I'm Not Your Girl
Reba McEntire Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Felt so right for awhile, almost really believed
I could stay here forever, my heart could be free
Oh I wish it were that easy, but it's never been for me
I'm not your girl

Feels so warm and so safe here, now don't get me wrong
But it's selfish to stay here, I'd be leading you on
Maybe someone else can give you
What you really, really want
I'm not your girl

They say people change
I wish it were true
It's something I've tried so hard to do
I can't explain
Why right feels so wrong
And I keep hearing the same old song

See, I've been here before, left a good thing behind
Can't see where I'm going, maybe love's really blind
I'm so afraid to lose the one, who was so hard to find
But I'm not your girl

They say people change
I wish it were true
It's something I've tried so hard to do
I can't explain
Why right feels so wrong
And I keep hearing the same old song

One day I'll come back here, and I'll knock at your door
She'll be sweet when she answers, then I'll know for sure




That life is never easy, in my complicated world
I'm not your girl

Overall Meaning

Reba McEntire's "I'm Not Your Girl" is a heart-wrenching country song about a woman who had a short-lived relationship that felt so right but quickly realized that it wasn't meant to be. The verses describe the woman's time with her partner in a moment of solace and passion, but soon, she realized that she cannot stay there forever. The song's chorus says that she is not his girl, and although she wishes that changing was easy, she hasn't been able to, and what feels right is still wrong.


The lyricist's message echoes universal themes of love, loss, and self-discovery, exploring heartbreak and the difficulty to be honest with oneself and loved ones in realizing that their relationship is not right. She has to leave to find better for herself and the partner who deserves to be with someone who can provide what they need out of a relationship. However, she fears that she may lose him and hurt him in the process of letting him go, but she can't be his girl because that's not who she is.


Overall, this song is a reminder that sometimes we need to take a step back from a relationship and realize that it's not the best path forward. It's a mature decision, but it's the right one for everyone involved.


Line by Line Meaning

Felt so right for awhile, almost really believed
I was comfortable here for a short while and convinced myself that I could stay longer, but it's not that simple.


I could stay here forever, my heart could be free
I thought that being here could set me free emotionally, but it's not that easy.


Oh I wish it were that easy, but it's never been for me
As much as I want to stay and be free, it's never really worked out for me.


I'm not your girl
I'm not the woman you're hoping to have a relationship with.


Feels so warm and so safe here, now don't get me wrong
Being here is comforting, but it would be selfish of me to stay when I'm not committed to you.


But it's selfish to stay here, I'd be leading you on
Staying here when I'm not interested in having a relationship with you would be unfair and misleading.


Maybe someone else can give you What you really, really want
Perhaps you'll find someone else who can give you what you're looking for.


They say people change I wish it were true It's something I've tried so hard to do
I've heard that people can change, and I want to change myself, but it's difficult.


I can't explain Why right feels so wrong And I keep hearing the same old song
I don't understand why the right decision feels so uncomfortable, and I keep facing the same situation repeatedly.


See, I've been here before, left a good thing behind Can't see where I'm going, maybe love's really blind
I've been in similar situations where I left a good relationship behind, and now I'm unsure which direction to take, perhaps love truly is blind.


I'm so afraid to lose the one, who was so hard to find But I'm not your girl
I don't want to lose someone that took me a long time to find, but I'm not interested in being in a relationship with you.


One day I'll come back here, and I'll knock at your door She'll be sweet when she answers, then I'll know for sure That life is never easy, in my complicated world I'm not your girl
Someday I may return, and if someone else is at the door when I come, it will confirm that life is complex, and I still won't be interested in a relationship with you.




Lyrics © Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC, Kobalt Music Publishing Ltd.
Written by: SHELLY PEIKEN, ERIC SILVER

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions