Joel the Lump of Coal
The Killers Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Some time ago, at Santa's place
Up in the old North Pole
There lived a lump of anthracite
Whose parents called him Joel

Joel, Joel, the lump of coal
Happy as a lump can be
He just wants to keep Santa warm
And make the elves cozy

But Santa Claus had other plans
For Joel one fateful day
"Joel, you're just the lump I need
Come join me on my sleigh"

Joel, Joel, the lump of coal
Heart leapt up with joy
"I'll soon be Santa's present to
A lucky girl or boy

We'll laugh and play together
And hold each other tight
Snuggle under clean white sheets
When we go to sleep at night"

Then Santa's elves all laughed at Joel
"You're in for a surprise
You're not a special Christmas gift
You're just a booby prize

What kid would ever want you?
You're filthy as can be
Now you have to go and live
With one who's been naughty"

"But I make heat," poor Joel cried
"And electricity"
"You pollute the air
With CO2 and mercury"

Joel, Joel, the lump of coal
Fell down upon his knees
"I don't wanna live with a naughty kid
Don't make me, Santa, please"

But Santa laughed his jolly laugh
"Ho, ho, you stupid lump
You're just the thing to teach this brat
That Santa ain't no chump"

So off they flew and, before he knew
Joel was in a sack
He cried and yelled to Santa Claus
"Why don't we just go back?"

And then came Christmas morning
And, much to Joel's surprise (Much to Joel's surprise)
He saw a boy with the saddest face
And tears were in his eyes (Tears were in his eyes)

He picked Joel up and held him
And said "You can be my friend (Hey man, let's be friends)
I would've liked some presents but
You're what Santa chose to send (Santa chose to send)

It's true, I've been a naughty boy
And maybe that's a sin (Maybe that's a sin)
If this is how Santa treats the kids
I'm just glad that I'm not him"

Joel, Joel, the lump of coal
Knew what he must do
He said "Now I know the reason why
I got sent to you

Cause when a person hurts inside
It turns him hard and cruel
But I know how to make your pain
Into a precious jewel

So take me in your hand, young man
And squeeze with all your might
Let's turn your pain and anger
Into something that shines bright"

Then Joel, Joel, the lump of coal
He gave his life away




So that one good naughty little boy
Had a diamond on Christmas day

Overall Meaning

The Killers' song Joel the Lump of Coal tells the story of a lump of coal named Joel, who dreams of being a Christmas present for a lucky girl or boy. He is excited when Santa Claus chooses him to be a special gift until he learns from the elves that he is not intended for a good child, but rather for a "naughty" one. Despite his protests that he is useful for making heat and electricity, Joel is taken away by Santa Claus to fulfill his duty as a lesson for the child who receives him. However, Joel eventually teaches the child to turn his pain and anger into something precious, and sacrifices himself so that the boy can have a diamond on Christmas day.


The song can be interpreted as a commentary on the expectation that Christmas presents have to be lavish and expensive to be appreciated, while disregarding the value of practical and useful gifts. The use of a lump of coal, a typically negative Christmas symbol, as the singer also emphasizes the importance of finding the positives in seemingly negative situations.


The playful and upbeat tone of the song contrasts starkly with the bittersweet ending, with Joel's sacrifice adding an unexpected emotional depth to the story. Overall, Joel the Lump of Coal shows that there is value in every gift, no matter how small or unexpected.


Line by Line Meaning

Some time ago, at Santa's place
This story takes place a while back in Santa's abode


Up in the old North Pole
The location of the story is the North Pole


There lived a lump of anthracite
There was a block of coal in this place


Whose parents called him Joel
This block of coal was named Joel by its parents


Joel, Joel, the lump of coal
This coal block is referred to as Joel throughout the story


Happy as a lump can be
Joel was content with his life at the North Pole and probably didn't know what was coming his way


He just wants to keep Santa warm
Joel's purpose in life was to provide heat to Santa


And make the elves cozy
In addition to keeping Santa warm, Joel was also supposed to provide warmth for the elves


But Santa Claus had other plans
However, Santa had different intentions for Joel


For Joel one fateful day
This change of events occurred on a particular, significant day


"Joel, you're just the lump I need
Santa found the perfect use for Joel


Come join me on my sleigh"
To achieve his goal, Santa asked Joel to accompany him on his sleigh ride


Heart leapt up with joy
Joel was thrilled by this sudden change of events


"I'll soon be Santa's present to
Joel thought he was going to be a gift


A lucky girl or boy
He believed that he would bring joy to some fortunate child


We'll laugh and play together
The happy child and Joel would have fun together


And hold each other tight
They would embrace and be affectionate to one another


Snuggle under clean white sheets
They would sleep cozily under fresh, white sheets


When we go to sleep at night"
This snuggling would occur at bedtime


Then Santa's elves all laughed at Joel
The other creatures at the North Pole mocked Joel


"You're in for a surprise
The elves believed that Joel was in for a shock


You're not a special Christmas gift
Joel was not an ordinary present


You're just a booby prize
He was nothing more than an unwanted, useless, or even harmful reward


What kid would ever want you?
The elves thought that no kid would receive Joel with excitement


You're filthy as can be
To complicate matters, Joel was dirty or unclean


Now you have to go and live
As a result, Joel was kicked out of the North Pole


With one who's been naughty"
He was paired with someone who didn't behave well


"But I make heat," poor Joel cried
As a defense, Joel explained what he was good for


"And electricity"
He could even produce electric power


"You pollute the air
But Santa's creatures criticized Joel over his ecological impact


With CO2 and mercury"
Specifically, they pointed out how he releases greenhouse gases and toxic elements


Fell down upon his knees
This negative feedback was devastating for the coal block


"I don't wanna live with a naughty kid
Joel, who meant well, didn't want to be in contact with bad behavior


Don't make me, Santa, please"
He begged Santa not to force him on this kid


Ho, ho, you stupid lump
Santa Claus didn't listen to Joel's plea and instead made fun of him


You're just the thing to teach this brat
However, Santa thought that Joel was actually the perfect solution to this kid's problems


So off they flew and, before he knew
Despite his reluctance, Joel was taken away with this naughty boy


Joel was in a sack
He was thus put in a bag or container for transport


He cried and yelled to Santa Claus
Joel expressed his disappointment and sadness to Santa


"Why don't we just go back?"
He wanted to return to the North Pole


And then came Christmas morning
Some time afterwards, it was finally Christmas day


Much to Joel's surprise (Much to Joel's surprise)
What followed next was unexpected for Joel


He saw a boy with the saddest face
This kid wasn't happy, to Joel's understatement


And tears were in his eyes (Tears were in his eyes)
He was actually crying


He picked Joel up and held him
However, he interacted with Joel in a manner better than anyone else has ever done


And said "You can be my friend
He befriended Joel not because of material gifts, but because of emotional support


(Hey man, let's be friends)
He expressed this invitation in modern slang


I would've liked some presents but
He admitted that he would've enjoyed some traditional gifts too


You're what Santa chose to send (Santa chose to send)
Regardless, this coal was a precious, unique jewel in its own way for him


It's true, I've been a naughty boy
He accepted his misbehavior


And maybe that's a sin (Maybe that's a sin)
He acknowledged the possibility that he did something wrong


If this is how Santa treats the kids
He questioned or expressed skepticism over Santa's generosity or sense of justice


I'm just glad that I'm not him"
He was relieved and happy that he wasn't in Santa's position and didn't have to deal with any problems himself


Knew what he must do
At this point, Joel knew what he needed to do


"Now I know the reason why
He realized that there was a higher purpose for him being with this boy


I got sent to you
That reason was to make this boy's hardships bearable


Cause when a person hurts inside
Joel understood why this boy was naughty


It turns him hard and cruel
By painful experiences, people can become bitter and mean


But I know how to make your pain
However, Joel had the ability to ease this boy's pain


Into a precious jewel
In fact, he would transform or convert that pain into something valuable


So take me in your hand, young man
He offered himself to this boy, inviting him to use him as he intended


And squeeze with all your might
He instructed him to use his strength to apply pressure on Joel


Let's turn your pain and anger
Through that physical process, Joel would transform those negative emotions


Into something that shines bright"
And create something beautiful out of that process


He gave his life away
Joel sacrificed himself for the benefit of this boy


So that one good naughty little boy
Through that sacrifice, this boy became something better


Had a diamond on Christmas day
This boy ended up with a precious stone that would remind him of his better self and a selfless act that transformed him




Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group
Written by: BRANDON RICHARD FLOWERS, DAVID KEUNING, MARK STOERMER, RONNIE VANNUCCI

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

Sebastián V

I can't believe that I'm still crying with a song written after a lump of coal 7 years ago.

Jerry Cerkanowicz

I cry also sebastian

MilkPudding

Same here. It's 2023 now

Michael Brown

Why is it that the killers singing about a lump of coal named Joel is still better than 80-90% of mainstream music today?...

lifeinthebarbie

it’s not

lifeinthebarbie

@GOATmaro you know brandon p0 0. ps right? cancelled.

Robb Hays

Because he gets it.

Michael Brown

@lifeinthebarbie What

Forgetful

@Nate B so much of rap is extremely intelligent.

1 More Replies...

Jimmy Kimmel Live

Merry Christmas! We're counting down the top ten #Kimmel  videos of 2014! Here is #7... #JoelTheLumpOfCoal  with The Killers

More Comments

More Versions