Beautiful Despair
Rodney Crowell Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Beautiful despair is hearing Dylan
When you're drunk at 3 a.m.
Knowing that the chances are
No matter what you'll never write like him

Oh, brother

Beautiful despair is why you lean
Into this world without restraint
'Cause somewhere out before you
Lies the masterpiece you'd sell your soul to paint

Oh, brother
What do we laugh or cry

Beautiful despair
Beautiful despair

Beautiful despair is slouching forward
Toward a past you might regret
All to suck the marrow out
Of every magic moment that you get

Beautiful despair is playing safe
When you were once a rebel child
Knowing that tomorrow comes
And all you've done is last another mile

Oh, brother
Oh, dear brother




Oh, my brother
What shall we drink or dry?

Overall Meaning

The lyrics to Rodney Crowell’s song “Beautiful Despair” is a contemplation on the universal feeling of failure despite striving towards glory. The melancholic song starts by comparing the despair that is felt when one is drunk at 3 a.m. and listening to Bob Dylan, knowing that no matter how much they write, they'll never achieve the level of unadulterated genius like Dylan. The song explores the pursuit of the artist's ultimate masterpiece, the one that could let the artist sell their soul just to paint, to showcase to the world. The lines “Beautiful despair is why you lean into this world without restraint” indicate that this pursuit is understandably pursued obsessively, despite the weight of failure.


As the song proceeds, it talks about the regrets in life, “Beautiful despair is slouching forward towards a past you might regret,” which people are desperately trying to forget. The last verse of the song says, “Beautiful despair is playing safe when you were once a rebel child. Knowing that tomorrow comes, and all you've done is last another mile.” These lines point out how life can become monotonous, despite once being a rebel or having the potential to flourish entirely. The song's final lines, "Oh, brother, oh dear brother, oh my brother, what shall we drink or dry?" sign off on this contemplative song, acknowledging that life can be lived in both ways, making the most of what's there or obsessing over what isn't.


Line by Line Meaning

Beautiful despair is hearing Dylan When you're drunk at 3 a.m. Knowing that the chances are No matter what you'll never write like him
Experiencing the bittersweet feeling of admiring Dylan's music while being drunk and realizing that no matter how hard you try, you can never write music like him.


Beautiful despair is why you lean Into this world without restraint 'Cause somewhere out before you Lies the masterpiece you'd sell your soul to paint
The overwhelming urge to pursue creative endeavors without holding back, knowing that there's a masterpiece that you are meant to create but not sure if it's worth the price of your soul.


Beautiful despair Beautiful despair
Repetition of the phrase emphasizing the beauty and poignancy of the feeling of despair.


Beautiful despair is slouching forward Toward a past you might regret All to suck the marrow out Of every magic moment that you get
Feeling the pull towards reflecting on a past that you might regret, but doing so to extract the essence of every magical moment that it had to offer.


Beautiful despair is playing safe When you were once a rebel child Knowing that tomorrow comes And all you've done is last another mile
Feeling stuck in life as you play it safe despite once being an adventurous rebel, knowing that time keeps passing by and all you've accomplished is surviving another day.


Oh, brother What do we laugh or cry
Expressing confusion and uncertainty, whether the appropriate response is to laugh or cry in response to the complex, beautiful feeling of despair.


Oh, dear brother Oh, my brother What shall we drink or dry?
Reflecting on the beauty and difficulty of life's complexities and asking what drink one shall raise to celebrate or lament it.




Lyrics © BMG Rights Management, Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC
Written by: RODNEY CROWELL

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions