Why
Nichole Nordeman Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

We rode into town the other day,
just me and my daddy.
he said I'd finally reached that age,
and I could ride next to him on a horse
that of course, was not quite as wild.

We heard a crowd of people shouting,
and so we stopped to find out why.
There was that man that my dad said he loved,
but today there was fear in his eyes.

So I said, “Daddy, why are they screaming?
Why are the faces of some of them beaming?
Why is He dressed in that bright purple robe?
I bet that crown hurts Him more than He shows.
Daddy please, can't you do something?
He looks as though He's gonna cry.
You said He was stronger than all of those guys;
Daddy, please tell me why.
Why does everyone want Him to die?”

Later that day, the sky grew cloudy,
and Daddy said I should go inside.
Somehow he knew things would get stormy.
Boy was he right, but I could not keep from wondering
if there was something he had to hide.

So after he left, I had to find out.
I was not afraid of getting lost.
So I followed the crowds to a hill
where I knew men had been killed,
and I heard a voice come from the cross.

And it said, “Father, why are they screaming?
Why are the faces of some of them beaming?
Why are they casting their lots for my robe?
This crown of thorns hurts me more than it shows.
Father please, can't you do something?
I know that You must hear my cry.
I thought I could handle a cross of this size.
Father, remind me why.
Why does everyone want me to die?
Oh, when will I understand why?”

My precious son, I hear them screaming.
I'm watching the face of the enemy beaming.
But soon I will clothe you in robes of my own.
Jesus, this hurts me much more than you know,
but this dark hour, I must do nothing,
though I've heard your unbearable cry.
The power in your blood destroys all of the lies;
soon you'll see past their unmerciful eyes.
Look, there below, see the child
trembling by her father's side.




Now I can tell you why...
she is why you must die.

Overall Meaning

The song "Why" by Nichole Nordeman is a poignant exploration of the questioning and doubt that can arise in the face of great suffering and injustice. The narrative is told from the perspective of a child accompanying their father into town on the day of the crucifixion of Jesus Christ. The child is confused and alarmed by the violence and cruelty of the scene, and repeatedly asks their father why such a thing is happening to Jesus. The father's answers are initially elusive and unsatisfying, but eventually we learn that the child is in fact the reason for Jesus' sacrifice, and that is why the father cannot intervene to save him.


The lyrics are rich with biblical references and allusions, as well as metaphorical and symbolic language that invites the listener to contemplate the deeper meaning of the story. The child's innocent confusion and questioning stand in contrast to the adult world of power and cruelty, and the father's measured responses hint at the complexities and mysteries of divine intervention. The crucifixion is framed as a dark hour of reckoning, with both Jesus and God the Father wrestling with the weight of what is happening. Ultimately, the song suggests that the only answer to the question of why Jesus had to die is found in the love of God for his creation, and the hope of redemption.


Line by Line Meaning

We rode into town the other day,
The singer and her father were on a journey together.


just me and my daddy.
The singer's father was the only one accompanying her.


he said I'd finally reached that age,
The singer's father acknowledged that the singer was old enough to join him on a horse.


and I could ride next to him on a horse
The artist was given permission to ride a horse beside her father.


that of course, was not quite as wild.
The horse was tame and safe for the artist to ride.


We heard a crowd of people shouting,
The singer and her father encountered a commotion in town.


and so we stopped to find out why.
The singer and her father paused to discover the cause of the disturbance.


There was that man that my dad said he loved,
The artist saw a man whom her father cherished.


but today there was fear in his eyes.
The man appeared frightened, which was unusual.


So I said, “Daddy, why are they screaming?
The artist asked her father the reason for the noise.


Why are the faces of some of them beaming?
The singer noticed that some of the people looked happy, which was strange.


Why is He dressed in that bright purple robe?
The artist inquired about the man's clothing.


I bet that crown hurts Him more than He shows.
The singer speculated that the man's crown was causing him pain.


Daddy please, can't you do something?
The singer implored her father to intervene.


He looks as though He's gonna cry.
The singer observed that the man might cry.


You said He was stronger than all of those guys;
The artist reminded her father of his previous assertion about the man's strength.


Daddy, please tell me why.
The artist pleaded with her father to explain the situation.


Why does everyone want Him to die?
The singer questioned why people desired the man's death.


Later that day, the sky grew cloudy,
Later in the day, the weather changed and became overcast.


and Daddy said I should go inside.
The artist's father instructed her to go indoors.


Somehow he knew things would get stormy.
The artist's father had foresight that the situation would become chaotic.


