Girl or Boy
Dani Shay Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Is that a girl, or is that a boy
Do they play with dolls or do they play with toys
I have to know the pink or blue,

The pink or blue now
How will people think of you, if they don't know how

Girl or boy, girl or boy?
Is that a lady or is that a man
Times have changed and lines are blurred
And I don't understand
I have to get a grip of this
It's bowing my mind
I am not a lesbian, but God she looks fine
Girl or boy, girl or boy
But God she looks fine
Girl or boy, girl or boy

Oh, but life is not a pink or blue painting
Hanging over someone's crib while they're waiting
To grow to be one or the other,
Living to please and to please their mother
And I hope we can grow to see that everybody is unique
And I know they told us when we were kids
But we forget it cause they also said
Don't be a p***y to the boy who cried
And they also said to the girl who fought
That's not very lady like
Well we gotta know who decides it
Do you or do I?
Who decides it?
Do you or I?





Girl or boy, girl or boy, girl or boy
Girl or boy, girl or boy, girl or boy

Overall Meaning

The lyrics to Dani Shay's "Girl or Boy" delve into the societal pressure to conform to gender norms and the struggle to understand and accept those who do not fit into those norms. The song starts with the confusion of how to categorize someone based on their appearance and interests. The singer questions whether the person is a girl or a boy and whether they play with dolls or toys in order to fit them into a narrow gender binary. The pressure to conform is evident in the line "How will people think of you, if they don't know how."


As the song progresses, the singer realizes that life is not a simple "pink or blue painting" and that everyone is unique. The pressure to conform to gender norms is damaging and creates a limited view of what it means to be a man or a woman. The lyrics suggest that people should be encouraged to be their true selves, rather than living to please others.


The chorus repeats the phrase "girl or boy" as a way to emphasize the narrow, binary view of gender that is prevalent in society. The line "But God she looks fine" suggests that the singer may have feelings for someone who does not fit into traditional gender roles.


Overall, the lyrics of "Girl or Boy" highlight the need for acceptance and understanding of those who do not fit into traditional gender norms. The pressure to conform can be damaging and limiting, and it is important to recognize that everyone is unique and should be encouraged to be their true selves.


Line by Line Meaning

Is that a girl, or is that a boy
I am unsure of their gender and feel the need to put them in a specific box.


Do they play with dolls or do they play with toys
I am trying to confirm their gender based on outdated gender stereotypes.


I have to know the pink or blue,
I am looking for a clear confirmation of their gender based on color preferences.


The pink or blue now
I am relying on a binary understanding of gender with limited options.


How will people think of you, if they don't know how
I am concerned with the opinions of others when it comes to someone's gender identity.


Girl or boy, girl or boy?
I am stuck in a binary understanding of gender and can't see beyond these two options.


Is that a lady or is that a man
I am uncertain of their gender, but am basing it on societal gender constructs of 'man' and 'woman'.


Times have changed and lines are blurred
Gender is becoming more fluid and less defined by societal norms.


And I don't understand
I am struggling to accept and comprehend this changing understanding of gender.


I have to get a grip of this
I am trying to control and make sense of something that is beyond my control.


It's bowing my mind
This is causing me stress and mental strain.


I am not a lesbian, but God she looks fine
I am attracted to this person regardless of their gender, but society has taught me to assume attraction based on gender.


Girl or boy, girl or boy
I am still stuck in a binary understanding of gender.


But God she looks fine
I am attracted to this person regardless of their gender and want to express that attraction.


Oh, but life is not a pink or blue painting
Gender cannot be reduced to a simplistic binary understanding of pink for girls and blue for boys.


Hanging over someone's crib while they're waiting
The gender construct is often imposed on individuals from birth and stifles their individuality.


To grow to be one or the other,
Society expects individuals to fit into one of two gender categories and restricts their ability to express themselves otherwise.


Living to please and to please their mother
Individuals are pressured to conform to societal gender expectations based on the expectations placed on them from birth.


And I hope we can grow to see that everybody is unique
We need to celebrate and respect individuality rather than imposing a binary understanding of gender.


And I know they told us when we were kids
Society has been indoctrinating children with a binary understanding of gender and gender roles from a young age.


But we forget it cause they also said
Despite being taught to celebrate individuality from a young age, societal expectations often override this teaching.


Don't be a p***y to the boy who cried
Boys are conditioned to be strong and 'masculine' and discouraged from expressing their emotions.


And they also said to the girl who fought
Girls are conditioned to be passive and 'feminine' and discouraged from being assertive or aggressive.


That's not very lady like
This phrase implies that there are specific expectations for women's behavior and that deviation from these expectations is unacceptable.


Well we gotta know who decides it
We need to question the societal norms and expectations that dictate gender roles and norms.


Do you or do I?
We need to give individuals agency over their own gender identity and respect their unique self-expression.


Girl or boy, girl or boy, girl or boy
Despite recognizing the limitations of a binary understanding of gender, the singer is still struggling to break free of this rigid definition.




Contributed by Declan E. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comment from YouTube:

crockboy

Yesterday I was at a park with a friend. We were on the swings and making another girl laugh. Her cousin came and started saying that he was a boy. He had a girl haircut. I'm pretty sure he was biologically female bc he said "my name is not Alexander! It's sander!!" Their parents didn't take much notice for some reason. But this is how the convo went
F (friend): were just embarrassing ourselves 😂
C (me, Casper): ikr! I feel kinda bad for the girl
G (girl): no, it's ok 😂
S (sander, the 6 yr old) yeh, u r embarrassing ur selves.
C: ok? Who invited u to this convo?
S: goes to tell his dad who doesn't care
Later
S: wait... are you a girl, or a boy
C: boy (I'm trans but I didn't tell him that)
S: how come ur wearing girl trousers (they were literally baggy dark blue trousers with patterns on)
C: how come u have girl hair?
S: goes to tell his dad that boy said I have girl hair! (Not saying why)
D (his dad): oh, why?
S: idk..... he just said it. He's really mean
D: but that's not a boy
S: it is!
D: that's a lady!
S: No!
D: mumbling towards his wife(?) maybe they're a transgender.
Luckily my mum came over to take us home but I'm still thinking about it. I wish I said that my trousers were genderless. Or that he has girl hair but that doesn't make him a girl.



All comments from YouTube:

snaaughty

"I am not a lesbian but damn girl you look fine" that's basically everyone with ruby rose.

Literally_Just_Art

Abigail Kathryn a year later and this is still the most relatable comment

Laine Alien

Abigail Kathryn true

Gen Searcaigh

"Everyone's a little gay"

alyvia dunson

Reason im lesbian right there . . . ..andmy girlfriend lmao

someone

True

10 More Replies...

Jan Vrolijk

Hi, Dani. I'm an old father with a young son from the Netherlands. I just found your clip with this song. I have this 11 y.o. son with the long (40+ centimeters) hair and who is often asked the same question. And because of his age he feels hurt about those questions. I let him listen to your song (he understands English pretty good). And the funny thing about the whole case is.... his name is Dani :-)

Jan Vrolijk

Unfortunately can't show you a pic of this beautiful boy. I haven't spread him around Flick-r or Instagram or whatsoever.

enhypen

I hope he feels better about himself and that society can be more open minded about being gender neutral and all, cheers! :)

Kimmm 13

loveedelight it's a girl

More Comments

More Versions