For the bands second album, Hand Over Your Loved Ones, Shannon Harris (from Relish) joined on keyboards. Due to disagreements with the record label, mostly caused by Brendan Brown's wish to self-produce the album, the album received little promotion and did not sell well.
Michael Bellar (keyboards) then joined the band and they re-released their second album (containing two new songs) on their own record label, Montauk Mantis, this time named Suck Fony. In 2005 they released their third studio album, TooSoonMonsoon, once again on their own label.
In 2005, both Mike McCabe (bass) and Michael Bellar (keyboards) left and were replaced by Nicolas diPierro and Gerard Hoffman. Then the following year, diPierro and Pete Brown left and were replaced by Matt Milligan (bass) and Kevin Garcia (drums).
Current lineup:
Brendan Brown (vocals)
Matt Milligan (bass)
Gerald Hoffman (keyboards)
Kevin Garcia (drums)
Johanna Cranitch (backing vocals)
Georgia Haege (backing vocals)
Web-page: http://www.wheatus.com/
This Island
Wheatus Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
But the guys at the deli back home
They don't believe me
I ride my bike all around
Round my hometown
Where nobody knows me
And they say that the problem is mine and I should take
When solutions are staring me right in the face
Yet we've run out of time
But if I do what you'd say everything would be fine
Well no thanks, I'd rather sit here and die on this island
Cash it in and stick to the end
No thanks, I'd rather sit here and die on this island
Can't you see than I need this to end
I had a dream about a song
It was so strong
It made all the rights wrong
But when I went to write it all down
Capture the sound
You won't believe what I found
Yeah it all came out bad, mad and sad when I played it
It sounded like, more like a fad that had lasted
A little too long that it had and I realised
That this was as good as it got
There's no snowmen in hell 'cause it's too fuckin' hot
So no thanks, I'd rather sit here and die on this island
Cash it in and stick to the end
No thanks, I'd rather sit here and die on this island
Can't you see than I need this to end
Yeah I thought that I knew who I was
What did I know?
Nothing, or all the above did I mention
Those hip new ideas that I got from you last week
They sucked all the life out of life in a heartbeat
And ripped mine right out of my chest
Right through
But you already knew that was true
Since you tried it the first time, in 1989
When you were the one in my shoes
And some asshole like you told you what you should do
When you do what you do
And you had to do it how he wanted you to
Have you learned how to live with regret
Yeah I can't get these things in my head
'cause if I turned out like you I would wish I was dead
No thanks, I'd rather sit here and die on this island
The song, "This Island" by Wheatus, talks about the struggles and frustrations of the main character who has lost touch with his sense of identity and purpose. The lyrics suggest that he feels disconnected from his hometown where he spends his time biking around without anyone recognizing him or acknowledging his existence. He reminisces about meeting the King of England in contrast to his experiences back home where he feels invisible.
The singer is encouraged to take a more positive outlook on his situation, but he appears to be disillusioned and feels that there are no solutions available to him. He is convinced that following the advice given to him will not bring him the happiness he desires. It is possible that he believes that he has lost his creative spark as well, as he has had a dream about writing a song. When he tries to put it down into words, it comes out sounding uninspired and shallow.
The song's final stanza reveals an underlying anger and bitterness, as the main character contemplates the idea of becoming someone who he despises. He fears becoming like someone who tells others what to do and how to live their lives. Rather than face that prospect, he’d rather die on the island he is stranded on than become that kind of person. The song as a whole highlights the importance of staying true to oneself and not giving up on your dreams and aspirations.
Line by Line Meaning
I met the King of England once
I had a moment of success and fame, but my current social circle doesn't believe me
But the guys at the deli back home
My peers from before my moment of success are the ones who don't believe me
They don't believe me
My peers from before my moment of success are skeptical of my success
I ride my bike all around
I wander around my hometown aimlessly
Round my hometown
My aimless wandering is limited to my hometown
Where nobody knows me
The people of my hometown don't really know me, despite my moment of success
And they say that the problem is mine and I should take
My peers suggest that my failure to connect with them is my own fault
Take a more positive line on the situation
They suggest that I should have a more positive attitude towards reconnecting with them
When solutions are staring me right in the face
My peers claim that the solution to my problem is obvious
Yet we've run out of time
Despite their advice, I feel like I've lost my chance to reconnect with my hometown
But if I do what you'd say everything would be fine
Although I don't really believe their advice will work, I acknowledge that if I followed it, I might be successful
Well no thanks, I'd rather sit here and die on this island
I'd rather accept a miserable fate on my own terms than follow advice that I don't believe will work
Cash it in and stick to the end
I'll endure my fate until the end
Can't you see than I need this to end
I'm desperate for the situation to change, but not enough to take their advice
I had a dream about a song
I had a creative vision
It was so strong
The vision was powerful
It made all the rights wrong
It challenged conventional thinking and made me question what I thought was right
But when I went to write it all down
I tried to capture the vision in concrete form
Capture the sound
I tried to make the music that represented my vision
You won't believe what I found
The result was disappointing and not representative of my vision
Yeah it all came out bad, mad and sad when I played it
The music I made didn't sound like my creative vision
It sounded like, more like a fad that had lasted
The music I made sounded like something that was popular but past its prime
A little too long that it had and I realised
I had spent too much time chasing after an unattainable idea
That this was as good as it got
I accepted that my creative pursuits had reached a dead end
There's no snowmen in hell 'cause it's too fuckin' hot
The way things are going is so sad that it's like snowmen would melt in hell
So no thanks, I'd rather sit here and die on this island
Like with my hometown situation, I'd rather accept a miserable fate on my own terms than keep chasing after something unattainable
Yeah I thought that I knew who I was
I thought I had a strong sense of identity
What did I know?
But in reality, I didn't really know myself
Nothing, or all the above did I mention
I didn't have any kind of strong self-conception, nor did I have a robust sense of my identity
Those hip new ideas that I got from you last week
I was influenced by the opinions of others
They sucked all the life out of life in a heartbeat
Their opinions drained me of motivation, inspiration, and drive
And ripped mine right out of my chest
They eroded my sense of self and passion
Right through
Completely
But you already knew that was true
You, the listener, might have already known how consuming other people's opinions can be
Since you tried it the first time, in 1989
This isn't a new phenomenon for anyone
When you were the one in my shoes
The listener of this song might have gone through a similar experience
And some asshole like you told you what you should do
The somebody who gave bad advice to me regarding my hometown situation might have been someone similar to you
When you do what you do
When you offer your opinions and guidance, which might not be helpful to the person you're trying to help
And you had to do it how he wanted you to
You might have been forced into doing what the person wanted you to do
Have you learned how to live with regret
Have you, the person who gave bad advice, accepted the fact that your advice might not have been helpful?
Yeah I can't get these things in my head
I can't forget the experience and the advice that didn't help me
'cause if I turned out like you I would wish I was dead
If I gave bad advice to someone and they had a miserable experience like me, I'd feel terrible and wish I could undo the damage I caused
No thanks, I'd rather sit here and die on this island
Given all of the above, I'd rather accept a miserable fate in isolation than continue struggling to improve my situation
Lyrics © Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC
Written by: BRENDAN BROWN, BRENDAN B. BROWN
Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind