HERETICS
Andrew Bird Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Born host to a tongue so sing a song about it
Held a breath for too long till we're half sick about it
Tell us what we did wrong, then you can blame us for it
Turn the clamp on our thumbs so we're down about it
And tell us all about it, we're so in doubt about it

How about some credit now
Credit is due for the damage that was done
We have wrought upon ourselves and others
With this blow and vicious gun
And although pratfalls can be fun, encores can be fatal

And then I hear you say
Thank God it's fatal, thank God it's fatal, not shy
Not shy and fatal, not shy and fatal, thank God
Thank God it's fatal, thank God it's fatal, not shy
Not shy and fatal, not shy and fatal

Wait just a second now
It's not all that bad, are we not having fun?
You make your mountains of handkerchiefs
Where the mascara always runs
So be careful when you're done you're bound to get post natal
Wait, did I just hear you say

Thank God it's fatal
No, we don't want to hear the sound of a draw
No, we don't want to hear the sound of a draw
And we don't want to hear the signs that you bore
You know the kind of sign you hang on a door
Saying, "We'll be back, we're a crack"

Now don't you think we might have heard all that before
Yeah, don't you think we might have heard all that before

Born host to a tongue so sing a song about it
Held our breath for too long till we're half sick about it




Tell us what we did wrong and you can blame us
Turn the clamp on our thumbs so we're down about it

Overall Meaning

"Heretics" by Andrew Bird is a song with a complex message about the duality of human nature. The lyrics are written from the perspective of someone who sees themselves as a "heretic," or someone who challenges the norm and questions authority. The first verse seems to be directed towards those who have criticized the singer's actions and ideas, as they ask to be told what they did wrong and then punished for it. The singer is resigned to their fate, acknowledging that they are "so in doubt about it" and willing to accept whatever comes their way.


In the second verse, the singer takes a step back and acknowledges the harm that they and others have caused through their actions. They suggest that "credit is due for the damage that was done" and that while pratfalls (or comedic falls) can be fun, the consequences can be fatal. This is a commentary on the tendency of humans to make mistakes and cause harm without fully understanding the consequences. The singer also references the role that society plays in this, as they suggest that "we have wrought upon ourselves and others" and that there is a cycle of violence that we must acknowledge.


Line by Line Meaning

Born host to a tongue so sing a song about it
We have the ability to speak up and share our thoughts, so let's use it to talk about the situation we're in.


Held a breath for too long till we're half sick about it
We've been avoiding addressing the problem for too long and it's making us feel uneasy and unwell.


Tell us what we did wrong, then you can blame us for it
We want to hear feedback on what we did wrong so we can take ownership and make things right, instead of just being blamed for it.


Turn the clamp on our thumbs so we're down about it
Makes us feel powerless and defeated, as if we have no control over the situation.


And tell us all about it, we're so in doubt about it
We're feeling unsure and hesitant, so we need more information about what's happening to make sense of it.


How about some credit now
We deserve recognition for what we've accomplished, despite the challenges we've faced.


Credit is due for the damage that was done
We accept responsibility for the harm we've caused and want to make amends for it.


We have wrought upon ourselves and others
Our actions have had negative consequences not only on ourselves, but also on those around us.


With this blow and vicious gun
Our actions were very harmful, like a violent attack.


And although pratfalls can be fun, encores can be fatal
Although we may laugh at our own mistakes, repeating them could have serious consequences.


And then I hear you say Thank God it's fatal, thank God it's fatal, not shy, Not shy and fatal, not shy and fatal, thank God Thank God it's fatal, thank God it's fatal, not shy, Not shy and fatal, not shy and fatal
There's a sense of relief or even celebration that consequences were serious enough to force change, rather than being ignored or brushed aside. But this attitude towards harm is unsettling and suggests a lack of empathy or compassion.


Wait just a second now
Let's pause for a moment to reconsider our perspective and actions.


It's not all that bad, are we not having fun?
There may be moments of enjoyment, but harm is still being done and it's important to acknowledge that.


You make your mountains of handkerchiefs
You're creating a big fuss or exaggerating the situation.


Where the mascara always runs
This is a stereotypical portrayal of women crying and being overly emotional.


So be careful when you're done you're bound to get post natal
If you continue down this path, you're likely to experience negative consequences similar to postpartum depression.


Wait, did I just hear you say Thank God it's fatal
This repeated phrase suggests a possible inability or unwillingness to truly understand the impact of harm caused.


No, we don't want to hear the sound of a draw
We don't want to hear about or experience more harm or violence.


And we don't want to hear the signs that you bore, You know the kind of sign you hang on a door
We don't want to hear empty promises or excuses.


Saying, 'We'll be back, we're a crack'
This phrase implies that the person will return and be a source of harm again, rather than actually changing their behavior for the better.


Now don't you think we might have heard all that before
We've heard these empty promises and excuses many times before, and they're not convincing or helpful at all.




Lyrics © O/B/O APRA AMCOS
Written by: ANDREW WEGMAN BIRD

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions