They formed in 1988 in Scarborough, Ontario, a suburb of Toronto, and they are best known for a series of hit singles including: "One Week", "Pinch Me", "If I Had $1000000" and "Brian Wilson". The band's music often features influences from 60s pop rock by artists such as The Beach Boys and The Beatles as well as a light-hearted and comedic performance style. Their trademark at live shows is humorous banter between songs as well as improvised raps/songs, both of which are staples at almost every concert they perform. Each member of the group is a versatile musician, as there are a lot of varied instruments, and each member (with the exception of drummer Tyler Stewart) has written and sung lead on at least one song for the band.
Group origins and indie work
Barenaked Ladies began as the duo of Ed Robertson and Steven Page. The two had gone to school together since Robertson was in the fourth grade (Page was a grade ahead), but were not friends until they ran into each other at a Harvey's restaurant following a Peter Gabriel concert. Each interested to find the other liked Gabriel, they began talking and found they had many of the same tastes. The two became friends, and when Page had an extra ticket to a Bob Dylan concert that no one wanted, he ran into Robertson at a party. The two attended the concert at Exhibition Stadium (most likely on August 29, 1988). It was a period where Dylan's band was led by G.E. Smith, and Robertson describes the show as "horrible" and "lame". The two turned to amusing each other, pretending they were rock critics, inventing histories and comments about the Dylan band. They also made up various band names; one of which was "Barenaked Ladies".
On another front, Robertson had agreed to perform with his cover band in a battle of the bands at Nathan Phillips Square for the Second Harvest food bank. The band broke up and he forgot about the gig. When he received a phone call a week before the show, asking him to confirm the gig, he improvised that the name of the band had changed to "Barenaked Ladies", recalling the name from the Dylan concert. He then called his friend Steve and asked if he wanted to do the gig; Steve reportedly replied "You told them that?". They arranged three rehearsals and missed them all.
They played the show, but instead of competing, they played while the other bands set up, playing every song they could think of that they both knew. The show went well and they were invited to open a show for another well-known local band, The Razorbacks, at the Horseshoe Tavern the coming weekend. They set up three more rehearsals, and again missed them all, and proceeded to improv their set once again. This would set a precident for an element of Barenaked Ladies concerts which still almost always contain some improvised raps or songs, as well as general improvised banter.
The two continued playing other shows like that and also began writing songs together. The band's first tape, Buck Naked, released in 1989, was recorded in basements and bedrooms. The pair became followers of a comedy group called Corky and the Juice Pigs, who they credit with exposing them to the idea of comedic stage presence. Ed and Steve presented the group with their tape, and were invited to open for the Juice Pigs on their cross-Canada tour.
One night, in Toronto, Ed and Steve invited their friends, percussionist Andy Creeggan and bassist Jim Creeggan, to play with them at a Chistmastime club show. "From the first note," Page recalls, "Ed and I just looked at each other and went 'this is it — this is the band'." The brothers were invited to join the band. Barenaked Lunch (also known as the Pink Tape) was released in 1990, and featured the two new band members. Unfortunately, the tape was mastered incorrectly and played too fast. As there were very few copies made of both Buck Naked and Barenaked Lunch, copies are now extremely rare.
After only six months, Andy went on a student exchange trip to Ecuador, and the band was lacking a percussionist. While playing at a buskers' festival in the summer of 1990, they met drummer Tyler Stewart, who took over the position. While Andy was gone the band gained some attention when they were winners at the 1990 YTV Achievement Awards. They gained further attention when they squeezed into a small "Speaker's Corner" video booth, operated by Citytv in Toronto, and performed "Be My Yoko Ono" as well as an ode to Speaker's Corner. After the former song was aired on television it quickly became popular with viewers, and noticeably increased the band's fanbase. Andy returned in early 1991 to find that Tyler had taken over the percussion role. This caused some concern for Andy, who then moved more towards keyboards, though he still played percussion (usually congas) on some songs. The band quickly embarked upon their first full fledged tour of Canada that winter.
