked it
bad review, photo too
got caught up in bad luck
heart breaken, mistaken
funny lookin', nothing cookin'
got sold cheap, then sold cheaper
hit rock botom then fell deaper
wrote a keeper, lost the tape
and even lost the piece of paper
empty benches, monkey wrenches
common sense sez "leave the trenches"
what a life, it ain't right
a hopeless fight, no end in sight
but- they always knew they'd make it!!
dented mics, rented mics
he meant, she meant
dis - agreements
legal hassless, label battles
lyrics choken, strings broken
fight they fought, tix they bought
flight they flew, show they threw
people saw, sound was raw
don't forget, now place yr bets
would be a tragedy to miss 'em
a travesy of the system
such devotion, no promotion
small fish in a giant ocean
saw the gypsy, she was tipsy (crystal ball was full of whiskey)
say, should they give it a go, hey?





Ball said all signs point to no way!
but - they always knew they'd make it !!

Overall Meaning

The song "They Always Knew" by Jeffrey Lewis describes the struggles that musicians face as they try to make a name for themselves in the music industry. In each verse, Lewis provides a vignette of a different challenge faced by a band or artist trying to make it. These challenges range from not being paid for art to facing legal battles with labels to having audiences not show up to gigs.


Despite all of these challenges, Lewis ends each verse with the refrain "But - they always knew they'd make it!!" The song is a tribute to the perseverance and resilience of musicians who continue to work towards their dreams in the face of adversity.


The chorus features a playful and ironic dialogue between the band and a fortune teller. The band asks if they should "give it a go" and pursue their dreams, and the fortune teller responds with a resounding "no way!" Despite this negative answer, the band remains confident and determined to succeed.


Overall, "They Always Knew" is a song that celebrates the unwavering spirit of musicians who pursue their passions despite all obstacles in their way.


Line by Line Meaning

Art they made, didn't get paid
They created art but didn't receive any payment for it.


gig they played, nobody came
They performed a gig but nobody showed up to watch.


tape they mailed, test they failed
They mailed a tape but it failed the test.


not accepted, drove and wrecked it
Their art was not accepted and they were so upset they drove and wrecked something.


bad review, photo too
They got a bad review and a bad photo taken.


got caught up in bad luck
They got caught up in a string of bad luck.


heart broken, mistaken
They were heartbroken and felt like they had made a mistake.


funny lookin', nothing cookin'
They didn't look quite right and they couldn't seem to get anything going.


got sold cheap, then sold cheaper
They were sold at a low price and then at an even lower price.


hit rock bottom then fell deeper
They hit rock bottom and then their situation got even worse.


wrote a keeper, lost the tape
They had written something great but then lost the tape it was on.


and even lost the piece of paper
They couldn't even find the piece of paper they had written something great on.


empty benches, monkey wrenches
There were no people sitting in the benches and there were obstacles and difficulties.


common sense sez 'leave the trenches'
It was reasonable to give up and stop trying.


what a life, it ain't right
Their life was hard and it wasn't fair.


a hopeless fight, no end in sight
Their struggles seemed never-ending and without resolution.


but- they always knew they'd make it!!
Despite all of these struggles, they were always confident they would be successful.


dented mics, rented mics
The mics they had were damaged or rented.


he meant, she meant
There were misunderstandings and disagreements.


dis - agreements
There were disagreements or problems with communication.


legal hassles, label battles
They had legal issues and problems with labels.


lyrics choken, strings broken
The lyrics weren't working and the strings on their instruments were broken.


fight they fought, tix they bought
They fought hard and bought tickets for shows.


flight they flew, show they threw
They flew to different places for shows and threw great performances.


people saw, sound was raw
People saw them perform, but the sound was still unrefined.


don't forget, now place yr bets
Don't forget how far they've come and place bets on their future success.


would be a tragedy to miss 'em
It would be a huge mistake to overlook them or not support them.


a travesty of the system
The system was flawed and it was tragic that they weren't getting the recognition they deserved.


such devotion, no promotion
They were devoted to their art but still weren't getting promoted.


small fish in a giant ocean
They were small in comparison to all of the other artists out there.


saw the gypsy, she was tipsy (crystal ball was full of whiskey)
They saw a fortune teller who was drunk and not very reliable.


say, should they give it a go, hey?
They were wondering whether they should keep trying or give up.


Ball said all signs point to no way!
The fortune teller said that it didn't look good for them.


but- they always knew they'd make it !!
Despite all odds, they always believed they would succeed.




Contributed by Annabelle V. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions