Why
Rascal Flatts Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

You must've a been in a place so dark, couldn't feel the light
Reachin' for you through that stormy cloud
Now here we are gathered in our little home town
This can't be the way you meant to draw a crowd

Oh why, that's what I keep askin'
Was there anything I could have said or done
Oh I, had no clue you were masking a troubled soul, God only knows
What went wrong, and why you'd leave the stage in the middle of a song

Now in my mind I keep you frozen as a seventeen year old
Roundin' third to score that winning run
You always played with passion no matter what the game
When you took the stage you shined just like the sun

Oh why, that's what I keep askin'
Was there anything I could have said or done
Oh I, had no clue you were masking a troubled soul, God only knows
What went wrong, and why you'd leave the stage in the middle of a song

Yeah, yeah, yeah

Now the oak trees are swayin' in the early autumn breeze
The golden sun is shining on my face
The tangled thoughts I hear a mockingbird sing
This old world really ain't that bad a place

Oh why there's no comprehending
And who am I to try to judge or explain
Oh, but I do have one burning question
Who told you life wasn't worth the fight
They were wrong
They lied
And now you're gone
And we cried

'Cause It's not like you, to walk away in the middle of a song





Your beautiful song
Your absolutely beautiful song

Overall Meaning

The song "Why" by Rascal Flatts is a touching tribute to a friend or loved one who has passed away. The opening lines "You must've a been in a place so dark, couldn't feel the light" sets the tone for the rest of the song. The singer is trying to comprehend why their friend took their own life. The chorus "Oh why, that's what I keep askin'/ Was there anything I could have said or done" speaks to the feelings of guilt and helplessness that often follow the suicide of a loved one. The singer wishes that they had been able to see the signs and do something to prevent the tragedy.


The second verse of the song describes the friend as they once were - a passionate and talented performer who always shone on stage. The singer remembers them as a seventeen-year-old rounding third to score the winning run, and as an adult who loved to perform. This contrast between who the friend used to be and the circumstances of their death is particularly poignant.


The final verse of the song is more hopeful. The singer reflects on the beauty of nature and the fact that life is worth living despite its challenges. They express their sorrow and confusion about their friend's decision to end their life, but also acknowledge that they cannot fully understand what led to their decision.


Overall, "Why" is a powerful and emotional song that deals with the complex emotions surrounding suicide.


Line by Line Meaning

You must've a been in a place so dark, couldn't feel the light
You were going through a difficult time and felt completely hopeless.


Reachin' for you through that stormy cloud
Trying to help you through your struggles, despite the obstacles in the way.


Now here we are gathered in our little home town
All of us who knew and loved you have come together to mourn your loss.


This can't be the way you meant to draw a crowd
You wouldn't have wanted to be remembered this way, with everyone gathered for your funeral.


Oh why, that's what I keep askin'
I keep wondering why you felt like you had to leave us.


Was there anything I could have said or done
Did I miss any signs that you were struggling? Was there anything I could have said or done to help?


Oh I, had no clue you were masking a troubled soul, God only knows
I didn't realize that you were struggling deep down, and only God knows what was truly going on in your mind and heart.


What went wrong, and why you'd leave the stage in the middle of a song
I'm trying to understand what could have gone wrong, and why you chose to end your life so abruptly.


Now in my mind I keep you frozen as a seventeen year old
I remember you as you were when we were younger, full of life and energy.


Roundin' third to score that winning run
You always gave your all, no matter the situation, and it breaks my heart to think of what you could have accomplished if things were different.


You always played with passion no matter what the game
I admired your enthusiasm and dedication, whether it was on the field or on stage.


When you took the stage you shined just like the sun
You had a radiant energy that lit up the room whenever you performed.


Now the oak trees are swayin' in the early autumn breeze
The world keeps moving on, even though you're no longer with us.


The golden sun is shining on my face
Despite my sadness, I can't help but appreciate the beauty of the world around me.


The tangled thoughts I hear a mockingbird sing
Even though my thoughts are a mess, the simple beauty of nature can bring some comfort.


Oh why there's no comprehending
I can't fully understand why you chose to leave us all behind.


And who am I to try to judge or explain
I don't want to pass judgement on your choices or pretend to know what was going through your mind.


Oh, but I do have one burning question
But there is something that I can't shake - who convinced you that life wasn't worth fighting for?