Early Canadian success
The full band's first release of note was the 1991 Yellow Tape. It was a demo tape originally created for the band's performance at South by Southwest and was the first recording to feature all five members. They spent between $2000 and $3000 on it, and sent a copy to all the labels in Canada; they were refused by all of them. The band turned to selling them off the stage, and wound up selling a lot of them. Word of mouth spread, and people began asking for the tape in local stores. The stores began asking the band for copies of the tape, and the demo tape became a commercial release. Sales began to steamroll based simply on word of mouth and their live shows, and the tape became the first indie release by any band to achieve platinum status (100,000 copies) in Canada.
Sales of the cassette tape were jump-started when the band was taken off the bill for the 1991 New Years Eve concert in Nathan Phillips Square outside Toronto City Hall because a staffer for then-mayor June Rowlands saw the band's name and felt it objectified women. The band shrugged it off and booked another show at McMaster University. However, the media got wind of the story and decided to write about it as an example of political correctness gone too far. The first article earned the paper a large quantity of mail against City Hall's decision. The story became more and more prominent until about a week after New Years, when the band was asked to take a photo in front of City Hall for the front page of the Toronto Star. The stories erroneously targeted Rowlands, even though she had not even been in town when the decision was made. The following week, sales of the Yellow Tape exploded. The City Hall story has followed the band ever since; Robertson credits the scale of the story to it being a slow news week.
Also in 1991, BNL contributed a cover of Bruce Cockburn's "Lovers in a Dangerous Time" to the Cockburn tribute album Kick at the Darkness. That song became the band's first Top 40 hit in Canada.
The first albums
The band's first full album, the hotly anticipated Gordon, released in 1992, was a smash hit in Canada and included some of the band's best known songs, including "Enid", the first single; "Be My Yoko Ono", the single which helped fund the album; "If I Had $1000000", which spawned a Kraft Dinner -- or, in the US, Kraft Macaroni & Cheese -- throwing tradition at live shows that the band has since discouraged; and "Brian Wilson", named after Beach Boy Brian Wilson (who later covered the song on a live album). It benefited from the fact that a number of songs on the album (including the latter three) had been live favorites for a while and had been recorded on past releases like the Yellow Tape. While the band was doing remarkably well in Canada, they found that it translated into little success in the U.S..
BNL's second album, Maybe You Should Drive, released in 1994, fared considerably less well with the Canadian public. On the album, the band toned down its comic image, collaborated with kd lang producer Ben Mink, and produced what many critics acknowledged as a more mature work. They tried touring in America, but the tour was a failure and ended up losing money despite an appearance on Late Night with Conan O'Brien. Before the next release Andy Creeggan decided to leave the band. He had become disillusioned with the direction of the band, and was not fond of touring. In addition, Creeggan wanted to attend McGill University to further study music.
The band released Born on a Pirate Ship as a quartet in 1996. The album received two large boosts from the inclusion of the song "Shoe Box" on the Friends soundtrack, and from the Jason Priestley-directed video for "The Old Apartment," which got notable American airplay. The Ladies appeared as the guest band on an episode of Beverly Hills 90210, immediately preceding their 1996 tour; they performed "The Old Apartment," "Life, In A Nutshell," and "Jane" at the Peach Pit After Dark night club. Kevin Hearn was hired as the keyboardist for the tour and ultimately joined the band full time.
From two dates on the Born on a Pirate Ship tour during 1996, BNL recorded and released a live album called Rock Spectacle (pronounced 'Rock spek-TAK' - French for "Rock Show"), which had a modest radio hit in the United States with "Brian Wilson." The album went Gold in the US and the success of "Brian Wilson", coupled with the success of "The Old Apartment", led to a new situation for the band. Having shed their self-proclaimed "geeks in short pants" image, the band knew their next album would be their chance to make it big in America.
Breakthrough American success
They turned out to be right, as the 1998 release Stunt became (and remains) their greatest success, buoyed by "One Week", which coincidentally spent "one week" at the number one spot on the storied Billboard Hot 100. Immediately after Stunt was released, however, Kevin Hearn was diagnosed with leukemia, eventually undergoing a bone marrow transplant and spending several months at a Toronto hospital recovering. The band toured, with friends Chris Brown and Greg Kurstin both filling in on keyboards until Kevin recovered enough to rejoin them on the road. The singles "It's All Been Done" (used as the opening theme song on the short lived animated TV series Baby Blues) and "Call and Answer" (which later appeared in the film "EdTV") also came from this highly successful album. The band was also asked to contribute a song ("Get In Line", ending up as a single) to the soundtrack of the FOX cartoon, King Of The Hill.
Maroon, released in 2000, did fairly well led by the single "Pinch Me", though not as well as Stunt had done. In 2001, they released a compilation album, entitled Disc One: All Their Greatest Hits 1991-2001, in ironic reference to a line from their early song "Box Set". It contains 15 singles from previous BNL albums, two singles from other compilations, and two new tracks (including the single "Thanks, That Was Fun").
Everything to Everyone was released October 21, 2003, timed to coincide with the first show of the new "Peep Show" tour. The first single off the album was "Another Postcard (Chimps)", which received modest radio play. "Testing 1, 2, 3" was the second single off of the album and received a video, but no CD single, while "Celebrity" was released later in the UK with a CD single, but no video. "Maybe Katie" and an edited version of "For You" from a concert in Glasgow, Scotland were also released as singles to radio. Unfortunately, the album was their weakest seller in years, with a short chart life, despite positive reviews. With the release, the band fulfilled their contract with Reprise Records, which they did not re-sign. This made the band independent for the first time since 1992 (though they retained a distribution relationship with Warner Music). On the subsequent Everywhere For Everyone tour, in early 2004, the band began offering their full live shows for purchase as a download or CD-R on an eponymous website, as well as subsequent studio releases.
Return to independence
The band's next album was Barenaked for the Holidays, which was released on October 5, 2004. It was their first independent record since the Yellow Tape, as well the first album recorded at Steven Page's then-recently completed studio at his farmhouse called "Fresh Baked Woods". The label the band created for this album is called "Desperation Records". Currently, there does not seem to be any plan by the band to release material by any artist on the label other than themselves. The band's 2005 Christmas fan club release of a rare 1991 concert was also released on the label.
In January 2005, the band taped a television pilot for a variety show, tentatively titled "Barenaked Ladies Variety Show", which was ultimately rejected by the FOX network. Later that year, the band was asked to write music for the Stratford Festival of Canada's musical production of Shakespeare's As You Like It. Steven Page wrote most of the music (Shakespeare had provided lyrics in the play), and the band recorded it for the actors to sing over. The recording (with Page's vocals) was available on CD from the festival and on the band's website. On July 2, 2005 BNL took part in the Live 8 concert in Barrie, Ontario.
Following several writing sessions throughout 2005, the band went into the studio at Fresh Baked Woods that fall to begin recording 29 songs. They broke from the studio in November and December of that year to play a 22-show holiday tour, each night of which they played one of their new songs. An iTunes Originals - a collection of interviews and live songs (coupled with some old album tracks) was recorded while the band was in the studio and was released in February 2006.
In January, the band went back into the studio to finish up the recordings they started the previous fall. Initially unsure of how to release so many songs, the band announced in May 2006 that they will release a one-disc album in early September entitled Barenaked Ladies Are Me. Several alternate versions will be available, including downloadable versions and a USB flash drive version. The band has stated that they expect to tour in support of the album starting with a U.S. tour around the release, followed by tours of the Canada and the UK in 2007. The band is also holding a contest in which the individual tracks from five of the new songs will be made available online. Fans can re-mix and submit them to the band, with the best remixes to be released on an EP, the proceeds from which will go to charity. The first single, "Easy", was released as a download on June 19, 2006. At around this time, it was also announced that the songs that did not make it to Barenaked Ladies Are Me will be released on another album, entitled Barenaked Ladies Are Men, in early 2007.
