Thin Wild Mercury
Todd Snider Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Poor Phil Ochs, sad and low
Hands in his pockets, wonderin' where to go
Watching those tail lights leave him behind
Thrown for the limousine for speaking his mind
Like a red-eyed photo into a garbage can
At the corner of hero and also ran
A fragile heart skipped a fragile beat
It's warm in the limousine, cold on the streets of

Thin wild mercury
And gold lame
Where things will go your way
Or they won't
Thin wind mercury
And gold lame
You know what they say
Or you don't

It was all over some new Dylan song
That Phil had the nerve to say sounded wrong
Dylan stopped the car, words shook like a fist
"Phil, you ain't a writer, you're a journalist"
Death of a rebel, twist of fate
If he ever thought better, he thought too late
Poor Phil Ochs, he slipped through the cracks
Judas went electric and he never looked back on

Thin wild mercury
And gold lame
Where things will go your way
Or they won't
Thin wild mercury
And gold lame
You konw what they say
Or you don't




No, you don't
No, you don't

Overall Meaning

The lyrics above are from Todd Snider's "Thin Wild Mercury" song, which was released on his 2019 album "Cash Cabin Sessions, Vol. 3." In this song, Snider reflects on the life and legacy of Phil Ochs, a folk singer and songwriter who was known for his political activism and protest music. Ochs was a contemporary of Bob Dylan, and the two often had a contentious relationship, with Ochs sometimes criticizing Dylan's music and Dylan dismissing Ochs as a journalist rather than a true artist.


The first verse of the song paints a picture of Ochs as a lonely and misunderstood figure, with his "hands in his pockets" and watching "tail lights leave him behind." He is contrasted with those who have achieved fame and success, riding comfortably in a limousine while Ochs is left on the cold streets. The reference to "hero and also ran" suggests Ochs was someone who tried to make a difference but ultimately fell short in the eyes of the music industry and his peers.


The chorus of the song refers to "thin wild mercury" and "gold lame," which can be interpreted as symbols of the glitz and glamour of the music industry. These are the trappings of success that Ochs was denied, and the lyrics suggest that success in this world is arbitrary and unpredictable. The final verse describes a specific incident where Dylan chastises Ochs for criticizing one of his songs, telling him "you ain't a writer, you're a journalist." This interaction, along with Dylan's move to electric music, signaled a turning point in the folk music scene, and Ochs was left behind as a casualty of this shift.


Overall, "Thin Wild Mercury" is a poignant tribute to Phil Ochs, and a commentary on the way the music industry can overlook and undervalue artists who are truly trying to make a difference in the world.


Line by Line Meaning

Poor Phil Ochs, sad and low
Phil Ochs is feeling down and unhappy


Hands in his pockets, wonderin' where to go
Phil Ochs is lost, uncertain of his future


Watching those tail lights leave him behind
Phil Ochs is seeing others move on while he stays behind


Thrown for the limousine for speaking his mind
Phil Ochs lost his opportunity for fame and success because he spoke his truth


Like a red-eyed photo into a garbage can
Phil Ochs' dream of success is discarded like a worthless item


At the corner of hero and also ran
Phil Ochs' failure puts him at the intersection of success and mediocrity


A fragile heart skipped a fragile beat
Phil Ochs' heart is broken and vulnerable


It's warm in the limousine, cold on the streets of thin wild mercury
The fame and success that Phil Ochs lost is represented as a warm, comfortable limousine, while his current state of failure is like the cold streets of a thin wild mercury


And gold lame, where things will go your way or they won't
The glitzy world of fame and success is represented as gold lame, where one's fate is uncertain


Thin wind mercury, and gold lame, you know what they say or you don't
The idea of fame and success is represented as a thin wind of mercury and gold lame, and understanding its implications is a matter of personal experience


It was all over some new Dylan song, that Phil had the nerve to say sounded wrong
Phil Ochs criticized a new Bob Dylan song that he felt was not up to par


Dylan stopped the car, words shook like a fist, 'Phil, you ain't a writer, you're a journalist'
Bob Dylan tells Phil Ochs that he is not a true artist, but just a journalist


Death of a rebel, twist of fate, if he ever thought better, he thought too late
Phil Ochs' fate is sealed as a failed artist, and it's too late to turn things around


Poor Phil Ochs, he slipped through the cracks, Judas went electric and he never looked back on
Phil Ochs was left behind as Bob Dylan became a successful electric artist, and Phil never recovered




Lyrics © Wixen Music Publishing, BMG Rights Management
Written by: Peter Cooper, Todd Daniel Snider

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found