Ruby Christine McGuire (July 30, 1926 – December 28, 2018), Dorothy "Dottie" McGuire (February 13, 1928 – September 7, 2012) and Phyllis McGuire (born February 14, 1931). Among their most popular songs are "Sincerely" and "Sugartime", both number-one hits.
The McGuire sisters were born in Middletown, Ohio, and grew up in Miamisburg near Dayton . Their mother, Lillie, was a minister of the Miamisburg First Church of God, where as children they sang in church at weddings, funerals, and revivals. When they started singing in 1935, the youngest sister, Phyllis, was four years old. Eventually, they sang at occasions outside church, and by 1949 were singing at military bases and veterans' hospitals, performing a more diverse repertoire than they had in church.
The McGuire Sisters signed with Coral Records in 1952. In the same year, they appeared on Arthur Godfrey's Talent Scouts, and Godfrey hired them for his other shows, where they remained for seven years. The November 1953 issue of Cosmopolitan called them "Godfrey's Merry McGuires". The sisters often were compared to the Andrews Sisters. Maxene Andrews said in an interview with Joe Franklin on WOR (AM) radio in 1979, "The McGuire Sisters were fine once they stopped imitating the Andrews Sisters." While working on the Godfrey show, the McGuires befriended the singer Lu Ann Simms and attended her wedding to the music publisher Loring Buzzell in July 1956. Buzzell's publishing firm, Hecht-Lancaster & Buzzell Music (co-owned by Harold Hecht and Burt Lancaster) provided two songs for the McGuire Sisters, "May You Always" and "Theme from The Unforgiven (The Need for Love)".
The McGuire Sisters and the Andrews Sisters met several times during their careers. Phyllis credited Patty, Maxene, and LaVerne Andrews during a television interview with Maxene in the 1990s, hosted by Sally Jessy Raphael, saying that her sisters and she met the Andrews Sisters in New York in the early 1950s and received important advice. The McGuires moved when they sang, often executing dance routines in lavish production numbers on countless television specials. The Andrews Sisters performed similarly in films in the 1940s, and were the first female vocal group to move when they sang, rather than just standing at a microphone. The sisters had mimicked that style, as well as those of the Mills Brothers and the Dinning Sisters ever since they were young, when they would perform short shows for family and friends in their parents' living room. Phyllis McGuire recounted that she and her sisters did not know any popular songs when they became famous (only the hymns taught to them by their mother), the trio imitated other singing groups long before their success.
They performed for five Presidents of the United States (Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford, Jimmy Carter, Ronald Reagan, and George H. W. Bush), and for Queen Elizabeth II. In 1958, their mother appeared as a guest challenger on the television game show To Tell the Truth. The sisters maintained a busy television schedule, making frequent appearances on popular variety programs hosted by Ed Sullivan, Dean Martin, Danny Kaye, Milton Berle, Andy Williams, Perry Como, and Red Skelton. The trio was dressed and coiffed identically and performed synchronized body movements and hand gestures with military precision. Their recordings of "Sincerely", "Picnic", and "Sugartime" all sold more than one million copies.
They retired from public appearances in 1968, giving their last performance that year on The Ed Sullivan Show. Phyllis McGuire continued to perform solo for a time. The demise of the group is often attributed to Phyllis' long-standing personal relationship with mobster Sam Giancana (although for years she claimed that their friendship was strictly platonic), which reportedly blacklisted the group.
During one of his 1960s court appearances for which Phyllis was subpoenaed, Giancana told reporters outside the courthouse, "Phyllis knows everything" about the rumored unethical behaviors of John F. Kennedy and his brother Robert. Phyllis has resided in a famously showcased mansion in Las Vegas for decades, boasting its own beauty parlor, a swan moat, and a replica of the Eiffel Tower which actually rose through the home's roof.
When asked by Barbara Walters during a 1980s ABC-TV 20/20 interview from within the mansion if any of the money to build the lavish home came from Giancana, Phyllis denied the innuendo, claiming that she invested heavily in oil when the sisters were at the height of their popularity. In the same interview, she acknowledged that her relationship with Giancana was in fact a love affair, saying, "When I met him, I did not know who he was, and he was not married, and I was an unmarried woman. And according to the way I was brought up, there was nothing wrong with that. And I didn't find out until sometime later really who he was, and I was already in love."[7]
The sisters reunited in 1986, performing at Toronto's Royal York Hotel for the first time since their retirement.[8] Numerous nightclub engagements followed in Las Vegas, Atlantic City, and New York City's Rainbow & Stars, showcasing the group and Phyllis' impersonations of Peggy Lee, Judy Garland, Pearl Bailey, Ethel Merman, and even Louis Armstrong.
