Monongahela River
Melanie Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Some get put in prison
Others put themselves in one
Pittsburgh, you're the living proof

Some kill themselves living
Others get killed for trying, trying hard
They kill the ones who break the rule
Row me down, row me down
Monongahela River
Water down the city's gloom

Oh the lamplight is frozen
On windows and Sundays
So we never see the darkest room

But the heartfire is burning
And I keep praying one day
We will see the light of truth

Row me down, row me down
Monongahela River
Water down the city's gloom

Row your boat to the shore
Monongahela River
Isn't water anymore

Some get put in prison




Other put themselves in one
Pittsburgh, you're the living proof

Overall Meaning

Melanie's song Monongahela River is a powerful commentary on society's inequalities and the perpetuation of cycles of violence and oppression. The opening lines "Some get put in prison, others put themselves in one" sets the tone for the song, highlighting how individuals can become trapped in situations that are both imposed upon them and self-inflicted. The city of Pittsburgh is then presented as proof of this reality, with its history of steel mills and labor disputes serving as a backdrop for the struggles of its inhabitants.


The song goes on to describe the different fates that befall those who try to escape these confines, whether through self-destruction or breaking the rules set by those in power. Yet, despite these struggles, there is a sense of hope in the chorus "Row me down, row me down, Monongahela River, water down the city's gloom". The river is a metaphor for cleansing and transformation, and there is a sense that the heartfire of those who strive for justice will eventually prevail.


The verses also paint a vivid picture of the city's landscape, with the frozen lamplight and the darkest room representing the hidden realities of poverty and oppression. Yet, despite this darkness, there is a belief in the power of the light of truth to change things for the better.


Overall, Melanie's Monongahela River is a powerful reflection on society's flaws and the need for change, but also a reminder that there is always the possibility of transformation and hope.


Line by Line Meaning

Some get put in prison
Certain individuals find themselves confined in prison due to their actions in life


Others put themselves in one
Some individuals make choices and act in ways that ultimately lead to their own imprisonment


Pittsburgh, you're the living proof
The city of Pittsburgh serves as evidence of both types of imprisonment mentioned in the previous lines


Some kill themselves living
Certain individuals end up perishing due to their lifestyle choices or behaviors, one way or another


Others get killed for trying, trying hard
Some people end up dying for taking risks and pursuing their goals with great effort


They kill the ones who break the rule
There are harsh consequences for going against established norms or laws in certain circumstances


Row me down, row me down
Addressing the river, the singer asks for a ride along the Monongahela


Monongahela River
A symbol and a setting for the people and events the song discusses


Water down the city's gloom
The artist hopes that the river's flow can wash away some of the sadness or negativity that pervades the city


Oh the lamplight is frozen
The artist describes a specific visual aspect of the city, where a still, cold light is prevalent


On windows and Sundays
This light seems to shine particularly on windows, or perhaps only on certain days of the week


So we never see the darkest room
The artist suggests that there may be some aspects of Pittsburgh that are hidden or unknown to many of its residents


But the heartfire is burning
Despite or perhaps because of the difficulties the city faces, there is an inner spirit that keeps burning within it


And I keep praying one day
The singer feels a sense of hope and believes in the possibility of things getting better


We will see the light of truth
The singer imagines a time when people will come to understand and address the problems facing the city, and perhaps find solutions to them


Row your boat to the shore
The artist addresses an unnamed party, inviting them to come closer to the river and its surroundings


Isn't water anymore
The artist notes that some part of the river has changed or disappeared, adding a note of melancholy or regret to the song




Contributed by Evelyn R. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

PasoBaby

I have loved Melanie since I was 14. I'm now 60.  I can't say how many times her music has solaced me when I was down, felt what I feel, and carried me through.  She is my absolute favorite.  Thank you of this.

Darryl Buckett

All of Melanie's songs are my favourites, hard to single one out but this is up there

piperhill fan

We enjoy Melanie and her songs very much : thank you for sharing, Lynn.

lynn dorton

thank you.....☮♪♫♥♪♫♥☮

Janneke Yentle

Thank you!!! Beautiful song!i love Melanie :) !

lynn dorton

me too!! have loved her most all my life! i also love Jim, noticed you are in love with his poetic artistry!!!!

Jane Jones

thank you thank you, love this underrated artist, my fave greenie song ever.

Elisa Griffith

I was 11 when I first started listening to Melanie she was my inspiration

Sue Taylor

Thank you! One of my favourites also.

elraval15

thanx a lot for posting. i haven't listen to this beautifull song for a long time. I love Melanie too ;-))

More Comments