Boy was he right, but I could not keep from wondering
The father's prediction was accurate, and the artist continued to think about what was happening outside.


if there was something he had to hide.
The singer entertained the idea that her father may have been concealing information from her.


So after he left, I had to find out.
Once her father departed, the artist sought answers herself.


I was not afraid of getting lost.
The singer was not intimidated by the possibility of becoming disoriented.


So I followed the crowds to a hill
The singer trailed the group of people to a nearby hill.


where I knew men had been killed,
The singer was aware that executions had occurred there before.


and I heard a voice come from the cross.
The artist heard a sound emanating from a crucifixion site.


And it said, “Father, why are they screaming?
The artist listened as a man on the cross cried out to his father.


Why are the faces of some of them beaming?
The man on the cross noticed that certain individuals appeared joyous.


Why are they casting their lots for my robe?
The man observed people gambling for his clothing.


This crown of thorns hurts me more than it shows.
The man divulged that the crown of thorns was causing him immense discomfort.


Father please, can't you do something?
The man on the cross begged for his father's assistance.


I know that You must hear my cry.
The man trusted that his words reached his father.


I thought I could handle a cross of this size.
The man admitted that he overestimated his capacity to handle his situation.


Father, remind me why.
The man requested that his father remind him of the purpose of his sacrifice.


Why does everyone want me to die?
The man questioned why death was the desired outcome for him.


My precious son, I hear them screaming.
The man's father responded to his cries.


I'm watching the face of the enemy beaming.
The man's father observed the countenance of the adversary.


But soon I will clothe you in robes of my own.
The man's father promised to honor him with a garment of his own making.


Jesus, this hurts me much more than you know,
The man's father divulged that the situation caused him great pain.


but this dark hour, I must do nothing,
The man's father recognized the necessity of allowing this tragedy to occur.


though I've heard your unbearable cry.
The man's father heard his anguished pleas.


The power in your blood destroys all of the lies;
The man's father understood that his son's sacrifice would be redemptive.


soon you'll see past their unmerciful eyes.
The man's father promised that his son would gain insight and wisdom.


Look, there below, see the child
The man's father indicated a young girl and her father.


trembling by her father's side.
The young girl appeared frightened and sought comfort from her father.


Now I can tell you why...
The man's father was finally able to reveal the purpose behind his son's sacrifice.


she is why you must die.
The young girl was the reason for the man's sacrifice.




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management, Universal Music Publishing Group
Written by: Alex DeLeon, Kara DioGuardi, Lucas Secon

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comments from YouTube:

CherMusca

"Why"

We rode into town the other day,
just me and my daddy.
he said I'd finally reached that age,
and I could ride next to him on a horse
that of course, was not quite as wild.

We heard a crowd of people shouting,
and so we stopped to find out why.
There was that man that my dad said he loved,
but today there was fear in his eyes.

So I said, 'Daddy, why are they screaming?
Why are the faces of some of them beaming?
Why is He dressed in that bright purple robe?
I bet that crown hurts Him more than He shows.
Daddy please, can't you do something?
He looks as though He's gonna cry.
You said He was stronger than all of those guys;
Daddy, please tell me why.
Why does everyone want Him to die?'

Later that day, the sky grew cloudy,
and Daddy said I should go inside.
Somehow he knew things would get stormy.
Boy was he right, but I could not keep from wondering
if there was something he had to hide.

So after he left, I had to find out.
I was not afraid of getting lost.
So I followed the crowds to a hill
where I knew men had been killed,
and I heard a voice come from the cross.

And it said, 'Father, why are they screaming?
Why are the faces of some of them beaming?
Why are they casting their lots for my robe?
This crown of thorns hurts me more than it shows.
Father please, can't you do something?
I know that You must hear my cry.
I thought I could handle a cross of this size.
Father, remind me why.
Why does everyone want me to die?
Oh, when will I understand why?'

My precious son, I hear them screaming.
I'm watching the face of the enemy beaming.
But soon I will clothe you in robes of my own.
Jesus, this hurts me much more than you know,
but this dark hour, I must do nothing,
though I've heard your unbearable cry.
The power in your blood destroys all of the lies;
soon you'll see past their unmerciful eyes.
Look, there below, see the child
trembling by her father's side.
Now I can tell you why...
she is why you must die.



