When Did You Leave Heaven?
Jimmy Scott Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

When did you leave heaven?
Why did they let you go?
How's everything in heaven?
I 'd like to know

Why did you trade heaven
For these earthly things?
Where did you leave your halo?
Where did you loose your wings?

If I kissed you
Would it be a sin?
Will they miss you?
Can you get back in?

I am only human
But you are so divine
When did you leave heaven?
Angel mine





When did you leave heaven
Angel mine

Overall Meaning

"When Did You Leave Heaven?" is a song originally recorded in 1936, but it has been covered by numerous artists over the years, including Jimmy Scott. The lyrics of the song are a combination of fascination and lament for a love interest who is believed to have come from heaven. The singer questions when their love left heaven, why they left, and what life is like in the heavenly realm. The singer is longing to be with their love again and is feeling unworthy of the divine nature of their partner.


The song's lyrics are rich with metaphors and references to heaven and divinity. The person the singer is addressing is referred to as an "angel mine," evoking images of an otherworldly being. The singer also wonders where their love interest's halo and wings have gone, suggesting that they have lost some of their divine qualities by being on Earth. The singer feels conflicted about their desire for their love interest, asking if kissing them would be a sin, suggesting that their love interest might be too pure for the earthly realm. The song's slow, mournful melody lends to the poignant longing that the singer feels for their lost love.


Line by Line Meaning

When did you leave heaven?
Asking the angel when they left heaven


Why did they let you go?
Questioning why the angels would let such a divine being leave heaven


How's everything in heaven?
Curious about the current state of heaven


I'd like to know
Expressing a desire to have more knowledge about heaven


Why did you trade heaven
Asking why the angel would give up paradise for worldly things


For these earthly things?
Wondering what earthly things caused the angel to leave heaven


Where did you leave your halo?
Curious about the whereabouts of the angel's holy symbol


Where did you lose your wings?
Wondering how the angel lost their divine wings


If I kissed you
Hypothetically wondering about the consequences of sharing an intimate moment with an angel


Would it be a sin?
Questioning the moral implications of a human interacting with a divine being


Will they miss you?
Wondering if the angel's absence is felt in heaven


Can you get back in?
Asking if it's possible for the angel to return to heaven


I am only human
Acknowledging the singer's limitations as a mortal being


But you are so divine
Highlighting the angel's divine qualities


When did you leave heaven?
Repeating the opening line to emphasize curiosity about the angel's departure


Angel mine
Addressing the angel in a loving and affectionate manner




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management, Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC, Spirit Music Group, Warner Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: RICHARD A. WHITING, WALTER BULLOCK

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

Ken Flott

Pure genius. Was lucky enough to see him live 3 times and meet him everytime. Nicest human on the planet. Much love Jimmy. Much love.

Jeanie Scott

Jimmy made heaven on earth in every situation now he is truly an angel in heaven. My Angel.

BrickCityBornandBred

I will always love the sound of your voice! Rest In Peace.

Gloria Allen

Great voice.

Mrs. Jimmy Scott - Jazz Wife 1

PJ DooWop, This is Mrs. Jimmy Scott. I can tell you for a fact that Johnny Ray & LaVerne Baker would sit in the front row at the Apollo and watch Jimmy's performances. Jimmy always cried when he sang becaused he lost his mother when he was 13 and never got over it. This is part of why his emotions onstage are so genuine and seem like a matter of life & death, it is his reality. Jimmy's crying on stage was real, Johnny Ray's imitation was fake. True fact. Jeanie Scott

bird of the abyss

I thought he made this song to worship Lucifer

Mrs. Jimmy Scott - Jazz Wife 1

@bird of the abyss That is sick.

bird of the abyss

@Mrs. Jimmy Scott - Jazz Wife 1 yeah it’s pretty cool. thank you for your reply

Anita Taylor

@bird of the abyss k

Tom Thiel

Thanks so much for the background, Mrs. Scott. Catherine Russel, a wonderful jazz singer, hits that same note at the end of her version. Perhaps to honor Jimmy. But this is so sweet. Special meaning for me as well.

6 More Replies...
More Comments

More Versions