Detroit Or Buffalo
Melanie Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

People expect you to fall
Hit that same old wall
Really they don't wanna help at all
They talk behind your back today
They shake their heads and say
Gee I always knew that the girl would come to no good anyway

God knows everybody's gotta go sometime
And I'm taking the train to the end of the line, yeah
Missin' that boy a mile at a time

I haven't been too well myself
Too much time upon the shelf
Sayin' that I don't need help when I do, I do
Still I think I'm gonna be just fine
A lot of friends a little wine
Still I'm wishing I could see you again sometime

Gonna pack my bags and go to Detroit or Buffalo
And if anybody wants to know where, you don't know, you don't know
God knows everybody's gotta go sometime
And I'm taking the train to the end of the line, yeah
Missing that boy a mile at a time

It's hard to open up that door
Like you've done so many times before
Sometimes you think you just can't do this anymore
Then you take a chance and take a train
Out into the pouring rain
When all you got there is your suitcase full of pain

Gonna pack my bags and go Detroit or Buffalo
And if anybody wants to know where, you don't know, you don't know
God knows everybody's gotta go sometime




And I'm taking the train to the end of the line, yeah
Missing that boy a mile at a time

Overall Meaning

"Detroit or Buffalo" is a song by singer-songwriter Melanie from her 1972 album, "Garden in the City". The song speaks about one's struggle with life and how "people expect you to fall" and "hit that same old wall" with no desire to help. However, despite facing challenges and criticism, the singer takes a train to the end of the line, either to Detroit or Buffalo, in search of something better. The song conveys a sense of restlessness and hopelessness, yet also touches on the idea of taking a leap of faith and embracing the unknown.


The lyrics suggest that the singer is going through a difficult time and that people are judging her based on her failures. She may be struggling with her mental health, as she admits that she "hasn't been too well" and needs help, even though she denies it to others. The line "when all you got there is your suitcase full of pain" suggests that she is carrying emotional baggage that she wants to leave behind. Despite everything, the singer still has hope and believes that she will be "just fine", with the help of "a lot of friends and a little wine".


The chorus repeats the phrase "God knows everybody's gotta go sometime" and emphasizes the singer's desire to escape and start anew. The line "missing that boy a mile at a time" suggests that the singer may have lost someone important to her, but she is gradually moving forward. The ambiguity of whether she is going to Detroit or Buffalo adds to the uncertainty and unpredictability of her journey.


Line by Line Meaning

People expect you to fall
People anticipate your failure


Hit that same old wall
Encounter the same obstacles as before


Really they don't wanna help at all
They don't want to help you


They talk behind your back today
They speak about you in secret and negatively in present time


They shake their heads and say
They disapprove and verbally express that opinion


Gee I always knew that the girl would come to no good anyway
They always expected you to fail


God knows everybody's gotta go sometime
Death is inevitable for everyone


And I'm taking the train to the end of the line, yeah
I'm going all the way to the end


Missin' that boy a mile at a time
Missing that boy little by little


I haven't been too well myself
I haven't been doing well either


Too much time upon the shelf
Been idle for too long


Sayin' that I don't need help when I do, I do
I pretend that I don't need help when I really do


Still I think I'm gonna be just fine
Despite my struggles, I believe I'll be okay


A lot of friends a little wine
Have many friends and a little alcohol


Still I'm wishing I could see you again sometime
I still desire to see you again


It's hard to open up that door
Challenging to take action


Like you've done so many times before
Like you've faced the same challenges many times


Sometimes you think you just can't do this anymore
Occasionally you doubt your abilities


Then you take a chance and take a train
Then you take a risk and depart


Out into the pouring rain
Into the rainstorm


When all you got there is your suitcase full of pain
All you have is your baggage filled with pain


Gonna pack my bags and go Detroit or Buffalo
I'm going to pack and leave to Detroit or Buffalo


And if anybody wants to know where, you don't know, you don't know
And if someone asks where I'm going, I won't say


Missing that boy a mile at a time
Missing that boy bit by bit




Contributed by Violet V. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions