Magazine
Casey Foubert/Pedro the Lion/David Bazan Lyrics

In "Magazine," David Bazan explores the dichotomy between good and evil, the superficiality of societal standards, and the consequences of striving for perfection. The first stanza sets the stage for this exploration. The line "This line is metaphysical" suggests that the lyrics delve into abstract concepts beyond the physical world. The repetition of "And on the one side, And on the other side" emphasizes the contrasting nature of humanity.

Bazan describes the bad half as living in wickedness and the good half as living in arrogance. This highlights the inherent flaws within both groups, suggesting that nobody is truly perfect or without fault. The mention of a steep slope with a short rope implies the precariousness of such dichotomous thinking, as it offers little room for redemption or growth. The steady flow moving to and fro suggests the constant movement and shifting of these dichotomies in society.

The subsequent lines "Oh look you earned your wings, Are you an angel now, Or a vulture?" introduce the theme of appearance versus reality. These questions juxtapose the idea of being seen as virtuous like an angel versus being opportunistic like a vulture. There is a sense of someone constantly watching for a mistake, waiting to pounce. This highlights the pressure and scrutiny that comes with a desire to be perfect.

The repeated phrase "Oh my God, what have I done?" expresses a sense of regret or realization. It suggests the acknowledgement of the consequences of striving for societal standards and the pressure to conform. The following verses question the desire to be on the cover of a magazine, symbolizing the pursuit of externally defined beauty and success. The mention of "healthy skin and perfect teeth" represents the superficial aspects that hide what lies beneath.

Bazan goes on to criticize the inauthenticity of presenting a flawless image while harboring darkness within. The darkness growing stronger could represent the internal struggles and pain that arise from masking one's true self. The metaphorical cramming of light down one's throat emphasizes the artificiality and forcefulness of trying to appear holy or without reproach. The question of how this quest to be above reproach ultimately works out speaks to the futility and emptiness of such efforts.

In the final repetition of "Wouldn't you love to be on the cover of a magazine? Healthy skin and perfect teeth, Designed to hide what lies beneath," Bazan brings the song's themes full circle. He invites the listener to examine their desire for external validation and the dangers of disregarding the complexity and darkness that resides within. The lyrics encourage introspection and authenticity, challenging the notion that perfection can be achieved or sustained by conforming to societal standards.