This Girl Black Girl
The Go-Betweens Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

They′ll always tell you that nothing is the worst
That this hunger that you're feeling
Can be passed off as thirst
Then they′ll turn and tell you not to leave the hearse
And these lilies of the air are just your family curse
This girl, that girl she counts the hours
This girl, black girl she wears flowers
The ship comes through the harbour
The sails wear the sun
The captain nodded slowly and assembled everyone
The matron clears her throat to sing
The doctor takes a drink
Down below the convicts fall
Because skeletons don't think




This girl, that girl she counts the hours
This girl, black girl she wears flowers

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of The Go-Betweens' song "This Girl Black Girl" delve into societal expectations and the repression of individuality. The first verse criticizes the idea that "nothing is the worst," suggesting that it's a dismissive way of invalidating one's emotions and desires. The second line draws the metaphorical parallel between hunger and thirst, further emphasizing the idea that one's true desires may be suppressed or ignored. Continuing with this idea, the third line tells the listener not to "leave the hearse," implying that one's true self may be buried and invisible to the world. Lastly, the final line of the verse speaks to a generational curse that may be passed down within a family, furthering the idea that pre-existing societal structures and expectations can limit personal growth.


In the following verse, the lyrics contrast the monotony of daily life with the hopeful imagery of a ship sailing through a harbor. The captain nods slowly and assembles everyone, suggesting that this is a moment of collective anticipation and purpose. However, the reflection is short-lived as the matron clears her throat to sing and the doctor takes a drink, emphasizing how easily hopes and dreams can be squashed by routine and hierarchies. The final line of the verse, "Because skeletons don't think," is perhaps the most poignant, effectively communicating the idea that society has stripped away any semblance of individuality or personal agency.


Line by Line Meaning

They'll always tell you that nothing is the worst
People will try to minimize your struggles and tell you that they are not that bad.


That this hunger that you're feeling
The strong desire you have is being downplayed by others.


Can be passed off as thirst
Others are suggesting that what you really want is something else entirely.


Then they'll turn and tell you not to leave the hearse
Even though they claim to understand, they will still tell you to stay in a situation that is harmful to you.


And these lilies of the air are just your family curse
You are being told that your problems are genetic or inherited, and therefore out of your control.


This girl, that girl she counts the hours
Two different girls are waiting and measuring their time until something important happens.


This girl, black girl she wears flowers
One of the girls is black and she is adorned with flowers, potentially signifying hope or beauty in the midst of struggle.


The ship comes through the harbour
A ship has arrived at the harbor.


The sails wear the sun
The sails are reflecting the light of the sun.


The captain nodded slowly and assembled everyone
The captain took charge and gathered everyone together.


The matron clears her throat to sing
The older woman in charge prepares to sing a song.


The doctor takes a drink
The doctor takes a break to have a drink.


Down below the convicts fall
The people who are imprisoned or punished suffer and fall.


Because skeletons don't think
The prisoners are not being treated as thinking individuals or humans with thoughts and feelings.


This girl, that girl she counts the hours
Two girls are still waiting and counting the time until something happens.


This girl, black girl she wears flowers
The same black girl is still wearing flowers and potentially finding hope or beauty in the midst of waiting and suffering.




Writer(s): Robert Derwent Garth Forster, Grant William Mclennan

Contributed by Jack F. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

@freudastaire

best damn extra track of all remastered albums with bonus extra tracks of all records in the world

@andreaneilcmc

They'll always tell you that nothing is the worst
That this hunger that you're feeling
Can be passed off as thirst

@Timmybear

Lindy's drumming, as usual, provides such brilliance to this catchy tune. I will never understand who decides what's played on the radio (I gave up trying to figure it out when I was 17, and haven't listened since).

@julesbrownoffthecuffreview3875

Beautiful song ❤

@discombobulator64

I've got this on 7' vinyl on the b-side to Man O' Sand to Girl O' Sea, I think I played this more than the a-side at the time

@misiurska

I always loved this song much more than many other from SHF.

@TheBalthus1

Magnificent...

@han444

Great

@oldmcmetal3688

An earwig for eternity

@philjames5763

In a parallel world The Go-Betweens and The Replacements would have been massive and the big hair, spandex wearing metalheads would never have escaped from The Rainbow Bar and Grill.Am happy that cool, dog loving Izzy made his pile though. 

More Comments

More Versions