Red Goodbye were an indie rock band from Long Island, New York.
They we… Read Full Bio ↴Red Goodbye were an indie rock band from Long Island, New York.
They were a duo of Andrew Horn (Vocals) and Alex Ruimy (Guitar), but Tom "Ham Sandwich" Vicale (since 2007, drums) and Mick LeBrian (bass) toured with them.
The band split up in 2011 and singer Andrew Horn formed a new band, One Time Mountain.

Discography:
- Red Goodbye (Demo, 2006)
- The Second Demo (Demo, 2007)
- Demo 3 (Demo, 2007)
- One Time Mountain (LP, 2009, sometimes called One Time Mountain: the Radiotower EP)

In summer 2009, several months after rock band Creed announced that their reunion album would be titled Full Circle, hundreds of torrents appeared on peer-to-peer file sharing sites labeled as a leaked copy of Full Circle but actually containing Red Goodbye's One Time Mountain, with modified file names and ID3 Tags. were enough to make the "leak" appear authentic. Some fans of the band were reportedly unaware they were not listening to Creed for months, until they searched for lyrics online and posted the accounts on the band's official website.
In the months leading up to the official Creed release, the album was downloaded upwards of 70,000 times.

The band drawed on early-90’s influences such as Alter Bridge, Dream Theater, John Mayer, and 3 Doors Down.

My Everything
Red Goodbye Lyrics

Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴

My everything
Take it away
Cryptic nights don't guarantee
Escape from this place

How can my dreams
Become realities?
His answer's just a blank stare,

Don't react now; just wait

We set sail on an ocean
Of moonlight covered dew
I can see the horizon
Day is breaking through
My lingering doubts
Eradicated and wiped out
But it's all an illusion

Three years go by
With flashes around me
Breathing deep and finding reason
Standing again

Making my way past
All the mistrust

Those with doubt have little reason
But they will see

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of Red Goodbye's song My Everything may not be immediately clear, as they appear to describe the singer's frustration with not being able to make their dreams become reality, and feeling like they are trapped in a "cryptic" and uncertain situation. The opening line, "My everything, take it away," suggests a feeling of desperation, as if the singer is willing to give up everything they have in order to escape this unsatisfying place. However, the second line, "Cryptic nights don't guarantee escape from this place," seems to imply that leaving may not be easy or even possible.

The next few lines seem to further elaborate on the frustration and confusion of the singer. They ask "how can my dreams become realities?" and receive only a "blank stare" in response. The line "don't react now; just wait" suggests that the singer is trying to remain patient and not give up hope, even though they are unsure what the future will hold.

The middle section of the song shifts to a more hopeful tone, describing a journey on an "ocean of moonlight" and seeing the horizon as the "day is breaking through." The singer's doubt and uncertainty are "eradicated and wiped out," but the final line of this section, "it's all an illusion," hints that this happiness may be fleeting or unreliable. The last stanza of the song suggests that the singer has made progress over a period of three years and has found "reason" and "standing again," perhaps meaning that they have gained confidence and stability. The lines "those with doubt have little reason / but they will see" imply that the singer is now secure enough in their own success to be confident in the face of criticism or skepticism from others.

Line by Line Meaning

My everything
Referring to a person, thing, or idea that is highly valued and whose removal or loss would be deeply painful or detrimental.

Take it away
Implying a plea to someone to remove the singer's everything or the source of their pain.

Cryptic nights don't guarantee
Suggesting that obscure or mysterious situations and moments in time do not necessarily provide a solution or lead to a positive result.

Escape from this place
Expressing a desire to leave a negative or oppressive environment.

How can my dreams
Posing a question about the artist's aspiration or vision for their future.

Become realities?
Asking how their hopes can be fulfilled or achieved in the future.

His answer's just a blank stare,
Saying that someone the singer looks up to or relies on gives no real or meaningful response to their query.

Don't react now; just wait
Advising patience or a pause in taking action, implying that the circumstances will become clearer given time.

We set sail on an ocean
Metaphorically describing the start of a journey or adventure.

Of moonlight covered dew
Painting a picture of a peaceful or beautiful scene, possibly hinting at a sense of romance or love.

I can see the horizon
Implying that the singer's journey is progressing and that they have a sense of direction or destination.

Day is breaking through
Suggesting a new start or the arrival of hope and positivity after a long, dark period.

My lingering doubts
Referring to the lasting or persistent uncertainty or suspicion held by the singer.

Eradicated and wiped out
Expressing that the singer has overcome their doubts or that their fears or concerns have been eliminated.

But it's all an illusion
Admitting that what the singer thought they saw or believed was just a false impression or expectation.

Three years go by
Noting the passage of time, suggesting that the artist's experiences covered by the lyrics are spread over a time period of around three years.

With flashes around me
Indicating that things are happening quickly or that there are rapid changes taking place, possibly causing confusion or agitation.

Breathing deep and finding reason
Referring to a need for the singer to remain calm and logical amidst chaos, crises, or emotional upheavals.

Standing again
Suggesting that the singer might have faced setbacks, but is now back on their feet and resuming the pursuit of their goals or dreams.

Making my way past
Referring to overcoming obstacles, challenges, or people that block the artist's progress.

All the mistrust
Referring to the suspicion or lack of confidence that others showed towards the artist.

Those with doubt have little reason
Arguing that individuals who challenge or express skepticism about the artist's abilities or objectives have poor justification for doing so.

But they will see
Expressing a sense of confidence or defiance, suggesting the singer's eventual success will silence any criticism or doubt.

Contributed by Julia N. Suggest a correction in the comments below.

To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

TRACKS