The Carroll County Accident
Porter Wagoner Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Carroll County's pointed out as kind of square
The biggest thing that happens is the county fair
I guess that's why it seemed like such a big event
What we all call the Carroll County accident

The wreck was on the highway just inside the line
Walter Browning lost his life and for a time
It seemed that Mary Ellen Jones would surely die
But she lived long enough for her to testify

Walter Browning was a happy married man
And he wore a golden wedding ring upon his hand
But it was gone, nobody knew just where it went
He lost it in the Carroll County accident

Mary Ellen testified he flagged her down
Said he was sick and could she drive him into town
No one even doubted what she said was true
'Cause she was well respected in the county too

I went down to see the wreck like all the rest
The bloody seats, the broken glass, the tangled mess
But I found something no one else had even seen
Behind the dash, in Mary's crumpled up machine

A little match box circled by a rubber band
And inside, the ring from Walter Browning's hand
It took a while to figure out just what it meant
The truth about the Carroll County accident

By dark of night, I dropped the ring into a well
And took a sacred oath that I would never tell
The truth about the Carroll County accident
'Cause the County ordered dad a marble monument





I lost him in the Carroll County accident

Overall Meaning

Porter Wagoner's "The Carroll County Accident" tells the story of a car accident that occurred in a small town in Carroll County. The song describes the town as being "kind of square," with the biggest event being the annual county fair. However, the accident was a particularly significant event in the town, likely due to the loss of life that occurred.


The accident involved a man named Walter Browning, who lost his life, and Mary Ellen Jones, who was severely injured. Mary Ellen later testified that Walter had flagged her down and asked her to drive him into town, indicating that he was sick. She was a respected figure in the county, and her testimony was considered truthful.


However, the song reveals that there was more to the story than met the eye. The singer of the song went to the accident site and found a matchbox with Walter's wedding ring inside. It took some time to piece together what it meant, but the truth eventually came out. Walter had been having an affair with Mary Ellen, and the ring had come off during the accident. The singer takes the ring and drops it into a well, taking an oath never to tell the truth about the accident, as the town had ordered a monument for Walter and did not want to tarnish his memory.


Overall, the song depicts a small town where secrets are kept and affairs are hidden. The accident was a tragic event that ultimately revealed more about the town's residents than anyone had anticipated.


Line by Line Meaning

Carroll County's pointed out as kind of square
Carroll County is seen as a rural and uneventful place


The biggest thing that happens is the county fair
The county fair is the most attended event in the area


I guess that's why it seemed like such a big event
Because nothing much happens, a car accident became a big event for the people in the area


What we all call the Carroll County accident
The car accident is now known as the Carroll County accident and is remembered by everyone in the county


The wreck was on the highway just inside the line
The car accident occurred near the county border


Walter Browning lost his life and for a time
Walter Browning died as a result of the car crash


It seemed that Mary Ellen Jones would surely die
Mary Ellen Jones was badly injured and it was assumed she may not survive


But she lived long enough for her to testify
Mary Ellen Jones survived long enough to give her testimony about the events leading to the car crash


Walter Browning was a happy married man
Walter Browning was content in his marriage


And he wore a golden wedding ring upon his hand
Walter Browning had a wedding ring on his hand made of gold


But it was gone, nobody knew just where it went
After the car accident, Walter Browning's wedding ring went missing and its whereabouts were unknown


He lost it in the Carroll County accident
It's believed that Walter Browning's wedding ring was lost or removed during the car accident


Mary Ellen testified he flagged her down
Mary Ellen Jones stated that Walter Browning stopped her car and asked her for a ride


Said he was sick and could she drive him into town
Walter Browning told Mary Ellen Jones that he was unwell and asked for a ride to town


No one even doubted what she said was true
Mary Ellen's testimony was credible and accepted by people in the county


'Cause she was well respected in the county too
Mary Ellen was a well-respected member of the community


