A Plague of Lighthouse Keepers: Eyewitness/Pictures/Lighthouse/Eyewitness
Van der Graaf Generator Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Eyewitness
Still waiting for my saviour,
storms tear me limb from limb;
my fingers feel like seaweed...
I'm so far out I'm too far in.
I am a lonely man, my solitude is true
my eyes have borne stark witness
and now my nights are numbered, too.
I've seen the smiles on dead hands,
the stars shine, but they're not for me.

I prophesy disaster and then I count the cost...
I shine but, shining, dying,
I know that I am almost lost.
On the table lies blank paper
and my tower is built on stone
I only have blunt scissors,
I only have the bluntest home...
I've been the witness, and the seal of death
lingers in the molten wax that is my head.

When you see the skeletons
of sailing-ship spars sinking low
You'll begin to wonder if the points
of all the ancients myths
are solemnly directed straight at you...

Pictures/Lighthouse
(Eddies, rocks, ships, collision, remorse)

Eyewitness
No time now for contrition:
the time for that's long past.
The walls are thin as tissue and
if I talk I'll crack the glass.
So I only think on how it might have been,
locked in silent monologue, in silent scream.

I'm much too tired to speak
and, as the waves crash on the bleak
stones of the tower, I start to freak
and find that I am overcome...

S.H.M.
'Unreal, unreal' ghost helmsmen scream
and fall in through the sky,
not breaking through my seagull shrieks...
no breaks until I die:
the spectres scratch on window-slits -
hollowed faces and mindless grins
only intent on destroying what they've lost.

I crawl the wall till steepness ends
in the vertical fall;
my pain has sailed into the sea:
no joking hopes at dawn.
White bone shine in the iron-jaw mask
lost mastheads pierce the freezing dark
and parallel my isolated tower...
no paraffin for the flame
no harbour left to gain.

Presence of the Night / Kosmos Tours
'Alone, alone' the ghosts all call,
pinpoint me in the light.
The only life I feel at all
is the presence of the night.

Would you cry if I died?
Would you catch the final words of mine?
Would you catch my words?
I know that there's no time
I know that there's no rhyme...
false signs find me
I don't want to hate,
I just want to grow;
why can't I let me
live and be free?
but I die very slowly alone.
I know more ways,
I am so afraid,
myself won't let me
just be myself
and so I am completely alone...

The maelstrom of my memory
is a vampire and it feeds on me
now, staggering madly, over the brink I fall.

(Custard's) Last Stand
Lighthouses might house the key
but can I reach the door?

I want to walk on the sea
so that I may better find a shore...
but how can I ever keep my feet dry?
I scan the horizon
I must keep my eyes on all parts of me.

Looking back on the years
it seems that I have lost my way:
Like a dog in the night, I have run to a manger
now I am the stranger I stay in.
All of the grief I have seen
leaves me chasing solitary peace;
But I hold experience in my head...
I'm too close to the light
I don't think I see right, for I blind me...

The Clot Thickens
Where is the God that guides my hand?
How can the hands of others reach me?
When will I find what I grope for?
Who is going to teach me?
I am me / me are we / we can't see
any way out of here.
Crashing sea - a trophied history:
Chance has lost my Guinevere...

I don't want to be one wave in the water
But sea will drag me deep
One more haggard drowned man...

I can see the lemmings coming,
but I know I'm just a man;




Do I join or do I founder?
Which can is the best I may?

Overall Meaning

Van der Graaf Generator's song A Plague of Lighthouse Keepers is a complex and introspective 23-minute-long piece about the isolation and loneliness of a lighthouse keeper. The song has 5 distinct sections, each with its own unique mood and melody. The lyrics are divided into 4 parts - Eyewitness, Pictures/Lighthouse, S.H.M., Presence of the Night/Kosmos Tours, and (Custard's) Last Stand.


In Eyewitness, the singer describes himself as a lonely man with a deep sense of solitude. He has seen things that have left him scarred and knows that his days are numbered. He has seen dead hands and knows that the stars do not shine for him. The singer prophesizes disaster but also knows that he is almost lost. He is stuck in an isolated tower with blunt scissors and blank paper. He has witnessed death and now carries the seal of death lingering in the molten wax of his head.


Pictures/Lighthouse describe how the time for contrition has passed and the walls around him are thin as tissue. The singer is overcome by the waves crashing on the bleak stones of the tower. He hears ghost helmsmen scream and falls through the sky himself. The spectres scratch on window-slits with hollowed faces and mindless grins intent on destroying what they've lost. He crawls the wall till the steepness ends and falls into the sea.


S.H.M. is a section where the singer is being dragged into the sea as his ship sinks. He sees the ghosts of other sailors and feels the claws of the sea dragging him in, but mockingly the ghost helmsmen screams "unreal, unreal," indicating the futility of his resistance. The maelstrom of his memory is like a vampire and feeds on him.


