Why Judy Why
Billy Joel Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Of all the people in the world that I know
You're the best place to go
When I cry, when I cry

I never asked for much before, not before
Things are changed; I need more
Tell me why, Judy, why?
I never thought that she would say
Say goodbye; but she did
And now I wanna die. I wanna die

I never thought that I would need, need a friend
But I did, in the end
Tell me why, Judy, why

Oh, what a scene
It's wrong for her to hang me up this way
Oh, where you been?
'Cause it's so hard to make it through the day

A man my age is very young, so I'm told
Why do I feel so old?
Tell me why, Judy, why?

Oh, what a scene
It's wrong for her to hang me up this way
Oh, where you been?
'Cause it's so hard to make it through the day

There's no tomorrow 'cause my dreams did not last




So I live in the past
Tell me why, Judy, why?

Overall Meaning

The lyrics to Billy Joel's song Why Judy Why evoke emotions of longing, confusion, and despair. The song seems to be about a man who has recently been left by a lover (presumably named Judy), and is struggling to make sense of his feelings. He finds solace in the fact that he can turn to Judy when he is feeling vulnerable, but ultimately feels betrayed by her when she is not there for him.


The first verse sets the stage for the rest of the song. The singer explains that Judy is his go-to person when he needs someone to lean on. He then laments that he has been forced to ask for more from her because of recent changes in his life. The second verse describes how he never thought that Judy would leave him, and he is devastated by her departure. He questions why he needs friends and why he feels so old at a young age.


The chorus repeats twice, emphasizing the singer's confusion and longing for Judy. The bridge seems to blame Judy for the singer's sadness, implying that she has wronged him in some way. The final verse reveals that the singer is living in the past because his dreams for the future have not come to fruition. He ends the song with one last plea to Judy to explain why she has left him.


Overall, Why Judy Why is a poignant and emotional song about a man struggling to cope with the loss of his lover. The lyrics suggest that he feels abandoned and alone, despite the fact that he has people in his life who care about him. He seems to find some solace in the fact that he can turn to Judy when he needs someone to lean on, but ultimately feels betrayed by her.


Line by Line Meaning

Of all the people in the world that I know You're the best place to go When I cry, when I cry
Out of everyone I know, you're the only one I can turn to when I need support during my times of sadness.


I never asked for much before, not before Things are changed; I need more Tell me why, Judy, why?
I used to be content with what I had, but now I find myself needing more. I'm asking for your help in understanding the cause of this change.


I never thought that she would say Say goodbye; but she did And now I wanna die. I wanna die
I never expected her to leave me, but now that she has, I feel helpless and overwhelmed with sadness.


I never thought that I would need, need a friend But I did, in the end Tell me why, Judy, why
I didn't realize the importance of having a friend until now. Please help me understand why I'm feeling this way.


Oh, what a scene It's wrong for her to hang me up this way Oh, where you been? 'Cause it's so hard to make it through the day
It's unfair that she's left me in this state of emotional turmoil. I need to know where you've been because it's difficult to make it through each day without her support.


A man my age is very young, so I'm told Why do I feel so old? Tell me why, Judy, why?
People say that I'm still young, but I don't feel that way. Please help me understand why I feel so old before my time.


There's no tomorrow 'cause my dreams did not last So I live in the past Tell me why, Judy, why?
I've lost hope for the future because my dreams have not come to fruition. This has led me to dwell on the past. I need your help in finding a way to move forward.




Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group
Written by: BILLY JOEL

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comments from YouTube:

@jennamarcus4283

Of all the people in the world that I know
You're the best place to go when I cry, when I cry
I never asked for much before, not before
Things are changed: I need more
Tell me why Judy why


I never thought that she would say, say goodbye
But she did, and now I want to die,
I want to die I never thought that
I would need, need a friend
Oh, but I did in the end
Tell me why Judy why
Oh what a scene
It's wrong for her to hang me up this way
Oh, where've you been?


'Cause it's so hard to make it through the day
A man my age is very young
So I'm told
Why do I feel so old?
Tell me why Judy why, Judy why


Oh what a scene
It's wrong for her to hang me up this way
Oh, where've you been?
'Cause it's so hard to make it through the day
There's no tomorrow
'Cause my dream did not last
So I live in the past
Tell me why Judy why
Tell me why Judy why
Oh, tell me why Judy why



@sergiograham

''WHY JUDY,WHY'' lyrics

Of all the people in the world that I know
You're the best place to go
When I cry, when I cry

I never asked for much before, not before
Things are changed; I need more
Tell me why, Judy, why?

I never thought that she would say
Say goodbye; but she did
And now I wanna die. I wanna die..

I never thought that I would need, need a friend,
But I did, in the end..
Tell me why, Judy, why..?

Oh, what a scene
It's wrong for her to hang me up this way
Oh, where you been?

'Cause it's so hard to make it through the day

A man my age is very young, so I'm told
Why do I feel so old?
Tell me why, Judy, why?

Oh, what a scene
It's wrong for her to hang me up this way
Oh, where you been?
'Cause it's so hard to make it through the day...

There's no tomorrow 'cause my dreams did not last
So I live in the past
Tell me why, Judy, why?....



All comments from YouTube:

@Adam1Gee

Billy Joel has a song for almost any situation. Right now, I feel like asking ‘why Judy why?’ in my life right now. Tomorrow I might feel like listening to ‘Tomorrow is today.’

@theklamoris

I hope you feel better now

@anthony2812

Such an underrated song

@prashantthakuri6074

Chords progression is hard and beautiful so people don't get often!
Such a legend composition

@mercedesgutierrezasensio7619

Totalmente.., menos para ti y por lo visto...para mí ..tengo 59 años y desde tengo 13, es mi canción favorita...adoro a Billy Joel!!!

@williampatrick2971

He won’t perform it live :(

@nerktwin

Always thought this song was so beautiful... unfortunate that not many people have heard it. Devastatingly gorgeous...

@danielhkhk7283

Always loved this song.

@lloydfox5752

Always my favorite. This song was why I started following him 50+ years ago.

@francismackin4681

Cold Spring Harbor is still my favorite Billy Joel album. I don’t hear anything but perfection

More Comments

More Versions