Garden In The City
Melanie Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

When I was young I lived in the country
Clouds were my friends I cannot answer why
Now that I've grown I live in the city
And heaven is so far I cannot reach the sky

I once met a man who lived in the city
The stone was his home he said his heart was mine
He led me far away when he told me I was pretty
How strange to go so far and never touch the sky

Gardens grow most times in the country
Grow a-wondrous high
Gardens grow sometimes in the city
Grow, but soon they die

Now I look up at the buildings of the city
Their fingers are so much longer than mine
I wish I had the hands of the city
For heaven is so far I cannot reach the sky

Gardens grow most times in the country
Grow a-wondrous high
Gardens grow sometimes in the city
Grow, but soon they die

When I was young I lived in the country
Clouds were my friends, I cannot answer why
Now that I've grown I live in the city




And heaven is so far I cannot reach the sky
And heaven is so far I'll never touch the sky

Overall Meaning

Melanie's song "Garden In The City" explores the differences between living in the country and living in the city. The lyrics reflect the loss of the natural world when one moves to the city, and the separation from the sky and the heavens that it brings. When Melanie was young, she lived in the country, and the clouds were her friends. However, now that she lives in the city, she feels as though heaven is unreachable. The song also touches on the idea of love and how it can lead one to go far away from home, but ultimately leave them feeling disconnected and unfulfilled.


Line by Line Meaning

When I was young I lived in the country
In the past, I used to live outside the city in a rural area.


Clouds were my friends I cannot answer why
For some unknown reason, I felt a special connection to the clouds in the sky.


Now that I've grown I live in the city
As an adult, I reside in an urban area among high rise buildings and concrete streets.


And heaven is so far I cannot reach the sky
I feel distant from the heavens and sky, as if they are out of reach.


I once met a man who lived in the city
I had an encounter with a man who also resided in the urban area.


The stone was his home he said his heart was mine
He claimed that his dwelling in the city was his home, and that he loved me.


He led me far away when he told me I was pretty
When he complimented me, he took me on a journey far from where we were standing.


How strange to go so far and never touch the sky
It felt odd to travel so far yet still not have any closer access to the sky.


Gardens grow most times in the country
Typically, you find flourishing gardens in rural areas.


Grow a-wondrous high
The flowers and plants in these gardens can grow to impressive heights.


Gardens grow sometimes in the city
Occasionally, you may come across gardens in the confines of the city.


Grow, but soon they die
However, these gardens don't last long and often suffer from neglect or pollution.


Now I look up at the buildings of the city
Currently, I often find myself gazing at the tall buildings that surround me in the city.


Their fingers are so much longer than mine
Their buildings stand tall and seem to dwarf my own physical presence.


I wish I had the hands of the city
I desire to have some control over the towering buildings and infrastructure of the city, as if I was a part of it.


And heaven is so far I cannot reach the sky
My earlier statement still holds true, and I still feel as if the sky and heavens are too far away.


And heaven is so far I'll never touch the sky
My last statement carries an overarching tone of hopelessness, and I feel as if the sky is forever out of my grasp.




Contributed by Nicholas K. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

UK - Martin

I haven't heard this album since 1974, when I was visiting my twin brother while he was studying at Cambridge University. That was, it's hard to believe, 45 years ago.....but I have never forgotten the album, nor Melanie's enchanting voice.
Thank you for uploading this.

D S

Great version of Lay Lady Lay. Never liked this tune much, but Melanie transforms it.

Brsbeach

Thank you for this- bringing back many memories of a watershed time in my life, and Melanie's music was always part of it...Fun Fact: Stop I Don't Want To Hear It was the theme for a youth movement film called 'RPM' (Revolutions Per Minute)...

MB

One of my favorite Melanie tunes. I still am intrigued at how the music has a "backward" sound

Wilfried Mathias

Maravillosa, gracias por compartir!

Larry Sampson

I love this album. This song is not available on Amazon's Alexa for some reason. Melanie and I have been on many a journey together.

Nick Byrne

First Melanie album I bought. Great memories!!

Jim Pratt

Great,Great,Great album probable Melanie's best!!!!!

Pete's music

Fantastic , part of the soundtrack to my formulative years 💀🌵

Renoir

Reminds me of when I left school....loved the scented cover

More Comments

More Versions