Presence of the Night/Kosmos Tours is about the presence of death, where ghosts pinpoint him in the light. The singer wonders if anyone will mourn his death or catch his final words. False signs find him, and he doesn't want to hate; he just wants to grow. But he is alone and dying very slowly.


(Custard's) Last Stand is a section where the singer holds on to the hope that lighthouses hold the key to his liberation. He wants to walk on water and find a shore but is stuck in the middle of the ocean. Looking back over the years, he realizes that he has lost his way like a dog in the night. He chases solitary peace but holds experience that blinds him. The Clot Thickens is a section where the singer is looking for guidance and knows that he is just a man, and he can see the lemmings (colloquially used to describe herd behavior) coming, and he wonders if he should join or founder, indicating a crisis of identity.



Line by Line Meaning

Still waiting for my saviour, storms tear me limb from limb; my fingers feel like seaweed... I'm so far out I'm too far in.
I am stranded in the middle of a hostile and violent environment, waiting for someone to rescue me. However, the storms are destroying me, leaving me feeling as if my limbs are being torn away. My fingers feel weak and tenacious, like floating seaweed. I feel like I'm out in the sea to such a degree that I'm too far gone to return.


I am a lonely man, my solitude is true my eyes have borne stark witness and now my nights are numbered, too. I've seen the smiles on dead hands, the stars shine, but they're not for me.
I am entirely isolated and alone, with nothing but my experiences and my own eye to bear witness to my situation. My nights are coming to an end because of the unrelenting storms assaulting me. I've seen the evidence of death and decay all around me, whether it's the dead bodies, or the stars that are distant and cold instead of offering warmth.


I prophesy disaster and then I count the cost... I shine but, shining, dying, I know that I am almost lost.
I can feel that disaster is coming, even though I haven't yet experienced it. I can see how much this will cost in terms of my own personal losses. I may be shining and alive now, but I know that death is going to eventually take me. I'm very close to being lost to the sea forever.


I only have blunt scissors, I only have the bluntest home... I've been the witness, and the seal of death lingers in the molten wax that is my head.
I'm ill-equipped to face what's coming. I'm trapped in a lighthouse, which is the only home I have, though it is not particularly helpful or sturdy. I've seen so much death and decay that I feel somewhat like a witness to every tragedy that occurs. My head is full of the evidence of all these deaths, as if the knowledge has been melted and hardened inside it like wax.


When you see the skeletons of sailing-ship spars sinking low You'll begin to wonder if the points of all the ancients myths are solemnly directed straight at you...
As you watch the ruins of destroyed ships sink beneath the waves, it's natural to feel that the ancient stories and myths hold some meaning for you personally. When everything is lost, and there's nothing to cling to, humans have always sought comfort in legends and stories that might hold some broader truth for them.


No time now for contrition: the time for that's long past. The walls are thin as tissue and if I talk I'll crack the glass.
It's too late to regret or apologize for anything that's happened. There's simply no time left. The walls of my lighthouse are weak and paper-thin. Even talking out loud could damage or even break the glass walls entirely.


S.H.M. 'Unreal, unreal' ghost helmsmen scream and fall in through the sky, not breaking through my seagull shrieks... no breaks until I die: the spectres scratch on window-slits - hollowed faces and mindless grins only intent on destroying what they've lost.
I'm losing my grip on reality, and as I do, the ghosts of the dead and the lost come screaming into my mind. Nothing can save me from their voices, which are like the shrieking of seagulls in my head. As they scratch and gnaw at my mind, I realize that all they're after is the destruction of what they once had and never will have again.


I crawl the wall till steepness ends in the vertical fall; my pain has sailed into the sea: no joking hopes at dawn.
I head upwards, climbing higher and higher, until there's nothing else left to climb, and I fall vertically to the bottom. All my pain has vanished, and I am numb as I hit the water. There's no hope of anything better to come in the morning.


'Alone, alone' the ghosts all call, pinpoint me in the light. The only life I feel at all is the presence of the night.
All around me, I hear the ghosts of the dead asking for company. The only thing that provides me with any sense of life is the vast presence of darkness that surrounds me.


Would you cry if I died? Would you catch the final words of mine? Would you catch my words? I know that there's no time I know that there's no rhyme... false signs find me I don't want to hate, I just want to grow; why can't I let me live and be free? but I die very slowly alone.
As I wonder what will happen when I die, I can't help but wonder if anyone will mourn for me or if my last thoughts will go unheard. I know that my time is running out, but there's no poetry or sense to my last days. All that's around me are lies and false hopes. All I want is to grow and live freely and why I can't just let myself be who I am. I'm coming to terms with the death that's waiting for me, but it's a very slow and lonely process.


