The Car Thief
The Residents Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

I once, I once, I once
Was part of you

You hoped that the
Hands choking me
Had broken me apart

Now I don't
Now I don't
Now I don't
Believe in you

My open end
Your only friend
Was always in the dark

'Til I took a shoe
That belonged to you
Then took a torch to your new car

And now that car
Looks like a star
That's fallen far from the dark

And now that car
Looks like a star
That's fallen far from the dark

And as my pain
Turns into flames
No one blames my heart

As my pain
Turns into flames
No one blames my heart

As my pain
Turns into flames
No one blames my heart

As my pain
Turns into flames
No one blames my heart

As my pain




Turns into flames
No one blames my heart

Overall Meaning

The Car Thief is a song by The Residents that tells the story of a person who has been hurt and rejected by someone they loved. The first stanza sets up the relationship dynamic, where the singer was once a part of the other person. However, the other person had hoped that the singer would be broken and destroyed by the hands of others. The singer then declares that they no longer believe in the other person, which was once their only friend. The phrase "my open end" suggests that the singer was vulnerable and open to the other person's influence, but they ended up in the dark, isolated and alone.


In the second stanza, the singer retaliates by stealing a shoe that belonged to the other person and then setting fire to their car. The burning car is described as falling far from the dark, which could symbolize how the other person now knows how it feels to be vulnerable and exposed. The singer's pain turns into flames, and "no one blames my heart," indicating that they will not be the one to blame for the destruction they caused.


Line by Line Meaning

I once, I once, I once
I used to be part of you, but not anymore


Was part of you
I used to be connected to you in some way


You hoped that the
You wished for something to happen


Hands choking me
Some force trying to control or harm me


Had broken me apart
Had successfully separated me from you


Now I don't
But now I no longer


Now I don't
But now I no longer


Now I don't
But now I no longer


Believe in you
Have faith or trust in you


My open end
My vulnerability or weakness


Your only friend
The only thing that supported or accepted me


Was always in the dark
Was never in the light, hidden or secret


Til I took a shoe
Until I did something drastic or unexpected


That belonged to you
That was yours, that you valued


Then took a torch to your new car
Then destroyed something else that was important to you


And now that car
The damaged vehicle


Looks like a star
Shines or stands out despite its damage


That's fallen far from the dark
In a different place than before, free from the hidden or negative


And as my pain
My emotional or physical suffering


Turns into flames
Becomes anger or destructive energy


No one blames my heart
My actions are justified, given the pain or betrayal I experienced




Contributed by Jacob G. Suggest a correction in the comments below.
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

bob black

one of my absolute fav songs from the residents

Forrest Green

"As my pain turns into flames, no one blames my heart" I heard Molly sing these lyrics in a live version of "Demons Dance Alone"

G95G95

This is my favorite line, from my favorite song, on my favorite album

Wally P Doyle

I was at the Seattle show on this tour. Met Molly, Hardy, Homer, and Nolan. The show was amazing, and so were they.

Nic Lawson

Saw this tour, met Molly.

More Versions