When
Andy Carpenter Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Your heart is broken
Your world is a bitter place
Your confidence shaken
Your faith erased
What you depend on
Is up in the air
You want to move forward
With no forward there

Your husband left you
No good reason why
He wants a new life
You want to die
He wants to be your friend
But you can't be his
Tell him to go to hell
You already did

The problem's not hatred
There's no hate from him
The facts of indifference are cruel
With it's pleasant skin and it's brutal grin
How the world learns your name
And it spins away

It's a question of damage
And wasted years
But love's never wasted
Though it led you here

It might be the worse place that you've ever been
Still you light up a room




When you walk in
You light up a room when you walk in

Overall Meaning

In "You", Andy Carpenter sings about a person who is going through a tough time after the end of a relationship. The breakdown of the relationship has left her broken-hearted, bitter, and shaken. She is struggling to depend on anything and feels as though she has no way forward. The song goes on to describe her specific situation of her husband leaving her without a good reason, wanting a new life, but still wanting to be friends. She ultimately chooses to cut him out of her life entirely.


The chorus is a reminder that although the situation is devastating and has caused damage, love is never wasted. The person is still able to light up a room despite being in the worst place they have ever been. The song is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit and the power of love even in the darkest moments.


Line by Line Meaning

Your heart is broken
Your emotions are shattered


Your world is a bitter place
Your environment is full of sorrow


Your confidence shaken
You lack self-assurance


Your faith erased
Your beliefs are destroyed


What you depend on
Your reliance


Is up in the air
Is uncertain


You want to move forward
You desire to advance


With no forward there
But there is no apparent path ahead


Your husband left you
Your spouse abandoned you


No good reason why
Without a valid explanation


He wants a new life
He desires a different existence


You want to die
You desire to end your life


He wants to be your friend
He desires a platonic relationship with you


But you can't be his
But you cannot mutually have the same bond


Tell him to go to hell
You instruct him to leave and never return


You already did
You already did this


The problem's not hatred
Hatred is not the issue


There's no hate from him
He does not harbor any hatred


The facts of indifference are cruel
The truth of disregard is pitiless


With its pleasant skin and its brutal grin
It can be alluring yet menacing


How the world learns your name
The way the world knows you


And it spins away
As it disappears into the distance


It's a question of damage
It's about harm that has been caused


And wasted years
And the years that were lost


But love's never wasted
But the love shared is never pointless


Though it led you here
Even though it brought you to this moment


It might be the worst place that you've ever been
This might be the most wretched situation you have faced


Still you light up a room
But even so, you radiate happiness


When you walk in
When you enter




Lyrics © O/B/O APRA/AMCOS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

angelo galea

Great version

Kelly Mark

@angelo galea Glad that you enjoyed it :)

MIKECNW

Wonder how this did on the charts either in the US or Canada?I've heard his version of "Baby I Love You" and "Rock Me Gently" which was released in 74 but not this song.Seemed like it wasn't till the 70's when we heard a lot more Canadian artists.

angelo galea

The first time i heard it was in 1972 in Toronto Canada

Kelly Mark

@angelo galea So Glad that you enjoyed Your Listen :)

Dale Tonelli

BARON LONGFELLOW STAND UP

More Versions