1) An American indie roc… Read Full Bio ↴There is more than one artist with this name:
1) An American indie rock and hip hop band
2) A British folk-pop band
1) A trio of Cincinnati-born men who fiddle with skins, strings, bells and microphones and present their findings to the listening public. Singer Yoni Wolf grew up the second son to an art book editor and a rabbi. He got his start recording bad poems and sloppy beats on the family synagogue’s 4-track. In junior high he discovered hip-hop. At art school, he learned how to drop out. Yoni’s brother Josiah played drums at Rabbi Wolf’s worship service as a kid, became a band geek as a teen, and fell in love with Thelonious Monk on his way to study music at University of Cincinnati. Doug McDiarmid would eventually get expelled from that same school for carrying a stun gun, but first he was raised by two French teachers and taught piano while in kindergarten. He also went to high school with the Wolfs, where he played in Steve Miller cover bands.
In various permutations together and with other now-notables (i.e. Doseone, Odd Nosdam, Mr. Dibbs, Atmosphere’s Slug), these three created and/or contributed to several freewheeling rap and lo-fi rock-related projects including Greenthink, Miss Ohio’s Nameless, Reaching Quiet, and the seminal cLOUDDEAD outfit. Their wildest dreams were achieved when they relocated to Oakland to make pop-inflected psychedelic folk-hop.
For four years, two EPs and 2003’s cult classic LP, Oaklandazulasylum, WHY? comprised Yoni Wolf alone. He honed his trademark delivery – a sickly sweet, half-rapped, singsong style – shined up his wry, picturesque poetry, and developed a clip-and-collage aesthetic using keyboards, toys, guitars, samplers and anything worth banging on. When Doug and Josiah moved west to join Yoni, they brought with them a hoard of instruments and the ability to wail on every last one. By chops and imagination, WHY? grew into a thing of flesh, bones and fully fledged songs, resulting in 2005’s Elephant Eyelash album. Critics swooned; ladies lauded; WHY? neither resisted nor rested. They toured – with Silver Jews, Yo La Tengo, and Islands. They collaborated – with Danielson Family, Department Of Eagles, and Subtle (Yoni also recorded with Fog’s Andrew Broder as “Hymie’s Basement”). They put out yet more music.
The brand new album Eskimo Snow is something of a companion piece to last year’s celebrated Alopecia LP. In February of 2007, the WHY? trio temporarily relocated to Minneapolis and officially inducted Fog players Andrew Broder and Mark Erickson. Recording live as a five-piece, WHY? created two distinct albums from those sessions: Alopecia, with its taut rhythms and biting wit, and Eskimo Snow, a shadowy and sprawling set that finds Yoni resigned to and ever-awed by those infinite erring bits of existence that make WHY? what it is.
2) Also an English folk-pop band active during the 90s. They released nine albums between '91 & '99, including the curiously-titled Pinnenstripeensuitenwearenfoddergeburnenclippenclopen.
Fatalist Palmistry
Why? Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
Cause it's good for the spine
And coffin rehearsal.
I know a psychic who
Reads her own palm and
Her findings are personal.
She keeps her fists shut tight
And she sleeps on her side.
Something I don't know.
But I am still alive, in love,
And wide-eyed in my time;
Not a mummy shrinking in its cloths.
Your cat clawed out my eyes
While I was distracted by your smile.
And now my sockets sit
Like empty catcher's mitts waiting.
And you ask me is there
Anybody else that I’m dating.
‘Anna & Nathan’
Anna, I’m patient,
But your painted pony is fading,
Lost like a snakeskin in high grass
And out there thrashing like a pet
Bird caught in a jet stream, that's me.
You counting blessings ‘cause
Your net worth ought to be less
Cream in your best dreams.
But God put a song on my palm
That you can't read
I’m lucky to be under
This same sky that held
The exhale from your first breath
Like a ring on a pillow of clouds
But you my tongue may stutter
But my gift heart screams clear and swells
To burst between the wrapped lengths
Of its baved ribbon cell.