Singing their greatest hits as part of their act, they were also featured performing specialty numbers such as the frantic "I Love a Violin", the a cappella "Danny Boy", and a segment during which Phyllis retired backstage as Christine and Dorothy shared the spotlight playing a concert arrangement of "The Way We Were" on twin pianos. Other highlights in the act were a comical Trinidad-flavored tune, a soft rendering of "Memory" from Broadway's Cats, and a "Money Medley", which they also performed live on the Jerry Lewis MDA Telethon in 1994. Since then, the sisters had made occasional public appearances together, including in 2004, when they reunited to perform in a PBS special Magic Moments: Best of '50s Pop. The sisters' command of their vocal cords and harmonious blend had not significantly diminished.
After their careers wound down, they opened a restaurant in Bradenton, Florida, calling it McGuire's Pub.
They were inducted into the National Broadcasting Hall of Fame in 1994, and in 2001, they were inducted into the Vocal Group Hall of Fame. They also have been inducted into the Coca-Cola Hall of Fame and the Headliners' Hall of Fame. They were inducted into the Hit Parade Hall of Fame in 2009.
Christine has two children, Herold and Asa; Dorothy had two, Rex and David. Phyllis has no children.
On September 7, 2012, Dorothy McGuire died at her son's home in Paradise Valley, Arizona, after suffering from Parkinson's disease and age-related dementia; she was 84. Dorothy's husband of 54 years, Lowell Williamson, died 6 months later on February 25, 2013, after sustaining a fractured back from a fall; he was 89.
Christine McGuire died in Las Vegas, Nevada in December 2018 at the age of 92.
The McGuire Sisters, and most especially Phyllis McGuire, who lives in Las Vegas, were the subjects of the 1995 HBO movie Sugartime, which depicted a romantic relationship between Phyllis and mobster Sam Giancana. Giancana was played by actor John Turturro, and Phyllis was played by actress Mary-Louise Parker.
The 1982 Robert Altman film Come Back to the Five and Dime Jimmy Dean prominently features the music of The McGuire Sisters. Their #1 single "Sincerely" is lip-synced by the film's stars Cher, Karen Black and Sandy Dennis as "The Disciples of James Dean."
They performed for five US Presidents - Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford, Jimmy Carter, Ronald Reagan, and George H. W. Bush), and for Queen Elizabeth II
In 1968, they retired from public performance apart from Phyllis who continued as a solo act but they reunited seventeen years later for a number of shows.
In 1994, they were inducted into the National Broadcasting Hall of Fame and In 2001, they were inducted into the Vocal Group Hall of Fame.
Discography
Year Single (A-side, B-side)
Both sides from same album except where indicated Chart positions Album
US CB US
AC UK[15]
1953 "Picking Sweethearts"
b/w "One, Two, Three, Four" — — — — Non-album tracks
"Toodle-Ooh Siana"
b/w "Miss You" — — — —
"Where Good Times Are"
b/w "Hey, Mister Cotton Picker" — — — —
"Are You Looking for a Sweetheart"
b/w "You'll Never Know Till Monday" — — — —
1954 "Uno, Due, Tre (The Italian Square Dance)"
b/w "Lonesome Polecat" (from Musical Magic) — — — —
"Pine Tree, Pine over Me" / 26 27 — —
"Cling to Me" — 49 — —
"Goodnight, Sweetheart, Goodnight"
b/w "Heavenly Feeling" (Non-album track) 7 8 — — By Request
"Muskrat Ramble" (see below)
b/w "Not As a Stranger" (Non-album track) — — — —
"Muskrat Ramble" / 10 9 — —