Who told you life wasn't worth the fight
I wish I knew who made you feel so helpless and worthless.


They were wrong
Whoever made you feel this way was wrong to do so, and their words hold no real truth or value.


They lied
The idea that life isn't worth living is a lie, and I wish I could have shown you that.


And now you're gone
I can't bring you back, no matter how much I wish I could.


And we cried
All of us who loved you are heartbroken and grieving over your loss.


'Cause it's not like you, to walk away in the middle of a song
None of us expected you to leave us so soon - it's not like you to give up without finishing what you started.


Your beautiful song
You had so much potential and so much to offer the world - it's a tragedy that your beautiful song had to end so soon.


Your absolutely beautiful song
I want you to know that your life was beautiful, and it was a privilege to know you for the time that we did.




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management, Universal Music Publishing Group, Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC, Warner Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: Robert Mathes, Allen Shamblin

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comments from YouTube:

Vah Bermudes

Porque? (Tradução 🇧🇷)

Tem sido um lugar tão escuro, não podia sentir a luz
Procurando por voce através da nuvem tempestuosa
Agora, estamos aqui reunidos na nossa pequena cidade
Isso pode não ser o que voce chama de multidão

Oh por isso que eu continuo perguntando
Havia alguma coisa que eu poderia ter dito ou feito?
Oh eu não tinha idéia que voce disfarçava a alma pertubada, só Deus sabe
O que ocorreu mal e porque voce deseja sair do palco no meio da canção
Mmmmmmm

Agora, na minha mente, eu mantenho voce congelada com 17 anos
Cerca de quando voce venceu a corrida
Voce sempre jogou com paixão, não importava o jogo
Quando voce esteve no tabalado, voce brilhou como o sol

Oh por isso que eu continuo perguntando
Havia alguma coisa que eu poderia ter dito ou feito?
Oh eu não tinha idéia que voce disfarçava a alma pertubada, só Deus sabe
O que ocorreu mal e porque voce deseja sair do palco no meio da canção
Yah yah yah

Agora os carvalhos estão remexendo com a brisa do outono
O dourado do sol está brilhando no meu rosto
Na confusão dos pensamentos, eu ouço um passarinho cantar
Este velho mundo, realmente não é um mau lugar

Porque não há compreensão?
E quem sou eu para julgar ou tentar explicar?
Mas eu tenho uma pergunta:
Quem disse que na vida não vale lutar?
Eles estão errados
Mentiram
E agora voce se foi
E nós choramos

Porque não é como se voce saisse no meio de uma canção

Sua bela canção
Sua absoluta bela canção 💓

👏👏😍🎶🎧 09/02/2020 🙋‍♀️



Jacqueline Piazza

Lyrics:
You must've a been in a place so dark, you couldn't feel the light
Reachin' for you through that stormy cloud
Now here we are gathered in our little home town
This can't be the way you meant to draw a crowd
Oh why, that's what I keep askin'
Was there anything I could have said or done
Oh I, had no clue you were masking a troubled soul, God only knows
What went wrong, and why you'd leave the stage in the middle of a song
Now in my mind I keep you frozen as a seventeen year old
Roundin' third to score that winning run
You always played with passion no matter what the game
When you took the stage you shined just like the sun
Oh why, that's what I keep askin'
Was there anything I could have said or done
Oh I, had no clue you were masking a troubled soul, God only knows
What went wrong, and why you'd leave the stage in the middle of a song
Yeah, yeah, yeah
Now the oak trees are swayin' in the early autumn breeze
The golden sun is shining on my face
The tangled thoughts I hear a mockingbird sing
This old world really ain't that bad a place
Oh why there's no comprehending
And who am I to try to judge or explain
Oh, but I do have one burning question
Who told you life wasn't worth the fight
They were wrong
They lied
And now you're gone
And we cried
'Cause It's not like you, to walk away in the middle of a song
Your beautiful song
Your absolutely beautiful song



