Why Can
Reba McEntire Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

He takes me to the places you and I use to go
He tells me over and over that he loves me so
He gives me love that I never got from you
He loves me too

His love is true
But why can't he be you
He never fails to call and tell me I'm on his mind
And I'm lucky to have such a guy I hear it all the time
And he does all the things that you would never do

He loves me too
His love is true
But why can't he be you
Oh he's not the one who dominates my mind and my soul

And I should love him so 'cause he loves me I know
But his kisses leave me cold
He sends me flowers
Calls on the hour
Just to prove his love
And my friends say that when he's around
I'm all he speaks of
And he does all the things that you would never do

He loves me too




His love is true
But why can't he be you

Overall Meaning

Reba McEntire's song Why Can't He Be You is a heartbreaking tale of a woman in a new relationship who is struggling to forget her previous love. In the song, she describes how her new partner does everything to show his love for her, but his affection cannot fill the void left by her ex-lover. The singer reminisces about the times she used to share with her former partner and how no matter how hard she tries to forget him, she can't seem to do so. Reba tells her new partner that his love is true but still wonders why he can't be her first love. She further explains that even though her current partner does everything right, his kisses fail to move her emotionally.


The song deals with the theme of love and heartbreak, and it is relatable to anyone who has ever suffered a break-up. The song represents the dilemma of many people in a new relationship after experiencing heartbreak. It portrays the aftermath of a broken relationship when one is trying to move on but is finding it challenging to forget the past. Even though the new partner is doing everything to show their love and be faithful, the singer cannot help but compare them to her former lover.


The chorus of the song, "But why can't he be you", captures the emotions of the singer and the frustration of being unable to get what she once had. The lyrics, "He does all the things that you would never do" show how the current lover does everything right but still cannot measure up to the previous lover.


Line by Line Meaning

He takes me to the places you and I use to go
He takes me to the same places that you and I used to go to


He tells me over and over that he loves me so
He repeatedly expresses his love towards me


He gives me love that I never got from you
His love for me is different from what you had given me


He loves me too
He loves me back


His love is true
His love is sincere


But why can't he be you
I wish he could be more like you


He never fails to call and tell me I'm on his mind
He always remembers to call me and let me know that he's thinking about me


And I'm lucky to have such a guy I hear it all the time
People around me keep telling me how lucky I am to have him


And he does all the things that you would never do
He does things for me that you never did


Oh he's not the one who dominates my mind and my soul
He's not constantly on my mind and in my thoughts like you are


And I should love him so 'cause he loves me I know
I know that I should love him back because he loves me


But his kisses leave me cold
His kisses don't make me feel the same as yours did


He sends me flowers
He gives me flowers as a gesture of his love


Calls on the hour
He calls me constantly throughout the day


Just to prove his love
He calls me to show me how much he loves me


And my friends say that when he's around I'm all he speaks of
My friends notice that he talks about me a lot when he's around them




Lyrics Β© Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC
Written by: HANK COCHRAN

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@jeffj4440

Fantastic video! Thank you for posting!

@suewalker3600

Great job on this Patsy Cline song. Reba was really young here

@grandmahicksvideocollection

Yes she was. Early twenties. Pretty rare stuff.

@marandalawson3604

πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έβ€πŸŽ‰πŸ˜’

@henilosalimatoa966

Reba McEntire you are and angle πŸ˜‡πŸ™πŸ™Œ with three 🌟 star πŸ’« love πŸ’• you

More Versions