Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

It's a Sin
Eddy Arnold Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

It's a sin, my darling how I love you
Because I know our love can never be
It's a sin to keep this memory of you
When silence proves that you've forgotten me

The dream I built for us has tumbled
Each promise broken like my heart
It's a sin, my darling how I love you
So much in love and yet so far apart




It's a sin to hide behind this heartache
To make believe that I've found someone new
It's a sin to say that I don't miss you
When people know I'm still in love with you

I'm sure you're happy with another
Who shares the love I couldn't win
Why pretend that I can't live without you
When deep inside I know that it's a sin

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of Eddy Arnold’s “It’s a Sin” express the singer's turmoil over a relationship that has ended, but that he is unable to let go of. He knows that his love is futile since he and his beloved can never be together. He understands that keeping his memories of her alive is pointless because she has forgotten him. But he finds it difficult to forget her and his love for her.


The lyrics also show the devastation of lost dreams and broken promises, accompanied by a broken heart, a burden that the singer carries alone. Despite his heartache, he knows that it is wrong to hide behind it and pretend that he has found someone else. Furthermore, he acknowledges that it would be a sin to lie and say that he doesn't miss her if he really does. He is aware that his ex has moved on and is happy with someone else, but he is not ready to let go.


In conclusion, “It's a Sin” portrays the struggle of letting go of love that is already lost. The singer comprehends that his love is foolish given the facts, yet he cannot help but dream of what could have been. The pain and longing resonate throughout the song, and the lyrics emphasize the guilt and futility of holding on to a love that can never be.


Line by Line Meaning

It's a sin, my darling how I love you
Expressing love for you is a sin, my dear, because our love cannot thrive.


Because I know our love can never be
Since I know that our love cannot sustain, it makes my love for you sinful.


It's a sin to keep this memory of you
Holding onto memories of you is a sin because silence shows that you have forgotten me.


When silence proves that you've forgotten me
The fact that you are silent shows that you have forgotten about me.


The dream I built for us has tumbled
The expectations that I had for us have crumbled.


Each promise broken like my heart
The promises that were made have been broken, and my heart is shattered.


So much in love and yet so far apart
Despite being deeply in love, we are far apart from each other.


It's a sin to hide behind this heartache
Trying to deceive myself and others by pretending to have found someone new is a sin.


To make believe that I've found someone new
Faking that I have moved on by finding someone new is not right.


When people know I'm still in love with you
Others know that I am still deeply in love with you, so pretending otherwise is a sin.


I'm sure you're happy with another
I am certain that you have found happiness with another person.


Who shares the love I couldn't win
The person you are with now is someone who reciprocates the love that I could not have.


Why pretend that I can't live without you
It is silly to pretend that I cannot survive without you.


When deep inside I know that it's a sin
I know deep down that it is wrong to indulge in this love that cannot flourish.




Lyrics © Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC
Written by: FRED ROSE, ZEB TURNER

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind

More Versions