Until I Get Caught Red Handed
Every Avenue Lyrics

The lyrics of Every Avenue's "Until I Get Caught Red Handed" paint a picture of someone who is keeping a secret, something they don't want anyone else to know. The first verse tells us that the person being addressed is assuming something about the singer, maybe even accusing them of something. The singer, however, knows the truth and wants to show that things are not always as they seem. They are keeping their secret close to their chest, hidden away in a box by the sea where no one else can find it. Pages are erased, and the faces of those who might find out are pale and strange, indicating that the singer thinks revealing their secret could have severe consequences.

The chorus suggests that the singer is hiding in the shadows, waiting for the right moment to come out. They're aware that they're doing something wrong, but they won't admit it until they're caught in the act. This idea is reinforced with the repetition of the line, "until I get caught red-handed." The second verse introduces the idea of a monster, which might represent the personification of the singer's secret. The listener is advised not to worry about what they might see once the monster is out in the open. Everyone falls apart sometimes, and it's okay to let it happen.

Overall, "Until I Get Caught Red Handed" is a song about secrets, their nature and consequences. The singer is afraid of the consequences of their actions if their secret were to be revealed. They feel like they're waiting in the shadows for someone to catch them out, but they're not ready to admit the truth until that point.