Muddy Hymnal
Iron & Wine Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

We found your name across the chapel door
Carved in cursive with a table fork
Muddy hymnals and some boot marks where you'd been

The shaking preacher told the captain's man
The righteous suffer in a fallen land
And pulled the shade to keep the crowd from peeking in
We found your children by the tavern door
With wooden buttons and an apple core
Playing house and telling everyone you'd drowned

The begging choir told the captain's man
We all assume the worst the best we can
And for a round or two, they'd gladly track you down

We found you sleeping by your lover's stone
A ream of paper and a telephone
A broken bow across a long lost violin

Your lover's angel told the captain's man




It never ends the way we had it planned
And kissed her palm and placed it on your dreaming head

Overall Meaning

The lyrics to Iron & Wine's song Muddy Hymnal depict a haunting story of someone who has been lost or presumed dead. The first verse establishes the discovery of the person's name carved in cursive on the chapel door with a table fork, indicating some sort of desperation or urgency. The mention of muddy hymnals and boot marks suggests a religious gathering or event that the person may have attended before their disappearance. The shaking preacher tells the captain's man that the righteous suffer in a fallen land, alluding to a sense of hopelessness or despair that may have contributed to the person's absence. The shade is pulled to keep the crowd from peeking in, perhaps indicating a desire for privacy or a sense of guilt.


The second verse describes the discovery of the person's children, playing by the tavern door, with wooden buttons and an apple core. The children are telling everyone that their parent has drowned, suggesting that they may have been witness to the person's disappearance or have been told this as a way to cope with their absence. The begging choir tells the captain's man that they assume the worst, but for a round or two, they'd gladly track the person down. This suggests that while there may be a sense of mourning or sadness, there is also a desire to find the person and potentially help them.


The final verse depicts the discovery of the person sleeping by their lover's stone, with a ream of paper and a telephone nearby. The broken bow across a long lost violin suggests a sense of loss or nostalgia. The lover's angel tells the captain's man that things never end the way we plan, and kisses her palm before placing it on the person's head. This moment is poignant and intimate, suggesting that the person may have been loved deeply and missed greatly.


Overall, the lyrics to Muddy Hymnal paint a vivid picture of a community coming to terms with the loss of someone they cared about deeply. While there is a sense of sadness and heartache, there is also a desire to find the person or potentially help them, and ultimately a sense of acceptance that things never turn out as planned.


Line by Line Meaning

We found your name across the chapel door
We discovered your name carved in cursive with a table fork on the chapel door


Muddy hymnals
Dirty religious songbooks


And some boot marks where you'd been
There were some footprints left behind of your movement


The shaking preacher told the captain's man
Anxious priest speaks to the ship captain's man


The righteous suffer in a fallen land
Righteous people undergo suffering in a corrupt society


And pulled the shade
Pulled down the window blinds


To keep the crowd from peeking in
To prevent people from looking inside


We found your children by the tavern door
We located your kids next to the pub entrance


With wooden buttons and an apple core
Acting as though wooden buttons and an apple core are toys


Playing house
Role-playing as a family


And telling everyone you'd drowned
Informing anyone who would listen that you didn't survive


The begging choir told the captain's man
The choir beseeched the ship captain's man


We all assume the worst the best we can
We presume the worst possible outcome at all times


And for a round or two
And for a few drinks


They'd gladly track you down
They would delight in finding you


We found you sleeping by your lover's stone
We located you snoozing adjacent to your lover's tombstone


A ream of paper and a telephone
A stack of paper and a landline phone


A broken bow
A snapped violin bow


Across a long lost violin
Over an instrument that's been missing for a long time


Your lover's angel told the captain's man
Your deceased significant other's heavenly messenger conversed with the ship captain's man


It never ends the way we had it planned
Things never turn out as we intended


And kissed her palm
Planted a kiss on her hand


And placed it on your dreaming head
And put the kissed hand on your slumbering mind




Lyrics © Warner Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: Samuel Ervin Beam

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@wrencormier513

this is honestly one of the best songs ever written, musically and lyrically

@user-dm8kz8ul8h

the 1 dislike is the captains man

@sera_sarzad

I think it's supposed to be "captain's men"?

What follows it in the second stanza is " they gladly tracked you down"

Not sure though

@karolwithaz

This song is hauntingly beautiful

@benjamink1403

There needs to be more stuff like this in the world

@mindbodydisconnect4082

This album is enough for my world :)

@sera_sarzad

Your lover's angel told the Captain's men
"It never ends the way we had it planned"
And kissed her palm and placed it on your dreaming head

@nuriyeuzumcu3030

💚💛💜💙💖💖💖

@rileyarnason2938

Pub Sop D,:

@pancho1095

pup sob

More Comments

More Versions