How Could You?
Billie Holiday Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

Just when romance got a start
You decided it was time to part
How could you?
How could you?

It was on a night like this
You left me and didn't leave a kiss
How could you?
How could you?

You know that love is just like apple pie
It's either sweet or tart
You could be the apple of my eye
But you, you, you upset the apple cart

I was looking forward to
All those little things you didn't do




How could you,
Could you break my heart?

Overall Meaning

The lyrics to Billie Holiday's song "How Could You?" are about a lover who abruptly leaves a relationship just as it was beginning to blossom. The singer is full of hurt and confusion, wondering how someone could end things so suddenly and without any explanation. The opening verse sets the scene, with the singer reminiscing about the joy and promise of new romance before abruptly being cast aside. The chorus, repeated several times throughout the song, consists of the singer questioning her former lover: "How could you? How could you?"


In the second verse, the singer recalls the specific circumstances of the breakup, revealing that her lover left her without so much as a goodbye kiss. The imagery of a sweet, juicy apple is used to represent love, with the singer lamenting that her lover has "upset the apple cart" by ending things so abruptly. In the final verse, the singer expresses her disappointment that the potential she saw in the relationship will never be realized. The song is a poignant exploration of the pain of lost love and the bewilderment that comes with sudden, unexplained endings.


Line by Line Meaning

Just when romance got a start
Right when the romantic relationship was flourishing


You decided it was time to part
You made the decision that it was time to end the relationship


How could you?
Asking how you could do this to me


How could you?
Repeating the question of how you could end the relationship so abruptly


It was on a night like this
Referring to a specific night when you left


You left me and didn't leave a kiss
You ended the relationship without any farewell or affection


How could you?
Expressing disbelief and pain from your sudden departure


How could you?
Repeating the question of how you could leave me without any affection


You know that love is just like apple pie
Making an analogy that love is like a familiar dessert


It's either sweet or tart
Love has two sides, it can be good or bad


You could be the apple of my eye
Referring to the person as someone important and special


But you, you, you upset the apple cart
You disrupted and ruined the peaceful situation


I was looking forward to
Expressing expectation for something in the future


All those little things you didn't do
Referring to the person not fulfilling what was expected in the relationship


How could you,
Asking how the person could fail to deliver these expectations


Could you break my heart?
Asking a rhetorical question about how the person could break your heart




Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group, Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC, Peermusic Publishing, Warner Chappell Music, Inc.
Written by: JONATHAN ROBINSON, GLORIA STEWART, JOEY ELIAS

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

MrPuros

His Master's Jazz voice. Billie Holiday has that thing..

Coraline Jones

Love it

Okmusix

Hi,
thanks for adding a comment.
I ask you two minutes to go and see our online shop:
https://teespring.com/it/stores/ok-store-16
Here you can find quality products at an affordable price: every week we add new ones.
A little gift for you:
https://sellfy.com/euterpe/p/9dyslf/

More Versions