In May 2006, Barenaked Ladies, along with other prominent Canadian musicians, formed the Canadian Music Creators Coalition in response to plans by the Canadian government to revisit and update copyright laws. Steven Page has acted as a conduit between the CMCC and the press, urging the government to focus on the Canadian cultural scene.
The band has also indicated that a boxed set is in the works, to possibly be released by Christmas from Rhino Entertainment which may include demos, unreleased songs and other exclusive material, both audio and video.
Following a lead from other artists (notably Dave Matthews and Friends), the band held a fan cruise called "Ships and Dip" from January 15-19, 2007. The band was onboard the entire cruise (unlike on other music cruises, such as aforementioned, where the headline band is not aboard the ship). They had several of their entertainment connections (bands and comedians) onboard. The bands Guster, The Brothers Creeggan, Kevin Hearn and Thin Buckle, and Trippin' Balls were all a part of the cruise. The band is already planning "Ships and Dip 3" for January 6-10, 2008, since "'Ships and Dip 2' would only be heartache and disappointment".
In the spring of 2008, the group released a children's album called "Snacktime".
In July 2008, Steven Page was arrested in New York State on posession of cocaine. After the arrest, the group stated they were "business as usual" and will be going into the studio in the fall to record a new album.
On February 24 2009, Steven Page announced he was leaving the group in a joint statement with the band on their website. Steven plans on working on solo material. March 7, 2009 saw their first show on stage as a foursome in Orlando Florida and in March 2010, they released All In Good Time, their first post-Page studio album.
The band released the album Grinning Streak, and the singles "Boomerang" and "Odds Are" in 2013, followed by the album Silverball in 2015. Barenaked Ladies x The Persuasions and Fake Nudes were both released in 2017.
In March of 2018, the band was inducted into the Canadian Music Hall of Fame. The induction took place at the 2018 Juno Awards, where Steven Page appeared with the band for the band for the first time in nine years. Following their induction, they performed "One Week" and "If I Had $100000" to close out the Junos telecast. Andy Creeggan also performed with the band during "If I Had $100000".
Side projects
Tyler Stewart, Jim Creeggan, Kevin Hearn, and Steven Page all have past or present side projects during their time off from BNL. Tyler was part of a trio called Don't Talk Dance which released a self-titled album in 1995, but are no longer together. Jim is part of the alternative/jazz trio The Brothers Creeggan, with brother and former BNL member Andy Creeggan and friend Ian McLauchlan. They have been on hiatus for several years now. Andy also has several solo albums. Kevin is the frontman of Kevin Hearn and Thin Buckle, who play a mix of alternative rock and jazz with many other eclectic influences. Steve has a side project called The Vanity Project. The first self-titled album was written mostly with long-time collaborator Stephen Duffy. Steve has said that the project is an opportunity for him to write with non-BNL writers, and a future release might not necessarily include Duffy.
Biography
Barenaked Ladies have authorized a biography, Public Stunts Private Stories, written by friend of the band and fellow "Scarberian" Paul Myers, brother of actor Mike Myers. It is published in Canada by Madrigal Press. An updated 2003 version includes a different cover, information about Disc One: All Their Greatest Hits 1991-2001 and Everything to Everyone, and corrects several typos found in the original version.
Website
barenakedladies.com
Break Your Heart
Barenaked Ladies Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
Was to run away and hide
But not this time, not this time
And the weakest thing I've ever done
Was to stay right by your side
Just like this time, and every time
I couldn't tell you I was happy you were gone
I couldn't tell you, so I had to lead you on
But I didn't mean to break your heart
And if I always seem distracted
Like my mind is somewhere else
That's because it's true, yes it's true
It's this stupid pride that makes me feel
Like I have to follow through
Even half-assedly, loving you
Why must I always speak in terms of cowardice?
When I guess I should have just come out and told you right from the start
Oh, why must I always tell you all I want is this?
I guess 'cause I didn't want to break your heart
And you said
What'd you think that I was gonna do
Curl up and die just because of you?
I'm not that weak, you know
What'd you think that I was gonna do
Try to make you love me as much as I love you?