Where is the God that guides my hand? How can the hands of others reach me? When will I find what I grope for? Who is going to teach me? I am me / me are we / we can't see any way out of here. Crashing sea - a trophied history: Chance has lost my Guinevere...
I feel lost and adrift, with no guiding hand or higher power to help me. Even other people can't save me or reach me. I'm not sure what I'm looking for, or if anyone can teach me how to get it. I am myself, but my sense of self is confused and intertwined with others. There's no clear way out of my situation. The history of life around me is violent and chaotic, like the crashing of the sea against the shore. My chance to be with someone I care about has already been lost.


Lighthouses might house the key but can I reach the door? I want to walk on the sea so that I may better find a shore... but how can I ever keep my feet dry? I scan the horizon I must keep my eyes on all parts of me.
The lighthouses that I've relied on for safety might have some answers for me, but I'm not sure that I'll be able to take advantage of them. I'm searching for safety in a sea of danger, hoping that I'll eventually find a shore. But how can I do this without getting wet? I must be hyper-vigilant in all directions, keeping watch for danger wherever it might be.


Looking back on the years it seems that I have lost my way: Like a dog in the night, I have run to a manger now I am the stranger I stay in. All of the grief I have seen leaves me chasing solitary peace; But I hold experience in my head... I'm too close to the light I don't think I see right, for I blind me...
As I reflect on the years gone by, I can't help but feeling lost and directionless. All my running and hoping has led me nowhere. Now, trapped in my own world, I am experiencing a deep sense of isolation. The grief and despair that I've experienced make me want to retreat to my own inner world, but I know that I hold valuable experience in my head. The light inside of me is so strong that I can't even see things properly anymore, and it's blinding me to reality.


Where is the God that guides my hand? How can the hands of others reach me? When will I find what I grope for? Who is going to teach me? I am me / me are we / we can't see any way out of here. Crashing sea - a trophied history: Chance has lost my Guinevere...
I feel lost and adrift, with no guiding hand or higher power to help me. Even other people can't save me or reach me. I'm not sure what I'm looking for, or if anyone can teach me how to get it. I am myself, but my sense of self is confused and intertwined with others. There's no clear way out of my situation. The history of life around me is violent and chaotic, like the crashing of the sea against the shore. My chance to be with someone I care about has already been lost.


I don't want to be one wave in the water But sea will drag me deep One more haggard drowned man...
I don't want to be another casualty in the sea, destroyed by the waves and the currents. But I know that the sea is too powerful, and I am too weak to resist its pull for much longer. Eventually, like so many others, I will drown.




Lyrics © Warner/Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: DAVID JACKSON, HUGH ROBERT BANTON, PETER HAMMILL, PETER JOSEPH ANDREW HAMMILL

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comments from YouTube:

Retro VZQZ

The Mellotron at the end alone in this is beyond demented

Pretty sure that's a mix of some truly creative playing

And some very crafty edits

And with how hard it is to pull anything tuneful out of one those temperamental proto synths, just shows the skill and mastery on display here

Truly a twisted prog masterwork for the ages

Sublime



frettickk

[I. Eyewitness]

[Instrumental Intro]

[Verse 1]
Still waiting for my saviour
Storms tear me limb from limb
My fingers feel like seaweed
I'm so far out I'm too far in
I am a lonely man
My solitude is true
My eyes have borne stark witness
And now my knights are numbered too

I've seen the smiles on dead hands
The stars shine, but they're not for me

[Verse 2]
I prophesy disaster
And then I count the cost
I shine but, shining, dying
I know that I am almost lost
On the table lies blank paper
But my tower is built on stone
I only have blunt scissors
I only have the bluntest hone

I've been the witness, and the seal of death
Lingers in the molten wax that is my head

[Verse 3]
When you see the skeletons of sailing-ship spars sinking low
You'll begin to wonder if the points of all the ancient myths
Are solemnly directed straight at you

[II. Pictures/Lighthouse]

[Interlude]

[III. Eyewitness]

[Verse 4]
No time now for contrition
The time for that's long past
The walls are thin as tissue
And if I talk I'll crack the glass

So I only think on how it might have been
Locked in silent monologue, in silent scream

[Verse 5]
I'm much too tired to speak
And, as the waves crash on the bleak
Stones of the tower, I start to freak
And find that I am overcome

[IV. S.H.M]

[Instrumental]

[Verse 6]
"Unreal, unreal!", ghost helmsmen scream
And fall in through the sky
Not breaking through my seagull shrieks
No breaks until I die
The spectres scratch on window slits
Hollowed faces and the mindless grins
Only intent on destroying
What they've lost

[Verse 7]
I claw the wall till steepness ends in the vertical fall
My pail has sailed into the sea: no joking hopes at dawn
White bone shine in the iron-jaw mask
Lost mastheads pierce the freezing dark
And parallel my isolated tower
No paraffin for the flame
No harbour left to gain

[V. The Presence of the Night]

[Instrumental]

[Verse 8]
"Alone, alone", the ghosts all call
Pinpoint me in the light
The only life I feel at all
Is the presence of the night

[Instrumental]

[Bridge]
Would you cry if I died?
Would you cry if I died?
Would you catch the final words of mine?
Would you catch my words?
I know that there's no time
I know that there's no rhyme (False signs find me)

[Verse 9]
I don't want to hate, I just want to grow
Why can't I let me live and be free?
But I die very slowly alone
I know no more ways, I am so afraid
Myself won't let me just be myself
And so I am completely alone

[Instrumental]
[Segue]

[VI. Kosmos Tours]

[Instrumental]

[Verse 10]
The maelstrom of my memory
Is a vampire and it feeds on me
Now, staggering madly, over the brink I fall

[VII. (Custard's) Last Stand]

[Verse 11]
Lighthouses might house the key
But can I reach the door?
I want to walk on the sea
So that I may better find a shore
But how can I ever keep my feet dry?
I scan the horizon
I must keep my eyes on
All parts of me

[Verse 12]
Looking back on the years
It seems that I have lost my way
Like a dog in the night, I have run to a manger
Now I am the stranger I stay in
Oh...

[Verse 13]
All of the grief I have seen
Leaves me chasing solitary peace
But I hold experience in my head
I'm too close to the light
I don't think I see right
For I blind me

[VIII. The Clot Thickens]

[Instrumental Bridge]

[Verse 14]
Where is the God that guides my hand?
How can the hands of others reach me?
When will I find what I grope for?
Who is going to teach me?
I am me, me are we, we can't see
Any way out of here
Crashing sea, atrophied history
Chance has lost my Guinevere

[Instrumental]

[Verse 15]
I don't want to be one wave in the water
But sea will drag me deep
One more haggard drowned man!
I can see the lemmings coming
But I know I'm just a man
Do I join or do I founder?
Which can is the best I may?

[Instrumental]

[IX. Land's End (Sineline)]

[Verse 16]
Oceans drifting sideways
I am pulled into the spell
I feel you around me
I know you well
Stars slice horizons
Where the lines stand much too stark
I feel I am drowning
Hands stretch in the dark

[Verse 17]
Camps of panoply and majesty
What is Freedom of Choice?
Where do I stand in the pageantry
Whose is my voice?
It doesn't feel so very bad now
I think the end is the start
Begin to feel very glad now...

[Chorus]
All things are a part
All things are apart
All things are a part

[X. We Go Now]

[Instrumental]

[Outro]
Ohhh, ohhh, ohhh, ohhh
Ohhh, ohhh
Ohh-ooh-ooh-ooh
Ohhh, ohhh, ohhh, ohhh
Ohhh, ohhh
Ohh-ooh-ooh-ooh
Ohhh, ohhh, ohhh, ohhh
Ohhh, ohhh
Ohh-ooh-ooh-ooh
Ohhh, ohhh, ohhh, ohhh
Ohhh, ohhh
Ohh-ooh-ooh-ooh
Ohhh...



All comments from YouTube:

BoRaXiN72 - TraVeLoGGeR

Regular humans cant create such masterpiece. They are either above-human or aliens...

tripittidy

I can guarantee you that Van Der Graaf Generator have transcended humankind

BoRaXiN72 - TraVeLoGGeR

Approved

BoRaXiN72 - TraVeLoGGeR

@Quollosuru Approved

Vasilis Lakerdas

​@tripittidy❤

1 More Replies...

Leonardo Capponi

Am I the only one that can't make it to the end without crying? This is one of my favorite tracks of all time, the lyrics and the music are just so powerful and emotional, and they also hit closely to me. Peter Hammill is one of the greatest musicians of all time and him having almost not recognition at all feels so wrong

Пигля Свантесон

Same emotions here❤

WatcherOfTheSkies

This song is about a very lonely lighthouse keeper who is of high class. He has gone completely mad from his solitude and mental anguish that he has suffered from. His wife died and he blames himself for it and can't forgive himself. He sees hallucinations and ghosts that want to kill him. He supposedly also accidentally killed a couple of sailors by not showing them the way via the lighthouse's shining light. He feels regret towards everything he has done during his miserable life and wants to end it all. At the very end he finds potential friends (the lemmings that represent humanity), but doesn't feel like he belongs anymore. Since he is so batshit crazy and depressed, he kills himself in the end and believes that he is now with his long dead wife. What a masterpiece this song is. A very dark, depressing masterpiece...

ywnbaw

Maximilian Bernard de wey is too hard for him to show de saylors

Scott Baldwin

Also a song that realistically shows just how devastating depression can be, as someone who suffers from it.

More Comments

More Versions