Bells of Rhymney
Pete Seeger Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Oh what can you give me?
Say the sad bells of Rhymney
Is there hope for the future?
Cry the brown bells of Merthyr
Who made the mine owner?
Say the black bells of Rhonda
And who robbed the miner?
Cry the grim bells of Blaina

They will plunder willy-nilly,
Cry the bells of Caerphilly
They have fangs, they have teeth,
Say the loud bells of Neathe
Even God is uneasy,
Say the moist bells of Swansea
They will plunder willy-nilly,
Say the bells of Caerphilly

Put the vandals in court,
Say the bells of Newport
All would be well if, if, if,
Cry the green bells of Cardiff
Why so worried, sisters, why?
Sang the silver bells of Wye




And what will you give me?
Say the sad bells of Rhymney

Overall Meaning

The Bells of Rhymney is a protest song written by Welsh poet Idris Davies and later adapted to music by Pete Seeger. The song paints a bleak picture of the Welsh mining industry in the mid-20th century, with each set of bells representing different aspects of the struggles faced by the miners and their families. The opening lines, "Oh what can you give me? Say the sad bells of Rhymney" could be interpreted as a cry for help or a call to action from those who have the power to help the miners.


The brown bells of Merthyr ask "Is there hope for the future?" which implies a sense of hopelessness and despair. The black bells of Rhonda then ask "Who made the mine owner?" suggesting that the miners are victims of a wider system that exploits them. The grim bells of Blaina then cry "And who robbed the miner?" which is a direct accusation of exploitation and mistreatment. The song is essentially an indictment of the coal industry and the powers that be who profit from the dangerous and grueling work required of the miners.


Throughout the song, the bells continue to express the struggles of the miners, with the bells of Caerphilly crying that the miners will be plundered willy-nilly, and even God feeling uneasy according to the moist bells of Swansea. The silver bells of Wye offer a hopeful question to the sisters, asking "Why so worried, sisters, why?" but ultimately the sad bells of Rhymney return, asking again "And what will you give me?" The song is a powerful statement of protest, highlighting the political and economic struggles faced by the miners in Wales during this time.


Line by Line Meaning

Oh what can you give me?
The singer asks what the bells of Rhymney can give to him.


Say the sad bells of Rhymney
The bells of Rhymney respond to the singer's query in a melancholy way.


Is there hope for the future?
The bells of Merthyr wonder if there is any hope for the future.


Cry the brown bells of Merthyr
The bells of Merthyr cry out in sorrow.


Who made the mine owner?
The artist questions who created the mine owner.


Say the black bells of Rhonda
The bells of Rhonda answer the singer's question about who made the mine owner.


And who robbed the miner?
The singer asks who is responsible for stealing from the miner.


Cry the grim bells of Blaina
The bells of Blaina cry out in sadness at the plight of the miner.


They will plunder willy-nilly,
The bells of Caerphilly warn that the plunderers will take everything without regard.


Cry the bells of Caerphilly
The bells of Caerphilly cry out as they express this warning.


They have fangs, they have teeth,
The loud bells of Neathe speak about the aggressiveness of the plunderers.


Say the loud bells of Neathe
The bells of Neathe repeat this warning to the artist.


Even God is uneasy,
The moist bells of Swansea suggest that even God is disturbed by this injustice.


Say the moist bells of Swansea
The bells of Swansea declare this fact to the singer.


They will plunder willy-nilly,
The bells of Caerphilly repeat their warning to the singer.


Say the bells of Caerphilly
The bells of Caerphilly reiterate their warning yet again.


Put the vandals in court,
The bells of Newport suggest that the vandals responsible for the injustice should be held accountable by the legal system.


Say the bells of Newport
The bells of Newport express this idea to the singer.


All would be well if, if, if,
The green bells of Cardiff offer a conditional statement, suggesting that if certain changes were made, things would improve.


Cry the green bells of Cardiff
The bells of Cardiff cry out in hope for change.


Why so worried, sisters, why?
The silver bells of Wye ask why the artist and others are so concerned.


Sang the silver bells of Wye
The bells of Wye sing out this question.


And what will you give me?
The singer repeats his initial question to the bells of Rhymney, wondering what they have to offer.


Say the sad bells of Rhymney
The bells of Rhymney offer no answer, as they remain resigned to their sadness.




Lyrics © O/B/O APRA AMCOS
Written by: Idris Davies, Pete Seeger

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

Gaynor Rogers

As a Welsh woman living here in Wales this song is awesome, especially when I think it's been heard all over the world and sung by so many. Thanks Mr Seeger. X

Joshua Woods

it's really special isn't it. Cymru am byth!

Gianvittore De Boni

I love Wales. Here Pete gives the welsh people a wonderful gift.

Terry Donegan

My friend Jason does a version of this. Please checkout Faithman meets world

banjoonthelump

This song is a poem titled, XV, written by injured Welsh miner, Idris Davies, and published in a book of poetry in 1938 titled, Gwalia Deserta. Thank you Pete for putting it to music.

Mark Sisto

He took ownership, copyrighted it, like he did Turn Turn Turn, and like he Guantanamera , and Lion Sleeps.. The communist copyrighted the way to the capitalist bank. $ $ $ $

Potemkin0

@Mark Sisto Perhaps ... but reading recently if my memory serves me correctly I believe he did ask Mrs Davies (Idris' widow) for permission to use the poem to write the song. If I'm wrong here, then please correct me.

Potemkin0

Just checked in his "Bells of Rhymney" songbook:- Words by Idris Davies, Music by Pete Seeger Copyright 1959 by Ludlow Music Inc. Used by permission
Also the authors and composers of Guantanamera are credited together with Used by permission
For Turn, Turn, Turn the words are from the Book of Ecclesiastes with music by Pete Seeger Copyright 1962 by Melody Trails Inc. Used by permission.
No information on Lion Sleeps
(Although of course both 'Inc' companies could have been owned by Pete at the time ...)

Roger Davies

@Potemkin0 Why did the person above want to believe the worst of a left wing person? Is it out of a reflexive hatred of the left? Why assume Seegar would not have used the words with permission without even bothering to check?

Marianne from Abergavenny near Merthyr using Roger's computer with permission.

Potemkin0

@Roger Davies For an definitive answer to your question Marianne from Aber, you must ask Mark, but personally, I think he's got an axe to grind. My attempt to vocalize 'Rhymney' derives from listening to the Cardiffians who would put pronounce the 'h' after the 'R' to sound posher than folks from the Valleys!

7 More Replies...
More Comments

More Versions