I went down to see the wreck like all the rest
The artist went to the site of the car accident to inspect it like everyone else in the county


The bloody seats, the broken glass, the tangled mess
The scene of the car accident was gruesome, with blood, broken glass, and the car in pieces


But I found something no one else had even seen
The singer discovered something nobody else had noticed before


Behind the dash, in Mary's crumpled up machine
The artist found an object behind the dashboard of Mary Ellen Jones' car


A little match box circled by a rubber band
Inside the car, the artist found a small box wrapped in a rubber band


And inside, the ring from Walter Browning's hand
The small box contained Walter Browning's wedding ring


It took a while to figure out just what it meant
It wasn't immediately clear how Walter Browning's wedding ring ended up in Mary Ellen Jones' car


The truth about the Carroll County accident
The discovery of the wedding ring finally revealed what really happened during the car accident


By dark of night, I dropped the ring into a well
To protect the reputations of those involved, the singer disposed of the wedding ring by dropping it into a well


And took a sacred oath that I would never tell
The singer promised to never reveal the truth about what happened during the car accident


The truth about the Carroll County accident
The singer is referencing the secret they have about the events that transpired during the car accident


'Cause the County ordered dad a marble monument
The county created a monument in memory of the artist's father who died in the car accident


I lost him in the Carroll County accident
The artist's father was killed in the Carroll County accident




Lyrics © Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC
Written by: Bob Ferguson

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comment from YouTube:

@sauquoit13456

On this day in 1969 {January 5th} Porter Wagoner's "The Carroll County Accident" peaked at #2* {for 4 weeks} on Billboard's Hot Country Singles chart, for the four weeks it was at #2, the #1 record for those four weeks was "Daddy Sang Bass" by Johnny Cash...
And on February 3rd, 1969 "The Carroll County Accident" reached #1 {for 3 weeks} on the Canadian RPM Country Singles chart...
Between 1954 and 1983 the West Plains, Missouri had fifty-eight records on the Billboard Country charts, fourteen made the Top 10 with two reaching #1, "A Satisfied Mind" for four weeks in July of 1955 and "Misery Loves Company" for two non-consecutive weeks in March of 1962...
Porter Wayne Wagoner passed away at the age of 80 on October 28th, 2007...
May he R.I.P.
* "The Carroll County Accident" was Porter Wagoner's second of two of his records to peak at #2, his other #2 record was "Cold Hard Facts of Life" for one week in April of 1967...
Plus in a duet with Dolly Parton he had a third record peak at #2, "Making Plans", for two weeks in August of 1980...
And from the 'For What It's Worth' department, the remainder of the Hot Country Singles' Top 10 on January 5th. 1969:
At #3. "I Take A Lot of Pride In What I Am" by Merle Haggard & the Strangers
#4. "When The Grass Grows Over Me" by George Jones
#5. "Smokey Bear" by Hank Thompson
#6. "Wichita Lineman" by Glen Campbell
#7. "Your Squaw Is On The Warpath" by Loretta Lynn
#8. "Yours Love" by Waylon Jennings
#9. "The Ballad of Forty Dollars" by Tom T. Hall
#10. "They Don't Make Love Like They Used To" by Eddy Arnold



All comments from YouTube:

@lindamitchum454

I Loved To Hear Porter Wagner Sing.. I Miss COUNTRY SONGS❤

@beverlymccollum8861

Such a great pleasure hearing Porter sing. These older songs are the best. Aren't like the silly ones we endure today.

@markowen3114

Hello dear,how’re you doing? Greetings from California 😊

@blackholeentry3489

Once saw him play in Branson, MO.

@auntkiki82

I miss country songs like this that actually told a story.

@larryduvall9475

white mans blues of that era

@mackbrowning5464

It reminds me of my dad his name is Browning also

@mackbrowning5464

Yep

@itislona5868

Yes

@lorettajohns1555

​@@larryduvall9475 😊

1 More Replies...
More Comments

More Versions