How could you be so low?
You arrogant man
What do you think that I am?
My heart will be fine
Just stop wasting my time
And now I'm over you, I'll be okay
And that I've got what I want
And that's rid of you
Bye
And it's not 'cause I'll be missing you
That makes me fall apart
It's just that I didn't mean to break
No, I didn't mean to break
No, I didn't mean to break
Your heart
Your heart (ooh-ooh)
The lyrics of Barenaked Ladies' song "Break Your Heart" explore the singer's struggles with their own fear and pride in a romantic relationship. In the first verse, the singer reflects on past instances of running away and staying silent in the face of difficult emotions. However, as the song progresses, it becomes clear that the singer is trying to break free of these old patterns and be more honest with their partner. Despite this effort, the singer still finds themselves struggling with fear and pride, which leads to misleading communication and ultimately the breakup of the relationship.
The chorus of the song features a conversation between the singer and their former partner. The partner accuses the singer of arrogance and weakness, while the singer insists that they never intended to hurt them. The song ends with the singer expressing their relief at being free of the relationship, but also acknowledging the pain that they caused.
Line by Line Meaning
The bravest thing I've ever done
I've always been a coward, but at one point, I had the courage to run away and hide
Was to run away and hide
I was too scared to face my problems or confront the person I was with, so I fled to avoid everything
But not this time, not this time
This time, I'm not going to run away, I'll face the situation I'm in.
And the weakest thing I've ever done
On the other hand, the lowest point in my life is when I stayed like a doormat by your side.
Was to stay right by your side
No matter how you treated me, I never had the guts to leave your side.
Just like this time, and every time
Like every other time, I allowed my weakness to take over and stay with you even when it was harming me.
I couldn't tell you I was happy you were gone
I didn't have the heart to tell you that I was feeling so much relieved without you.
So I lied and said that I missed you when we were apart
Instead of being truthful, I just pretended that I've missed you even if I didn't.
I couldn't tell you, so I had to lead you on
I didn't have the courage to tell you the truth, so I led you on and gave you false hope.
But I didn't mean to break your heart
Despite all the lies and pretense, I didn't intend to hurt your emotions.
And if I always seem distracted
I'm usually not present in the moment and always lost in my thoughts.
Like my mind is somewhere else
My mind wanders around aimlessly, never staying focused on one point.
That's because it's true, yes it's true
It's true, and that's why I'm always agitated and preoccupied.
It's this stupid pride that makes me feel
My ridiculous sense of pride always creates the impression of me having to follow through even when it's pointless.
Like I have to follow through
I have a silly perception that it makes me noble to continue loving you even though it's fruitless.
Even half-assedly, loving you
Even when it's not genuine, I still felt the need to act like I loved you.
Why must I always speak in terms of cowardice?
I always use pessimistic phrasing because I'm a perpetual coward.
When I guess I should have just come out and told you right from the start
I should have been honest with you from the beginning instead of lying and misleading you.
Oh, why must I always tell you all I want is this?
I always insist on what I want because I fear to confront and work through our problems.
I guess 'cause I didn't want to break your heart
It's because I cared about you, and I didn't want to crush your sentiments towards me.
What'd you think that I was gonna do
You thought I was weak, and I'd collapse as soon as you left me.
Curl up and die just because of you?
You assumed that I couldn't survive without you, and I was emotionally dependent on you.
I'm not that weak, you know
I'm strong and capable of standing on my feet and thriving without you.
Try to make you love me as much as I love you?
I never attempted to coerce you to love me like I love you, which is pitiful.
How could you be so low?
Your audacity to underestimate me is repulsive.
You arrogant man
You are a self-centered, egocentric individual.
What do you think that I am?
What kind of person do you imagine I am to tolerate all this disrespect?
My heart will be fine
I'll heal from the hurt and disappointment you've caused me.
Just stop wasting my time
Put an end to this cycle of immaturity and waste of both our time.
And now I'm over you, I'll be okay
Now that I've let go of any attachment to you, I can confidently say I'm ready to move on and let go of the past.