Alexiss Salting

You must've a been in a place so dark, couldn't feel the light
Reachin' for you through that stormy cloud
Now here we are gathered in our little home town
This can't be the way you meant to draw a crowd
Oh why, that's what I keep askin'
Was there anything I could have said or done
Oh I, had no clue you were masking a troubled soul, God only knows
What went wrong, and why you'd leave the stage in the middle of a song
Now in my mind I keep you frozen as a seventeen year old
Roundin' third to score that winning run
You always played with passion no matter what the game
When you took the stage you shined just like the sun
Oh why, that's what I keep askin'
Was there anything I could have said or done
Oh I, had no clue you were masking a troubled soul, God only knows
What went wrong, and why you'd leave the stage in the middle of a song
Yeah, yeah, yeah
Now the oak trees are swayin' in the early autumn breeze
The golden sun is shining on my face
The tangled thoughts I hear a mockingbird sing
This old world really ain't that bad a place
Oh why there's no comprehending
And who am I to try to judge or explain
Oh, but I do have one burning question
Who told you life wasn't worth the fight
They were wrong
They lied
And now you're gone
And we cried
'Cause It's not like you, to walk away in the middle of a song
Your beautiful song
Your absolutely beautiful song



Georgia Marcos

You must've a been in a place so dark, couldn't feel the light
Reachin' for you through that stormy cloud
Now here we are gathered in our little home town
This can't be the way you meant to draw a crowd
Oh why, that's what I keep askin'
Was there anything I could have said or done
Oh I, had no clue you were masking a troubled soul, God only knows
What went wrong, and why you'd leave the stage in the middle of a song
Now in my mind I keep you frozen as a seventeen year old
Roundin' third to score that winning run
You always played with passion no matter what the game
When you took the stage you shined just like the sun
Oh why, that's what I keep askin'
Was there anything I could have said or done
Oh I, had no clue you were masking a troubled soul, God only knows
What went wrong, and why you'd leave the stage in the middle of a song
Yeah, yeah, yeah
Now the oak trees are swayin' in the early autumn breeze
The golden sun is shining on my face
The tangled thoughts I hear a mockingbird sing
This old world really ain't that bad a place
Oh why there's no comprehending
And who am I to try to judge or explain
Oh, but I do have one burning question
Who told you life wasn't worth the fight
They were wrong
They lied
And now you're gone
And we cried
'Cause It's not like you, to walk away in the middle of a song
Your beautiful song
Your absolutely beautiful song



All comments from YouTube:

candace mandace

My 16 year old daughter, Abby, took her own life 9/26/15. That was the night my heart broke in a million pieces and time stopped. When I walked in and found her. I have never prayed or screamed to God like I did that night. I held her in my arms and just prayed. As a mother who lost her entire world, I want to take the pain that I feel and help other teens who think about suicide. I know if my daughter would have thought how this would devastate me I know in my heart she wouldn't. Depression is an ugly disease and if I can help another teen from causing their mother the pain I feel then I know that Abby's story will continue. Her story is not over.

Catherine Alcantara

I no how you feel I'm just the aunt and friend and daughter the middle child its kills me be hrave be strong her story does continue she's loves you god has yours and my back friends are cruel even boys are cruel r.i.p sbby

Matt Garza

I'm so sorry...

mike mailman

Im so sorry.....You truly touched my heart.....God bless you

PayItForward_7

I'm So Sorry You Lost Your Child to this. I had One FANTASTIC DATE with a Sweet PERFECT GENTLEMAN
OLD FASHIONED. I DIDN'T Know His Wife Destroyed Him. & SADLY I Never got a Second Date. I was waiting for him to call 3 weeks later
He'd Destroyed his bike & did the WORST THING IMAGINABLE. I STILL MISS HIM. Thank you for the KINDNESS Oliver You'll Never Be Forgotten.💔

Edward Reipi

Oh my heart cries out for this beauty as a mom

338 More Replies...

Georgina Zhou

I have thoughts of suicide when I'm depressed about my awful past. Even though I suffer from depression, I try all my best to cope with it and think about positive things more often. If I end my life too soon, then that will be very sad for my family and friends, and I don't want them to suffer from the never-ending sadness of the loss of me. Therefore, I must stay positive in order to have a long, happy life.

artsifartsinailz

Your past doesn’t define you! You can be healed and forgiven. Forgiving and being forgiven is beautiful. It’s possible!❤️

CrazyKatie89 NiftyMom

Music, tub and chill lots of tears.

Zippy Zepeda

@Welsh Kaibigan i have hard times too.i like cared for

More Comments

More Versions