Brandy McNamee

The only issue I have with this song is how some of the lyrics make it seem as if Jesus was ignorant of/confused by the reasons behind what was not true at all. Yes, Christ was 100% human, but He was also 100% GOD. He always knew what awaited Him and why He had to die. The Bible is quite clear on that:

"Then cometh Jesus with them unto a place called Gethsemane, and saith unto the disciples, Sit ye here, while I go and pray yonder. And he took with him Peter and the two sons of Zebedee, and began to be sorrowful and very heavy.
Then saith he unto them, My soul is exceeding sorrowful, even unto death: tarry ye here, and watch with me. And he went a little farther, and fell on his face, and prayed, saying, O my Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me: nevertheless not as I will, but as thou wilt. And he cometh unto the disciples, and findeth them asleep, and saith unto Peter, What, could ye not watch with me one hour?Watch and pray, that ye enter not into temptation: the spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak.
He went away again the second time, and prayed, saying, O my Father, if this cup may not pass away from me, except I drink it, thy will be done. And he came and found them asleep again: for their eyes were heavy. And he left them, and went away again, and prayed the third time, saying the same words. Then cometh he to his disciples, and saith unto them, Sleep on now, and take your rest: behold, the hour is at hand, and the Son of man is betrayed into the hands of sinners. Rise, let us be going: behold, he is at hand that doth betray me." ~ Matthew 26:36-46

Q: Did Jesus know He was probably going to be put to death? Couldn't He have done something to avoid it and keep on living? -- K.McK.

A: Yes, Jesus knew beyond doubt that His days were numbered, and that He would be put to death by those who opposed Him. He also knew when it would happen. Only weeks before His death He told His followers, "They will mock him, insult him and spit on him; they will flog him and kill him" (Luke 18:31-33).

And yet Jesus did not shrink back from this or try to escape. Instead, the Bible says, He deliberately continued on His way. Why did He do this? Not because He had some kind of a twisted martyr complex, or because He was tired of living -- not at all. Instead, He knew it was part of God's plan for Him to die -- because by His death, He would become the final and complete sacrifice for all our sins. Jesus declared, "The Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many." (Mark 10:45).

Was there any other way for our sins to be forgiven? Only hours before His arrest Jesus struggled alone in prayer, asking God to take away the horror of what was about to happen to Him. He prayed, "Father, if you are willing, take this cup from me; yet not my will, but yours be done" (Luke 22:42).

But there was no other way -- for on the cross, all our sins were transferred to Him, and He took upon Himself the judgment and Hell that we deserve. Think of it: He died for you! God loves you that much! Have you responded to His love by committing your life to Christ? ~Question posed to, and answered by, Billy Graham - who I imagine is having the time of his [eternal] life right now. :)

Anyway, that is only kerfuffle that puts a damper on this song for me, and it would seem that judging by the comments, I'm far from the only one a little bit confused and put off by the wording. The ultimate message remains truthful, and I'm certainly not here to start a row or denigrate Nichole Nordeman, whose music I adore... I just wish this song had been worded differently, for accuracy's sake.



All comments from YouTube:

Lego Dad of 3

This song is the song God used to bring me to salvation, 14 years ago.

Jesse Stassi

@Terry Wilson horses aren't extinct. I see them all the time.

Roxanne Villa

Arthur Banks -me as well! I never forget the message it spoke to my heart and how everything my pastor and friends were sharing/teaching finally made sense. Finally clicked. To me it was that He was the Lamb. THE LAMB that paid the price for me.

Ally S

I'm not a Christian, but I can still appreciate it. I love her voice, and the heartfelt lyrics of this song.

tony69em

@Scott Bennett you said that perfectly, sir.

Scott Bennett

Ally, I'm Christian, so that means I love you no matter what! Your CHOICE is your own and that is part of the reason, I believe Christ died for us. I can only pray for you in hopes that you will CHOOSE to accept the free gift of love, mercy, forgiveness and LOVE LIKE YOU HAVE NEVER KNOWN. I sincerely love you and that will never change regardless of what YOU DECIDE. God bless you and embrace you in His unconditionally loving arms.

Justin Osborne

The bible tells us to examine yourself to see if you are in the faith. Since you are not a christian, your assessment evaluation is clearly made definite. This means that you never was truly born of the spirit. When a person is born of the spirit, they have totally changed. If you desire to be saved, repent and believe. Do not ask Jesus into your heart. Give him your whole heart and everything that you are to everything that he is. Repent is to feel ashamed of sinning and forsaking it. Belief means that you put all your trust in Jesus.

Ally S

I did once

Justin Osborne

+Miss Kitty Please get right with God before its everlasting too late.

1 More Replies...

Matt S

When I first listened to this song, and every time thereafter, when it got to the 3rd verse, I cried.

17 years later, I listened to it again a few minutes ago and I still lost it. This is the ONLY song that has EVER had that effect on me.

More Comments

More Versions