But I am still alive, in love,
And wide-eyed in my time;
Not a mummy shrinking in its cloths.
There's a moth flock in my gut growing;
A tug at my groin like tides trying
To pull moon towards them,
I can't ignore them.
And when we say your name
Our tongues catch flame.
And you wonder why we ain't
Got nothing to say.
‘Anna & Nathan’
(At your house)
Anna, I’m patient,
(Embroidered on a kitchen towel.)
But your painted pony is fading,
Lost like a snakeskin in high grass.
And out there thrashing like a pet
Bird caught in a jet-stream, that's me
You’re counting blessings ‘cause
Your net worth ought to be
Less cream in your best dreams.
But God put a song on my palm
That you can't read
I’ll be embalmed
With it long before you'll see
"Why?" is an American alternative hip-hop band. Their song "Fatalist Palmistry" is a slow, contemplative ballad that touches on themes of mortality, spirituality, and love. The lyrics describe the singer's daily routine of sleeping on their back, which they believe is good for their spine, but which they also describe as "coffin rehearsal." The singer is aware of a psychic who reads her own palm, and while the singer is still alive and "wide-eyed in [their] time," the psychic still has an air of mystery and knowledge that the singer does not possess. The singer also describes a personal relationship that seems to be fading away, with their partner counting blessings to compensate for the growing distance between them.
The song's title refers to the practice of palmistry, which is the art of reading a person's palm to gain insights into their personality and future. The term "fatalist" could refer to someone who believes that events are predetermined and that free will is an illusion. The song's lyrics touch on existential themes and a sense of powerlessness in the face of fate. However, the song also suggests that there is still hope and agency in the present moment, even as the future remains uncertain.
Line by Line Meaning
I sleep on my back
Cause it's good for the spine
And coffin rehearsal.
I sleep on my back because it’s better for my physical health and to rehearse for the end of my life when I’ll be in a coffin.
I know a psychic who
Reads her own palm and
Her findings are personal.
I know a psychic who can read her own palm, and the results relate personally to her.
She keeps her fists shut tight
And she sleeps on her side.
Well maybe she knows
Something I don't know.
The psychic keeps her fists shut and sleeps on her side, perhaps because she knows something about the world that I don’t.
But I am still alive, in love,
And wide-eyed in my time;
Not a mummy shrinking in its cloths.
I’m alive, in love, and alert, not yet dead and wrapped in cloth like a mummy.
Your cat clawed out my eyes
While I was distracted by your smile.
And now my sockets sit
Like empty catcher's mitts waiting.
And you ask me is there
Anybody else that I’m dating.
Your cat blinded me while I was looking at you, and now my empty eye sockets wait like baseball gloves. And you ask me if I’m seeing anyone else.
‘Anna & Nathan’
Anna, I’m patient,
But your painted pony is fading,
Lost like a snakeskin in high grass
And out there thrashing like a pet
Bird caught in a jet stream, that's me.
You counting blessings ‘cause
Your net worth ought to be less
Cream in your best dreams.
Anna, I’m trying to be patient, but our relationship is fading like a painted pony in the sun, and I feel like I’m out of control and flailing like a bird in a jet stream. You’re grateful for what you have, but maybe you need less in your life.
But God put a song on my palm
That you can't read
God gave me a special talent or purpose, but you don’t understand it.
I’m lucky to be under
This same sky that held
The exhale from your first breath
Like a ring on a pillow of clouds
But you my tongue may stutter
But my gift heart screams clear and swells
To burst between the wrapped lengths
Of its baved ribbon cell.
I’m glad to be under the same sky as you, and I feel a strong emotional reaction when I’m around you. My heart is full and wants to express itself clearly.
There's a moth flock in my gut growing;
A tug at my groin like tides trying
To pull moon towards them,
I can't ignore them.
And when we say your name
Our tongues catch flame.
And you wonder why we ain't
Got nothing to say.