"Lonesome Polecat" 28 33 — — Musical Magic
"Christmas Alphabet"
b/w "Give Me Your Heart for Christmas" 25 34 — — Greetings from the McGuire Sisters
1955 "Sincerely" / 1 2 — 14 By Request
"No More" 17 — — 20
"Open Up Your Heart (and Let the Sun Shine In)"
b/w "Melody of Love" — — — —
"The Naughty Lady of Shady Lane"
b/w "Hearts of Stone" (non-album track) — — — —
"It May Sound Silly" / 11 14 — — Chris, Phyllis, Dottie
"Doesn't Anybody Love Me?" flip — — — Musical Magic
"Something's Gotta Give" / 5 4 — — Chris, Phyllis, Dottie
"Rhythm 'n Blues" flip 32 — — Teenage Party
"Kiss Me and Kill Me with Love"
b/w "If It's a Dream" — — — — Non-album tracks
"He"
b/w "If You Believe" 10 4 — — Greetings from the McGuire Sisters
"Give Me Love" / 95 30 — — Non-album track
"Sweet Song of India" — 34 — — Chris, Phyllis, Dottie
"Be Good To Me" / — 46 — — Teenage Party
"My Baby's Got Such Lovin' Ways" — 40 — —
"I'd Like to Trim a Tree with You"
b/w "The Littlest Angel" — — — — Greetings from the McGuire Sisters
1956 "Missing"
b/w "Tell Me Now" (non-album track) 44 36 — — Musical Magic
"Picnic" / 13 20 — — Chris, Phyllis, Dottie
"Delilah Jones" 37 36 — 24
"Weary Blues" / 32 42 — — Sugartime
"In the Alps" 63 — — —
"Ev'ry Day of My Life" / 37 33 — — Chris, Phyllis, Dottie
"Endless" 52 36 — —
"Goodnight, My Love, Pleasant Dreams"
b/w "Mommy" (from Children's Holiday) 32 23 — — Musical Magic
1957 "Kid Stuff"
b/w "Without Him" — 36 — — Musical Magic
"Blue Skies"
b/w "He's Got Time" (from Greetings from the McGuire Sisters) — — — — Do You Remember When
"Please, Don't Do That to Me"
b/w"Drownin' in Memories" — — — — Teenage Party
"Beginning to Miss You"
b/w "Rock Bottom" — — — —
"Around the World In 80 Days"
b/w "Interlude" 73 — — — Sugartime
"Kiss Them for Me"
b/w "Forgive Me" — — — —
"Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town"
b/w "Honorable Congratulations" — — — — Greetings from the McGuire Sisters
"Sugartime"
b/w "Banana Split" 1 7 — 14 Sugartime
1958 "Ding Dong"
b/w "Since You Went Away to School" 25 43 — —
"Volare"
b/w "Do You Love Me Like You Kiss Me" 80 — — — May You Always
"Sweetie Pie"
b/w "I'll Think of You" — — — —
1959 "May You Always"
b/w "Achoo-Cha-Cha" 11 21 — 15
"Summer Dreams" / 55 64 — — Sugartime
"Peace" 85 97 — — May You Always
"Red River Valley"
b/w "Compromise" (Non-album track) — — — — Showcase
"Some of These Days"
b/w "Have a Nice Weekend" (Non-album track) — — — —
1960 "Livin' Dangerously"
b/w "Lovers Lullaby" 97 — — — Non-album tracks
"Theme from The Unforgiven (The Need for Love)"
b/w "I Give Thanks" (Non-album track) — — — — Showcase
"The Last Dance"
b/w "Nine o'Clock" (Non-album track) 99 — — —
"To Be Loved"
b/w "I Don't Know Why (I Just Do)" — — — —
1961 "Just for Old Time's Sake"
b/w "Really Neat" (Non-album track) 20 17 — — Just for Old Time's Sake
"Tears on My Pillow"
b/w "Will There Be Space in a Space Ship" (Non-album track) 59 55 12 — Showcase
"Just Because" / 99 96 — —
"I Do, I Do, I Do" — tag — —
"I'm Just Taking My Time"
b/w "I Can Dream, Can't I" (Non-album track) — — — — Subways Are for Sleeping
1962 "Sugartime Twist"
b/w "More Hearts Are Broken That Way" 107 130 — — Showcase
"Mama's Gone, Goodbye"
b/w "I Really Don't Want to Know" — — — — Songs Everybody Knows
1963 "Summertime (Is the Time for Love)"
b/w "Cordially Invited" — — — — Non-album tracks
1964 "Now and Forever"
b/w "Never" — — — —
"Candy Heart"
b/w "Dear Heart" — — — —
"Ticket to Anywhere"
b/w "I'll Walk Alone" — — — —
1966 "Truer Than You Were"
b/w "Grazia" — — 30 — Right Now!
Phyllis McGuire solo singles
Year Single (A-side, B-side) Chart positions Album
US CB US
AC
1964 "I Don't Want to Walk Without You"
b/w "That's Life" 79 85 13 Non-album tracks
"Just a Little Lovin'"
b/w "You Don't Have the Heart to Tell Me" — — —
1965 "Run to My Arms"
b/w "Someone Else Is Taking My Place" — — —
1966 "My Happiness"
b/w "Vaya Con Dios" — — — Phyllis McGuire Sings
Somethings Gotta Give
The McGuire Sisters Lyrics
Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴ Line by Line Meaning ↴
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
When an irresistible force such as you
Meets and old immovable object like me
You can bet as sure as you live
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
When an irrepressible smile such as yours
Warms an old implacable heart such as mine
Don't say no because I insist
Somewhere, somehow
Someone's gonna be kissed
So en garde who knows what the fates have in store
From their vast mysterious sky
I'll try hard ignoring those lips I adore
But how long can anyone try
Fight, fight, fight
Fight, fight it with all of our might
Chances are some heavenly star spangled night
We'll find out as sure as we live
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Fight, fight, fight it with all of our might
Chances are some heavenly star spangled night
We'll find out as sure as we live
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta
Something's gotta give
The McGuire Sisters' song "Something's Gotta Give" is a classic love song that captures the longing and excitement of falling in love. The song is based on the idea of two opposing forces meeting and the inevitable result that something has to give. The lyrics talk about how a force as irresistible as falling in love with someone as stubborn and immovable as the singer will only lead to one thing - an unstoppable force of passion.
The first verse describes the feeling of meeting someone who is unlike anyone else, someone who seems to possess an irresistible force that can't be ignored. The second verse builds upon this idea, with the singer falling irrepressibly in love with someone who has an implacable heart that seems impossible to break. The chorus then repeats the idea that something has to give when these two opposing forces meet, and they can't help but give in to the passion that's building between them.
The third verse talks about the struggle of trying to resist this passion, with the singer trying to ignore the lips of the person they adore. However, the lyrics recognize how futile this is, with the chorus repeating the idea of something having to give. The song ends with the two lovers facing off, ready to fight but knowing deep down that they'll eventually give in to the irresistible force between them.
Overall, "Something's Gotta Give" is an ode to the power of love and the inevitability of giving into the passion that it creates. The lyrics expertly capture the excitement, longing, and inevitable surrender of falling in love.
Line by Line Meaning
Something's gotta give
A situation can't stay as it is, a change needs to happen
Something's gotta give
A situation can't stay as it is, a change needs to happen
Something's gotta give
A situation can't stay as it is, a change needs to happen
When an irresistible force such as you
When a strong and irresistible person like you
Meets and old immovable object like me
Encounters an old and stubborn person like me who won't change their ways
You can bet as sure as you live
It's a certainty that something has to give
When an irrepressible smile such as yours
When your smile is so infectious and impossible to resist
Warms an old implacable heart such as mine
Melts my cold and unyielding heart
Don't say no because I insist
Please don't refuse because I am determined
Somewhere, somehow
At some point, in some way
Someone's gonna be kissed
We will kiss each other eventually
So en garde who knows what the fates have in store
We should be prepared for whatever the future holds
From their vast mysterious sky
From a vast and impenetrable universe
I'll try hard ignoring those lips I adore
I'll try my best to resist your irresistible lips
But how long can anyone try
But it's difficult to resist forever
Fight, fight, fight
We must struggle and put up a fight
Fight, fight it with all of our might
We need to fight with all our strength to make a change
Chances are some heavenly star spangled night
It's likely that someday under a starry sky
We'll find out as sure as we live
We will discover what we need to do for sure
Something's gotta give
A situation can't stay as it is, a change needs to happen
Something's gotta give
A situation can't stay as it is, a change needs to happen
Something's gotta give
A situation can't stay as it is, a change needs to happen
Something's gotta
A change needs to happen
Something's gotta give
A situation can't stay as it is, a change needs to happen
Lyrics © Warner/Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: JOHNNY MERCER
Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
TOTAL ROMS
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
When an irresistible force such as you
Meets and old immovable object like me
You can bet as sure as you live
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
When an irrepressible smile such as yours
Warms an old implacable heart such as mine
Don't say no because I insist
Somewhere, somehow
Someone's gonna be kissed
So en garde who knows what the fates have in store
From their vast mysterious sky
I'll try hard ignoring those lips I adore
But how long can anyone try
Fight, fight, fight
Fight, fight it with all of our might
Chances are some heavenly star spangled night
We'll find out as sure as we live
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Fight, fight, fight it with all of our might
Chances are some heavenly star spangled night
We'll find out as sure as we live
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta
Something's gotta give
Joseph Bonilla
Wow this song is incredible. love the big band music and the incredible voices of the beautiful McGuire sister's. Just heavenly. been listening to it over and over again.Thanks to whomever gave the song to the McGuire sister's to sing. They brought their special touch to this song, also the band a perfect choice. I can't get enough of it. Can't help but think of Marilyn Monroe when I hear it. Brings a tear to my eyes, especially knowing she didn't finish the movie. but luckily I found the movie with Marilyn Monroe in it. I'm one of her biggest fans. Now I'm also a fan of the McGuire sister's. I wish one of the choreographers from the show 'So You Think You Can Dance' would use this song with the McGuire sister's in one of their dance routines. it would be so hot and sexy, especially seeing the dancers wearing the incredible clothes from the era. wish this would come true. I was surprise to find the original movie with Marilyn Monroe in it on You Tube. Can't wait to watch it. thank you You Tube for posting this song and original movie. i always wanted to see it, now my dream wish has come true. I feel sexy when I hear this song. your new fan Joe Bonilla
Peter Lynch
Such incredibly intelligent lyrics! And the sound of the blended voices of the Macguire Sisters, sounding with vintage polish and perfection! Love their rendition of the title song 'Picnic' from the movie with Novak and Holden! So beautiful!
dept2
Johnny Mercer wrote those intelligent words! And...he also wrote the MUSIC - he usually just wrote words - and PICNIC is my favorite song!
MsRocky1954
One of my favorites! Brings back memories of Las Vegas in the 60s. And the way it used to be, the shows, the strip and all those amazing people that were regulars way back when! The Maitee D’s knew your name, knew what you like to drink and your favorite table. Wonderful music everywhere and the best entertainers. Blessed that I experienced that! Love this song!
TOTAL ROMS
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
When an irresistible force such as you
Meets and old immovable object like me
You can bet as sure as you live
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
When an irrepressible smile such as yours
Warms an old implacable heart such as mine
Don't say no because I insist
Somewhere, somehow
Someone's gonna be kissed
So en garde who knows what the fates have in store
From their vast mysterious sky
I'll try hard ignoring those lips I adore
But how long can anyone try
Fight, fight, fight
Fight, fight it with all of our might
Chances are some heavenly star spangled night
We'll find out as sure as we live
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Fight, fight, fight it with all of our might
Chances are some heavenly star spangled night
We'll find out as sure as we live
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta give
Something's gotta
Something's gotta give
sauquoit13456
Phyllis McGuire, the last surviving member of the trio, The McGuire Sisters, passed away on December 29th, 2020 of natural causes in Las Vegas, Nevada. She was 89 years old...
Between 1954 and 1961 the Middletown, Ohio trio had thirty-two records on Billboard's Top 100 chart, six made the Top 10 with two reaching #1, "Sincerely" for six weeks in February of 1955 and "Sugartime" for four weeks in February of 1958...
Besides "Sincerely" and Sugartime", the trio's other four Top 10 records were "Goodnite, Sweetheart, Goodnite" {#7 in 1954}, "Muskrat Ramble" {#10 in 1954}, "Something's Gotta Give" {#5 in 1955}, and "He" {#10 in 1955}...
Phyllis McGuire, as a solo artist, had one charted record, "I Don't Want to Walk Without You", it reached #79 in 1964...
May Ms. McGuire R.I.P.
Badoocee
Still Classy💎
Gregory Jay Valent
I remember them from Arthur Godfrey's daytime talk/variety show. I was little, my mother and grandmother always had it on.
Marco Rodriguez
I love this song and i'm only 26 haha, greetings from Argentina
Catherine
Never be embarrassed when you have taste….