Pierre & Anatole
The Great Comet Original Cast Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

PIERRE
You promised Countless Rostova to marry her and were about to elope, is that so?

ANATOLE
Mon cher
I don′t consider myself bound to answer questions put to me in that tone

PIERRE
My face, already pale
Becomes distorted by fury
I seize you by the collar with my big big hands
And I shake you from side to side
Until your face shows a sufficient degree of terror
When I tell you I must talk to you!

ANATOLE
Come now, this is stupid!
What what don't don′t!

PIERRE
You're a scoundrel and a blackguard
And I don't know what deprives me of the pleasure
Of smashing your head in with this!
Did you promise to marry her?

ANATOLE
I didn′t think of it. I never promised, because -

PIERRE
Have you any letters of hers?
Any letters?
I shan′t be violent, don't be afraid
First, the letters
Second, tomorrow you must get out of Moscow

ANATOLE
But how can I?

PIERRE
Third
You must never breathe a word of what has happened between you and the Countess
Now I know I can′t prevent your doing so
But if you have a spark of conscience
Pierre paces the room several times in silence

ANATOLE
Anatole sits at a table frowning and biting his lips

PIERRE
After all, you must understand
That besides your pleasure
There is such a thing as other people, and their happiness and peace
And that you are ruining a whole life
For the sake of amusing yourself!
Amuse yourself with women like my wife
With them you're within your rights
But to promise a young girl to marry her
To deceive, to kidnap
Why don′t you understand that that's as cruel as beating an old man or a child?

ANATOLE
Well I don′t know about that, eh?
I don't know that and I don't want to
But you have used such words to me
′Scoundrel′ and so on
Which as a man of honor I will not allow anyone to use

PIERRE
Is it satisfaction you want?

ANATOLE
You could at least take back your words, eh?
If you want me to do as you wish?

PIERRE
Fine I take them back, I take them back!
And I ask you to forgive me
And if you require money for your journey -

ANATOLE
Anatole smiled
The reflection of that base and cringing smile
Which Pierre knew so well in his wife
Revolted him

PIERRE
Oh, vile and heartless brood!

ANATOLE




Next day Anatole left
For Petersburg!

Overall Meaning

The lyrics to the song "Pierre & Anatole" are a conversation between Pierre and Anatole where Pierre confronts Anatole about his intentions with Countess Rostova. Pierre accuses Anatole of promising the Countess to marry her and planning to elope. Anatole tries to dodge the question, but Pierre becomes enraged and threatens him physically. Finally, Pierre calms down and speaks about the importance of other people's happiness and the consequences of one's actions. The conversation ends with Anatole leaving for Petersburg the next day.


The lyrics are filled with themes of betrayal, manipulation, and the importance of morality. Anatole's intentions with the Countess were not honorable, and he was willing to deceive and kidnap her to fulfill his desires. Meanwhile, Pierre is depicted as a man struggling with his own morality and control over his emotions. As the conversation progresses, Pierre realizes the significance of his actions and the impact it could have on the Countess's life.


Overall, the song offers insight into the complex relationships and social norms of 19th-century Russia. It also offers a glimpse into the challenges of human nature and the struggle to balance our desires with our moral obligations.


Line by Line Meaning

You promised Countless Rostova to marry her and were about to elope, is that so?
Pierre accuses Anatole of his intentions to marry Countless Rostova and elope with her.


Mon cher I don′t consider myself bound to answer questions put to me in that tone
Anatole ignores Pierre's question, stating that he doesn't have to respond in a derogatory tone.


My face, already pale Becomes distorted by fury I seize you by the collar with my big big hands And I shake you from side to side Until your face shows a sufficient degree of terror When I tell you I must talk to you!
Pierre expresses his anger and shakes Anatole to make him afraid so that he could talk to him.


Come now, this is stupid! What what don't don′t!
Anatole brushes off Pierre's accusations and doesn't take them seriously.


You're a scoundrel and a blackguard And I don't know what deprives me of the pleasure Of smashing your head in with this! Did you promise to marry her?
Pierre insults Anatole and is holding something that he wants to hit him with.


I didn′t think of it. I never promised, because -
Anatole admits to not thinking about marrying Countless Rostova nor making any promises.


Have you any letters of hers? Any letters? I shan′t be violent, don't be afraid First, the letters Second, tomorrow you must get out of Moscow
Pierre asks Anatole for Countless Rostova's letters and tells him to leave Moscow the next day.


But how can I?
Anatole wonders how he could leave Moscow.


Third You must never breathe a word of what has happened between you and the Countess Now I know I can′t prevent your doing so But if you have a spark of conscience Pierre paces the room several times in silence
Pierre tells Anatole to keep his encounter with Countless Rostova a secret, and paces the room as he thinks about Anatole's conscience.


Anatole sits at a table frowning and biting his lips
Anatole is distressed and nervously bites his lips as he thinks about the situation.


After all, you must understand That besides your pleasure There is such a thing as other people, and their happiness and peace And that you are ruining a whole life For the sake of amusing yourself! Amuse yourself with women like my wife With them you're within your rights But to promise a young girl to marry her To deceive, to kidnap Why don′t you understand that that's as cruel as beating an old man or a child?
Pierre lectures Anatole on the morality of deceiving, abducting, and ruining Countless Rostova's life, and compares it to child abuse.


Well I don′t know about that, eh? I don't know that and I don't want to But you have used such words to me ′Scoundrel′ and so on Which as a man of honor I will not allow anyone to use
Anatole defends his honor and refuses to tolerate Pierre's insults.


Is it satisfaction you want?
Pierre wants to know if Anatole feels satisfied with his response.


You could at least take back your words, eh? If you want me to do as you wish?
Anatole asks Pierre to retract his insults if he wants Anatole to do as he wishes.


Fine I take them back, I take them back! And I ask you to forgive me And if you require money for your journey -
Pierre apologizes and offers money for Anatole's journey.


Anatole smiled The reflection of that base and cringing smile Which Pierre knew so well in his wife Revolted him
Anatole's smile resembled one that Pierre's wife had, and it disgusted him.


Oh, vile and heartless brood!
Pierre insults Anatole and his family.


Next day Anatole left For Petersburg!
Anatole leaves for Petersburg the next day.




Writer(s): Dp, Dave Malloy

Contributed by Samuel L. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

Eyeball Freak

The part where Pierre grabbed Anatole and shook him is so funny, I love this musical, thanks for uploading this!

AroMor

@Anatole Kuragin SCOUNDREL

Anatole Kuragin

rude :’(

The Great Shooting Star

You‘re very welcome! Every time this scene comes up I‘m honestly just like „Yasss Pierre get him“ hahaha

Luke Mckenzie

I hate that I feel bad that Anatole gets genuinely upset and afraid

themaan

Don't feel bad about that, because Pierre is genuinely terrifying in this scene (even if Anatole does deserve it)

Leoliy Xolsun

THE WAY HIS WIFE FWISHES HER DRESS IN ANGER JUST ALWAYS MAKES ME LOSE IT

Michael William Ybarra

2:08

pupy Kig

When they first saw eachother JSJSJDJ

Selenium 34

Oop

More Comments

More Versions