What Would You Say
Dave Matthews Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Up and down the puppies' hair
Fleas and ticks jump everywhere
'Cause of original sin

Down the hill, fell Jack and Hill
And you came tumbling after
'Cause of original sin
Rip away the tears
Drink a hope to happy years
And you may find a lifetime's passed you by

What would you say?
Don't drop the big one
If you a monkey on a string
Don't cut my lifeline
If you a doggie on a chain
Don't bite the mailman
What would you say?

I was there when the bear ate his head
Thought it was a candy
Everyone goes in the end
Knock knock on the door. Who's it for?
There's nobody in here
Look in the mirror, my friend
I don't understand at best
And cannot speak for all the rest
The morning rise, a lifetime's passed me by

What would you say?
Don't drop the big one
If you a monkey on a string
Don't cut my lifeline
If you a doggie on a chain
Don't bite the mailman
What would you say?

Every dog has its day
Every day has its way of being forgotten
Mom, it's my birthday, would you say?
What could you say?
What would you say?

I was there when the bear ate his head
Thought it was a candy
Everyone goes in the end
Knock knock on the door. Who's it for?
There's nobody in here
Look in the mirror, my friend
I don't understand at best
And cannot speak for all the rest
The morning rise, a lifetime's passed me by





What would you say?

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of Dave Matthews Band's song "What Would You Say" explore the concept of the fragility of life and the idea that we are all mere mortals. The opening lines describe the chaotic world of nature, where even the cutest puppies can carry fleas and ticks. The line "Cause of Original Sin" suggests that the imperfections and dangers of the world can be traced back to humanity's fall from grace.


The rest of the song is a medley of seemingly unrelated thoughts and images that invite the listener to consider life's big questions. The lines "Rip away the tears, drink a hope to happy years, and you may find a lifetime's passed you by" suggest that life is fleeting and precious, and we should not waste it on tears and sorrow. The chorus poses a series of hypothetical scenarios, all of which invite us to consider how we would respond to different challenges in life.


The final lines of the song, "Every dog has its day, every day has its way of being forgotten" and "I don't understand at best and cannot speak for all the rest" continue the theme of mortality and the limitations of human knowledge. The song ultimately invites us to reflect on our place in the world and asks us to consider how we can live a fulfilling life.


Line by Line Meaning

Up and down the puppies' hair
Refers to the chaotic, unpredictable nature of life - just like the way a dog's hair can be all over the place.


Fleas and ticks jump everywhere
Continuing on the theme of chaos, this line suggests that there are always going to be things in life that annoy or frustrate us, just like the way dogs can pick up fleas and ticks.


'Cause of original sin
A reference to the Christian belief that Adam and Eve's first sin caused a fall from grace for all of humanity, and thus everything bad that happens in the world can be traced back to that initial event.


Down the hill, fell Jack and Hill
A playful twist on the classic nursery rhyme 'Jack and Jill', suggesting that sometimes things don't go according to plan and people (or puppies) can trip and fall.


And you came tumbling after
Refers to the idea that we can be influenced or affected by the people around us - if one person falls, others may follow suit.


Rip away the tears
A call to action to try and overcome feelings of sadness or grief.


Drink a hope to happy years
Suggests that we should try to focus on positive things and have faith that good things will come in the future.


And you may find a lifetime's passed you by
Reinforces the idea that life is unpredictable and short, and we should make the most of our time while we can.


What would you say?
A rhetorical question that asks the listener to reflect on their own values and beliefs.


Don't drop the big one
A reference to nuclear war and the idea that individuals should try to prevent catastrophic events from happening.


If you a monkey on a string
A metaphor for feeling trapped or controlled in life, and the importance of breaking free from those constraints.


Don't cut my lifeline
A plea to not sever relationships or ties that are important to someone's well-being.


If you a doggie on a chain
Continuing on the metaphor of feeling trapped, this time referring to the feeling of being tied down or held back in life.


Don't bite the mailman
A humorous line that suggests we shouldn't snap at the people who are just trying to do their jobs - a metaphor for being patient and understanding with others.


Every dog has its day
A common saying that suggests everyone will have their moment of triumph or success eventually.


Every day has its way of being forgotten
A reminder that time moves quickly and the things we do today may not be remembered tomorrow.


Mom, it's my birthday, would you say?
A nostalgic line that conjures up memories of childhood birthdays, and the simple joys of life.


What could you say?
Another rhetorical question that suggests the power of words and their ability to comfort or encourage others.


I don't understand at best
An acknowledgement that there are many things in life that we may never fully comprehend or make sense of.


And cannot speak for all the rest
A humble admission that our own experiences and perspectives may not reflect those of others.


The morning rise, a lifetime's passed me by
An observation that time flies and it's easy to lose track of the years that have gone by.




Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group
Written by: DAVID JOHN MATTHEWS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comment from YouTube:

@tnawcwvictoria

This song was Top 10 on Casey's Top 40 25 years ago

God Bless the Dave Mathews Band and R.I.P. LeRoi Moore, Thanks for your contributions to the Entertainment Industry

and BTW, I use to watch the Music Video on VH1 back in the 90's

Plus, this song was out when shows like Full House, SWAT KATS, American Gladiators, The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, California Dreams, Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers, Family Matters, Boy Meets World, Step By Step, Hangin' with Mr. Cooper, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles on CBS, Ghostwriter, Martin, The Nanny, Home Improvement, Grace Under Fire, Frasier, Seinfeld, Living Single, Friends, ER, Party of Five, X-Men, 90210, New York Undercover, Rescue 911, Where in the World is Carmen Sandiego? and Sisters were still on the air

Plus, the late Richard Dawson returned as the KING of the Family Feud, STING RULED WCW-World Championship Wrestling, Bret "The Hitman" Hart RULED the WWF, Hakeem Olajuwan and the Houston Rockets RULED the NBA, Harlem Heat were the HOTTEST Tag Team in Professional Wrestling, Oprah and Ricki Lake were still the QUEENS of Daytime Talk and the Atlanta Braves RULED the MLB and TBS SuperStation

Remember those shows?



All comments from YouTube:

@gregorymartin513

I was in a grocery store today, this song came on. I was singing like I was in the car!
RIP Leroi Moore.

@membersonlydave

The 90's were so fucking awesome.

@nickbernath741

Goddamn right

@janedoe-hq9vn

Indeed, then we went into the world of "hash".......as in "re"...and today? When I turn on a so-called "Pop" or "Popular" station, I literally forget periods of time(I'm just INTO THAT MUSIC WOW!!!!!!)....it's loaded with subliminals(why else would I be buying so much,...)....... freaking songs all sound the same because guess what? Only two dudes write all of that dungurianuselope....or that's what the Internet God's told me, and if it came from them, then it has to be TRUE!!!

@lesnash6953

Except for Dave Matthews

@tylerrobinson8963

Yes...yes they were. They were the best

@tammyjanda1380

The music was real but not as graxeful as th1970s.

11 More Replies...

@michaelshulskie8367

This is my favorite Dave Matthew's song. It's pure genius!

@kaijubasementtonyc7331

Saw it live last week. It's just soo good it hurts.

@kirkl4president227

Each to their own, but I don't see how anyone likes Dave
Matthews 🤷‍♂️

More Comments

More Versions