Miner's Canary
Vanessa Carlton Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

I will sing, to keep the peace
Down below in the cage you built for me
A cave of echoes
A miner's canary

You were older, you knew the way
To keep me breathing even though the air was thin
There was no oxygen
A miner's canary

Lead me, slowly
I am your detective
A living warning sign
Kill me slowly
As I keep you company
I'll be keeping time

A sentinel so sensitive
You have to lose me
Just to feel the state you're in
You're bound to darkness
A miner's canary

Lead me, slowly
I am your detective
A living warning sign
Kill me slowly




As I keep you company
I'll be keeping time

Overall Meaning

In "Miner's Canary" by Vanessa Carlton, the lyrics depict a relationship where one person takes on the role of a caretaker or protector for the other. The singer refers to herself as a miner's canary, symbolizing vulnerability and sensitivity, while the other person is represented as an older, wiser figure who guides and supports her.


The first verse describes how the singer is singing to maintain harmony and unity within the relationship, despite being confined within the metaphorical cage her partner has built for her. The reference to a "cave of echoes" suggests that her thoughts and emotions are trapped, reverberating within the confines of this dynamic.


The second verse continues to emphasize the role of the older person in the relationship, who understands how to keep her going even in difficult circumstances. The phrase "there was no oxygen" could imply a lack of emotional support or the feeling of suffocation in the relationship. Here, the miner's canary imagery alludes to the singer's ability to sense and warn of potential dangers or issues within the relationship.


The chorus introduces a shift in perspective. The singer becomes a detective, searching for answers or insights into the dynamic they share. She is aware that her presence serves as a warning sign, indicating the potential harm or toxicity in the relationship. The line "kill me slowly" suggests that she may be sacrificing her well-being to be there for her partner, while also "keeping time" refers to her maintaining the pace or rhythm of the relationship.


In the final verse, the singer becomes a sentinel, someone who stands guard and watches over her partner. However, the sensitivity and depth of her emotions make her disposable in the eyes of her partner. Losing her becomes necessary for them to recognize or feel the weight of their own emotional state, which seems to be trapped in darkness. This further reinforces the idea that the singer is the metaphorical miner's canary, a sacrificial figure who brings attention to the imminent dangers within the relationship.


Overall, "Miner's Canary" portrays a complex and potentially toxic relationship dynamic where one person's emotional well-being is jeopardized for the sake of the other's comfort. The usage of miner's canary imagery effectively captures the vulnerability and sensitivity of the singer's role in this relationship as she navigates the challenges and sacrifices that come with it.


Line by Line Meaning

I will sing, to keep the peace
I will use my voice to maintain harmony and avoid conflict


Down below in the cage you built for me
Trapped in the confinement that you created for me


A cave of echoes
A space where sound reverberates, representing emptiness and loneliness


A miner's canary
Symbolizing a warning sign, an indication of danger or harm


You were older, you knew the way
Being more experienced, you understood how to navigate the circumstances


To keep me breathing even though the air was thin
Ensuring my survival despite the challenging and suffocating conditions


There was no oxygen
Lacking the necessary support or sustenance


A miner's canary
Serving as a warning of impending danger or harm


Lead me, slowly
Guide me at a gentle pace


I am your detective
Figuratively, I am exploring and investigating your actions and motives


A living warning sign
Existing as a living embodiment of caution and danger


Kill me slowly
Metaphorically harm me gradually over time


As I keep you company
While providing companionship and support to you


I'll be keeping time
Acting as a reminder of the passing moments and the consequences they bring


A sentinel so sensitive
Being watchful and perceptive, attuned to even the slightest changes


You have to lose me
You must let go of my presence


Just to feel the state you're in
In order to fully comprehend and experience your own emotional state


You're bound to darkness
Trapped and confined within a state of despair and gloom


A miner's canary
A symbol of warning, indicating the presence of danger or distress


Lead me, slowly
Guide me cautiously and gradually


I am your detective
I am actively engaged in uncovering and understanding your actions and intentions


A living warning sign
An embodiment of caution and potential harm in your life


Kill me slowly
Metaphorically cause me gradual harm and suffering


As I keep you company
While providing companionship and support despite the resulting pain


I'll be keeping time
I will serve as a reminder of the passing moments and the consequences they bring




Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group
Written by: Vanesa Carlton

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@engrfka

Vanessa is definitely not an underrated singer. She's basically what you call a pure artist. Pure artists are just not 'celebrated' these days.. She doesn't need to resort to nudity or alter her work for the sake of commercialization. Sure, at the end of day, she might be making lesser money or less of a fan base but I'm telling you she sleeps in peace at the end of the day and is completely satisfied as she gets to do what she always wanted. And her fan base is true and not based on fake fans that other mainstream artists have.

@ManiSoSweet

Right. we actually BUY her music.

@nikolamilovanovic7129

I buy some CDs of her.

@antoniocastro2301

Honestly I think Vanessa is an underrated singer her music is amazing and the people that gave her dislikes obviously don’t know what good music is in my opinion

@brunodeandradeful

exotic visions she the most underrated singer/songwriter of her generation. Unfortunately labels are only interested in money. What Vanessa makes goes beyond music, it’s art, pure magic.

@IloveSPIDERZ

The dislikes could be accidental... Maybe they were sleeping and the button was inadvertently pressed?

@lyrilljackson

@@IloveSPIDERZ it's 2020 already voting stopped mattering long before reddit removed showing downvote counts lul

@thelonelyconner1908

Listen buddy, almost everyone's knows her album "A thousand miles" and after that no one really cared for her music, just how it is, people have all there different opinions, but for the ones that like little pump, they should got to hell and never come back, but hay that's just my opinion.

@sameershakya7194

Her album Heroes and Thieves is one of the best albums I've listened to. Every single song is soo good.

7 More Replies...

@joeyjoe7930

Every time I think Vanessa has outdone herself, she comes up with another brilliant song. The lyrics and instrumentals in this song are epic!

More Comments