You & I
Original Off-Broadway Cast Lyrics

The lyrics of "You & I" by the Original Off-Broadway Cast convey a sense of vulnerability and uncertainty in a relationship. The opening lines express the singer's acknowledgment that they are flawed and may bring chaos or disaster to the relationship. They feel unsure about how to navigate the beginning of the relationship, wishing to skip ahead to a more comfortable stage. This showcases their lack of experience or fear of commitment.

Repeating the phrase "I should tell you" emphasizes the internal struggle the singer is facing. They likely have important feelings or information they want to share with their partner but are hesitant or unsure of how to express themselves. This repetition reflects their inner dialogue, as they question their own ability to communicate effectively.

The verses continue with the singer confessing their past mistakes and actions, such as blowing out a metaphorical candle to gain re-entry or doing something hurtful to regain the relationship's spark. The mention of a "forgotten smile" suggests that the singer had lost their joyfulness until their partner's presence sparked something within them, possibly infusing their life with happiness again.

The bridge section questions the future while playing with words. Asking "Who knows where? Who goes there?" reflects the uncertainty that comes with embarking on a new relationship. The repetition of "Here goes" suggests a mix of excitement and anxiety as the singer takes a leap of faith into the unknown, indicating a willingness to trust their desires and venture out of their comfort zone.

The final lines of the song reflect a juxtaposition of conflicting emotions. The singer acknowledges the risk involved in pursuing this relationship, referencing walking through fire without being burned. They find comfort in the support of their partner, symbolized by clinging to their shoulder, despite the pain that may arise from their interactions. This emotional turmoil is captured by the phrase "stinging and older, asleep on pins."

In conclusion, "You & I" by the Original Off-Broadway Cast lyrically explores the vulnerability, uncertainty, and excitement that accompany the beginning stages of a relationship. The song expresses the fragility of the singer's self-image and their willingness to take a leap of faith in pursuit of connection and happiness. Ultimately, it portrays the internal dialogue and conflicting emotions that arise when embarking on a new romantic journey.