Why?
Discharge Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Besides her man she kneels
Holds him tight and begins to cry
Why why why but why
Her loved one's just another piece of meat on the battlefields
Her cries break out into screams
As she now becomes hysterical with grief
Her loved one's just another piece of meat on the battlefields




Overall Meaning

The Discharge's song, "Why?" portrays the emotional turmoil of a woman who loses her loved one in the war. The lyrics are a poignant commentary on the horrors of war and the devastating impact it has on the lives of innocent people. The opening lines "Besides her man she kneels" depict the woman's helplessness and her inability to do anything except hold her loved one and cry. The repetition of the question "why?" reflects her bewilderment and confusion as to why this senseless war has taken away her loved one from her.


As the song progresses, her cries turn into screams and she becomes hysterical with grief. The lines "Her loved one's just another piece of meat on the battlefields" emphasize how war reduces human beings to mere objects and devalues their worth. The woman's pain and anguish are palpable, and the song serves as a reminder of the true cost of war.


Line by Line Meaning

Besides her man she kneels
She is on her knees next to her significant other


Holds him tight and begins to cry
She tightly embraces him and begins to weep


Why why why but why
She repeatedly asks why, expressing her confusion and agony


Her loved one's just another piece of meat on the battlefields
She feels that her loved one has been dehumanized and reduced to nothing more than a casualty of war


Her cries break out into screams
Her weeping turns into loud, anguished screams


As she now becomes hysterical with grief
Her sadness and pain cause her to lose control and become hysterical


Her loved one's just another piece of meat on the battlefields
She repeats her earlier statement, emphasizing her belief that her loved one's life was tragically reduced to a meaningless loss on the battlefield




Lyrics © Kobalt Music Publishing Ltd., Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC, Universal Music Publishing Group, Warner/Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: CALVIN E. (GENE) TAYLOR

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Most interesting comment from YouTube:

McAwesomeDelux

Visions Of War - 0:00
Does This System Work - 1:31
A Look At Tomorrow - 2:47
Why - 4:41
Maimed And Slaughtered - 5:49
Mania For Conquest - 6:56
Ain't No Feeble Bastard - 8:10
Is This To Be - 9:39
Massacre Of Innocents (Air Attack) - 11:09
Why - 12:31



All comments from YouTube:

aristotle358

Takes me back to when I bought this on its release! I lived it then and funnily enough I still love it now at 59 yrs old.😎

Drew Ski

Old punk? Or still punk?

aristotle358

@Drew Ski Same person, evolved over the years.

Κωνσταντινος Χριστογλου

the vinyl was red..at all..cause mine is...(GREEK EDITION)

Graeme Stroud

What’s not to love?

Marcelo Bielsa

@aristotle358 me too 🤪

2 More Replies...

Игорь Игоревич

Безумный улёт все кайфова и дико круто убойный альбом🔥🖤🖤🖤🖤🔥👿🤘🤘🤘

McAwesomeDelux

Visions Of War - 0:00
Does This System Work - 1:31
A Look At Tomorrow - 2:47
Why - 4:41
Maimed And Slaughtered - 5:49
Mania For Conquest - 6:56
Ain't No Feeble Bastard - 8:10
Is This To Be - 9:39
Massacre Of Innocents (Air Attack) - 11:09
Why - 12:31

Ammy Almeida

album foda

Woody

Remember buying this when it came out still have it classic & so much better than the debut album

More Comments

More Versions