I Could Have Told You So
Esther Phillips Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

I could have told you she would hurt you,
She'd love you awhile and desert you,
If only you'd asked I could have told you so!
I could have saved you some crying,
Yes, I could have told you she was lying,
But you were in love and you didn't want to know.

I hear her now as I toss and turn and try to sleep,
I hear her now making promises she'll never keep;
And now it's over and done with,
She'll find someone new to have fun with!
Through all of my tears I could have told you so.

And now it's over and done with,
She'll find someone new to have fun with!




Through all of my tears I could have told you so,
Through all of my tears I could have told you so.

Overall Meaning

In Esther Phillips's song "I Could Have Told You So", the singer expresses regret for not warning their friend about a lover who they knew would eventually hurt and deceive them. The singer laments that they could have saved their friend from heartbreak and tears if only they had spoken up. Despite their own tears of sorrow, the singer is not surprised that the relationship has ended, as they had always known that the lover would move on to find someone new to have fun with.


The lyrics convey a sense of regret and helplessness that is relatable to anyone who has watched a loved one willfully ignore red flags in a relationship. The song's slow, mournful melody and Phillip's soulful delivery emphasize the sadness and poignancy of the lyrics.


Interestingly, the song was actually written by Columbia Records executive, George Avakian, under the pseudonym "P.D.Q. Bach". Avakian has stated that he wrote the song as a response to Frank Sinatra's album "In the Wee Small Hours", which he felt lacked a strong narrative flow. The song has since been covered by several artists, including Sinatra himself.


Line by Line Meaning

I could have told you she would hurt you,
I knew that she was going to cause you pain.


She'd love you awhile and desert you,
She would show you affection for some time before abandoning you.


If only you'd asked I could have told you so!
If you had asked me, I would have revealed the truth to you.


I could have saved you some crying,
I could have prevented you from shedding tears.


Yes, I could have told you she was lying,
I was aware that she was deceiving you.


But you were in love and you didn't want to know.
Despite my warning, you chose to ignore my advice due to your love for her.


I hear her now as I toss and turn and try to sleep,
I am haunted by her voice as I struggle to sleep.


I hear her now making promises she'll never keep;
She is still making false promises that she will not fulfill in the future.


And now it's over and done with,
The relationship is now over and finished.


She'll find someone new to have fun with!
She will soon find another person to entertain her.


Through all of my tears I could have told you so.
I am shedding tears now, but I could have warned you about the outcome of the relationship.


And now it's over and done with,
The relationship has come to a close.


She'll find someone new to have fun with!
She will soon find another partner to enjoy herself with.


Through all of my tears I could have told you so,
Despite my own emotional pain, I know that I could have warned you.




Lyrics © OBO APRA/AMCOS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

hotbananas

Thanks for this , sadly this lovely lady is so underappreciated. Esther we love you.

Debra Garza

I grew up on this lovely ladies music Lord have mercy she's got so many more that are just as great listen to let me in your life on my God that'll tear you up

Therone Dawson

OMG, what a fantastic,fabulous and beautiful singer. She sings this song with so much soul. I am crying. She certain told me with this song.

706

Just did a show with the beatles like it was just another gig . She is the 🐐. Go mrs Esther

hotbananas

Still love you Esther , you will never be forgotten.

fabrici o

Esto es cantar, qué maravilloso canta! Increíble 😍

Eleonora Zichinolfi

in that time ,there were a lot of great singers,today of great singers are very few

Claudio Piscitelli

Dios mio,cuanta belleza lo podría escuchar 10000 veces por día

Tommy Bankston

I'm actually really, REALLY SHOCKED that NO ONE HAS COMMENTED ABOUT THIS SONG. This is exquisite, with so much emotion. "I Could Have Told You" was composed by the late Jimmy Van Heusen, with lyrics by the late Carl Sigman. Esther Phillips rendition of this standard is sung with raw and smoldering brilliance. Thank you for posting one of my favorites.

Brent Dillahunty

Thank you for your wealth of information, much appreciated!

More Comments

More Versions