And that I've got what I want
I now have what I need in life, and that doesn't include you anymore.
And that's rid of you
I'm glad you're no longer present in my life because you were a burden on me.
Bye
I'm putting things behind me, and it's time to say farewell.
And it's not 'cause I'll be missing you
Contrary to popular belief, I'm not yearning for your presence or missing you much.
That makes me fall apart
It's not because of you that I'm struggling to keep going.
It's just that I didn't mean to break
My intentions weren't to hurt you in any way.
No, I didn't mean to break
I'm genuinely sorry for any harm I may have caused you.
No, I didn't mean to break
I never intended to destroy your emotional well-being.
Your heart
I apologize for any hurt and pain I may have caused you.
Your heart (ooh-ooh)
Your sentiments towards me matter, and I realize my wrongdoing.
Lyrics © Warner Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: Steven Page
Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
Nova
The bravest thing I've ever done
Was to run away and hide
But not this time, not this time
And the weakest thing I've ever done
Was to stay right by your side
Just like this time, and every time
I couldn't tell you I was happy when you were gone
So I lied and said that I missed you when we were apart
I couldn't tell you, so I had to lead you on
But I didn't mean to break your heart
And if I always seem distracted
Like my minds somewhere else
That's because it's true, yes it's true
It's this stupid pride that makes me feel
Like I have to follow through
Even half-assedly, loving you
Why must I always speak in terms of cowardice?
When I guess I should have just come out and told you right from the start
Why must I always tell you all I want is this?
I guess 'cause I didn't want to break your heart
And you said
What'd you think that I was gonna do,
Curl up and die just because of you?
I'm not that weak, you know
What'd you think that I was gonna do,
Try to make you love me as much as I love you?
How could you be so low?
You arrogant man,
What do you think that I am?
My heart will be fine
Just stop wasting my time
And now I know that you will be okay, and that I got what I want
And that's rid of you
Good bye
And it's not cause I'll be missing you
That makes me fall apart
It's just that I didn't mean to break
No I didn't mean to break
No I didn't mean to break
Your heart
Nova
The bravest thing I've ever done
Was to run away and hide
But not this time, not this time
And the weakest thing I've ever done
Was to stay right by your side
Just like this time, and every time
I couldn't tell you I was happy when you were gone
So I lied and said that I missed you when we were apart
I couldn't tell you, so I had to lead you on
But I didn't mean to break your heart
And if I always seem distracted
Like my minds somewhere else
That's because it's true, yes it's true
It's this stupid pride that makes me feel
Like I have to follow through
Even half-assedly, loving you
Why must I always speak in terms of cowardice?
When I guess I should have just come out and told you right from the start
Why must I always tell you all I want is this?
I guess 'cause I didn't want to break your heart
And you said
What'd you think that I was gonna do,
Curl up and die just because of you?
I'm not that weak, you know
What'd you think that I was gonna do,
Try to make you love me as much as I love you?
How could you be so low?
You arrogant man,
What do you think that I am?
My heart will be fine
Just stop wasting my time
And now I know that you will be okay, and that I got what I want
And that's rid of you
Good bye
And it's not cause I'll be missing you
That makes me fall apart
It's just that I didn't mean to break
No I didn't mean to break
No I didn't mean to break
Your heart
Dominique Garofalo
Thank you.
Cap’n Cringe
Thank you 🙏🏻 😭
Helen Pain
Thanks
Blurt Reynolds
Not that I can actually sing; but when I’m alone and I sing along to this masterpiece, I always end up in tears
Oopers
this song still gives me chills.
Jill Bretzman
r/asmr
ColieDee Kenzo
This album is excellent! I absolutely love it! I've been listening to it since I was a teen, I'm 31 now. My father would play this album through anytime the stereo was turned on. I miss my Daddy. My kids know every song on this album. 100% Gold.
thewishingwell
Anyone else just love screaming out this song with Steve?
UtlraStar2021
I know I sound like garbage doing it but I still belt it out anyways