I feel nervous and excited around you, like a fluttering in my stomach and a strong pull towards you. Our tongues catch fire when we talk about you, but you don’t understand why we can’t express ourselves.
‘Anna & Nathan’
(At your house)
Anna, I’m patient,
(Embroidered on a kitchen towel.)
But your painted pony is fading,
Lost like a snakeskin in high grass.
And out there thrashing like a pet
Bird caught in a jet-stream, that's me
You’re counting blessings ‘cause
Your net worth ought to be
Less cream in your best dreams.
Anna, I’m at your house trying to be patient, but our relationship is fading. You’re thankful for what you have, but maybe you need less in your life.
But God put a song on my palm
That you can't read
I’ll be embalmed
With it long before you'll see
God gave me a special talent or purpose that you don’t understand. It’s a part of me that will last even beyond my death.
Contributed by Hudson A. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
@aspaceproductions
I sleep on my back cause it's good for the spine
And coffin rehearsal
I know a psychic who reads her own palms
And her findings are personal
She keeps her fists shut tight
And she sleeps on her side
Well, maybe she knows something I don't know
But I am still alive, in love and wide-eyed in my time
Not a mummy shrinking in its cloths
Your cat clawed out my eyes while I's distracted by your smile
And now my sockets sit like empty catcher's mitts waiting
And you ask me is there anybody else that I'm dating
Anna & Nathan
Anna & Nathan
Anna & Nathan
Anna I'm patient
But your painted pony is fading
Lost like a snakeskin in high grass
And out there thrashing like a pet bird caught in a jet stream, that's me
Your count them blessings because your net worth oughta be less cream in your best dreams
But God put a song on my palm that you can't read
I'm lucky to be under
The same sky that held
The exhale from your first breath
Like a ring on a pillow of clouds
By you my tongue may stutter
But my gift heart screams clear and swells
To burst between the wrapped lengths
Of its bowed ribbon cell
But I am still alive, in love and wide-eyed in my time
Not a mummy shrinking in its cloths
There's a moth flock in my gut growin'
I tug at my groin like tides trying
To pull moon towards them
I can't ignore them
And when we say your name our tongues catch flame
And you wonder why we ain't got nothin' to say
Anna & Nathan
Anna & Nathan
Anna & Nathan
Anna I'm patient
But your painted pony is fading
Lost like a snakeskin in high grass
And out there thrashing like a pet bird caught in a jet stream, that's me
Your count them blessings because your net worth oughta be less cream in your best dreams
But God put a song on my palm that you can't read
I'll be embalmed with it long before you'll see
@jesin945
Been listening since 2008 and I'll never stop
@JankaMouse
What was this man on back when he made this? It was a perfect album 100% and infuriating in many ways, too. Unique sounds. Looking back it brings me so many memories. Love. 😢
@darksyde3000
Absolutely obsessed with this song right now! Can't seem to find a single Live video of it performed literally anywhere on the Internet. If anyone knows of one, please pass it along. <3
@grantfaucett1144
I'm sure you found this already but .....
https://youtu.be/_fLI2l49fsQ
@virgil8284
Exactly I've been listening since I was a kid and I cant find no reactions barley and comments into 2021 or live items crazy
@christopherheady7377
Wolf, thank you for letting me touch your spiky hair :)
Yoni, you gave teen us a lot.
@mcdude9578
this whole album is nostalgia
@luciendepeiro317
Uno de esos temas en los que el puro hip hop parece quedar diluido y simplemente representa la versatilidad de un género musical abierto, variado y siempre dispuesto a reproducirse. Why? consigue una proximidad emocional desde la sencillez abierta, sin límites melódicos. Al final, esa apertura facilita la expansión. Gran tema dentro del hip hop alternativo.
51. Why?, "Fatalist palmistry".
[https://youtu.be/ko_xjDm-2DI]
@lisabrenner9116
*
@sonofamachinegun8568
Such an underrated band