To Have and To Have Not
Billy Bragg Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Up in the morning and out to school
Mother says there'll be no work next year
Qualifications, once the Golden Rule
Are now just pieces of paper

Just because you're better than me
Doesn't mean I'm lazy
Just because you're going forwards
Doesn't mean I'm going backwards

If you look the part you'll get the job
In last year's trousers and your old school shoes
The truth is, son, it's a buyer's market
They can afford to pick and choose

Just because you're better than me
Doesn't mean I'm lazy
Just because I dress like this
Doesn't mean I'm a communist

The factories are closing and the army's full
I don't know what I'm going to do
But I've come to see in the Land of the Free
There's only a future for the Chosen Few

Just because you're better than me
Doesn't mean I'm lazy
Just because you're going forwards
Doesn't mean I'm going backwards

At twenty one you're on top of the scrapheap
At sixteen you were top of your class
All they taught you at school
Was how to be a good worker
The system has failed you, don't fail yourself

Just because you're better than me
Doesn't mean I'm lazy




Just because you're going forwards
Doesn't mean I'm going backwards

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of Billy Bragg's "To Have and to Have Not" are a powerful commentary on the state of the working class in the UK in the 1980s, and their struggle to find employment amidst a society where qualifications no longer guarantee a future. The song begins with a bleak image of a mother telling her child there will be no work next year, effectively rendering the pursuit of education and qualifications pointless. He questions the notion that qualifications are the golden rule, as they are now just pieces of paper.


The second verse focuses on how people are judged based on their appearance, as if "looking the part" is more important than actual qualifications or skills. The chorus emphasizes that just because someone is better than another person, it doesn't mean the other person is lazy. Just because someone appears to be progressing forward, it doesn't mean that others are moving backward. The song seems to be questioning the myth of meritocracy that permeates Western society.


The third verse speaks to the fact that even once-secure industries such as factories are closing and there are limited options for people. The song suggests that in a country of supposed freedom and opportunity, there's only a future for the chosen few, and the system has failed the working-class. The final verse ends with a rallying cry, urging people not to fail themselves even if the system has failed them.


Overall, "To Have and to Have Not" is a scathing critique of neoliberalism and the impact of this economic and political ideology on ordinary people. It highlights the absurdity of a society that judges people based on their appearance rather than their actual abilities, and it exposes the reality of a society that is far from the "land of the free" for most.


Line by Line Meaning

Up in the morning and out to school
Starting the day early and attending school


Mother says there'll be no work next year
Predicting a lack of job opportunities


Qualifications, once the Golden Rule
Education was once the key to success


Are now just pieces of paper
Educational qualifications are now not valued in the job market


Just because you're better than me
Being superior doesn't make me inferior


Doesn't mean I'm lazy
My lack of success is not due to laziness


Just because you're going forwards
Your career advancement doesn't mean my career is going in reverse


Doesn't mean I'm going backwards
I can still progress in my career


If you look the part you'll get the job
Appearance is important in getting a job


In last year's trousers and your old school shoes
Outdated attire can affect job prospects


The truth is, son, it's a buyer's market
Employers have the upper hand in selecting candidates


They can afford to pick and choose
Employers have multiple qualified candidates to select from


The factories are closing and the army's full
The job market is limited with factory closures and army recruitment limitations


I don't know what I'm going to do
Unemployment uncertainty


But I've come to see in the Land of the Free
Realizing the lack of opportunities in the United States


There's only a future for the Chosen Few
Success is limited to a small number of individuals


At twenty one you're on top of the scrapheap
At 21, the best job opportunities may have already been taken


At sixteen you were top of your class
Academic success doesn't translate into job success


All they taught you at school
Limited preparation for the job market


Was how to be a good worker
Education focused on workplace obedience


The system has failed you, don't fail yourself
The education system has not provided proper job preparation, but individuals can still succeed




Lyrics © O/B/O APRA AMCOS
Written by: Billy Bragg

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions