Promise Of Eternity
The Magnetic Fields Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

What if the show couldn't go on
What if we all got jobs
And got to bed before dawn

What if Old Joe had to retire
What if all the stage hands were let go or fired
That's just like what the world would be
If you fell out of love with me
I can't let this happen to you
Don't you let it happen to me

What would our friends and family say
If they could only see
If you let this happen to us

Don't think you'd be setting me free
Wasn't it you and I who made
Promises of eternity

What if the lights didn't go on
What if the velvet curtain had to be taken down
What if the clowns couldn't be clowns

And all those painted smiles gave in to plaintive frowns
What if no show ever happened again




No Seven, no 8 1/2, no Nine, and no "10"
All numbers and no mystery No promise of eternity

Overall Meaning

The lyrics of "Promise of Eternity" explore the idea of a relationship disintegrating and what that means for the future. The song begins with the hypothetical situation of the show not going on, symbolizing the end of their relationship. The second verse delves into the reality of what would happen if Old Joe had to retire, signifying the end of an era in the relationship. The chorus then expresses the fear of what others would say if they broke up and that they made promises of eternity. Finally, the last verse paints a bleak picture of a world without the show, without mystery, just empty numbers.


The song is a commentary on the fragility of relationships and how easily they can crumble. The metaphor of a stage production brings home the idea of a relationship being a performance, with roles to play and scripts to follow. By alluding to famous theater productions such as "Seven," "8 1/2," and "Nine," the songwriter Stephen Merritt draws on the idea of how the magic of the stage can transform and transport us.


Line by Line Meaning

What if the show couldn't go on
What if we were unable to continue our journey together


What if we all got jobs
What if our personal careers overshadowed our relationship


And got to bed before dawn
What if we prioritized work and neglected the time we spent together


What if Old Joe had to retire
What if circumstances changed and we were no longer able to maintain our current lifestyle


What if all the stage hands were let go or fired
What if important people or elements in our life disappeared


That's just like what the world would be
All of these hypothetical situations culminate into what the future would be like without each other


If you fell out of love with me
If your feelings for me were to decrease or disappear


I can't let this happen to you
I would not want you to experience these negative feelings


Don't you let it happen to me
Similarly, please do not allow yourself to feel this way about me


What would our friends and family say
If they were to see our relationship deteriorate, what would their reaction be


If they could only see
If they knew the full extent of our situation


If you let this happen to us
If we allowed our relationship to fall apart


Don't think you'd be setting me free
Breaking up would not result in ultimate freedom as anticipated


Wasn't it you and I who made
We were the ones who created


Promises of eternity
Promises to be with each other forever


What if the lights didn't go on
What if the usual spark in our relationship faded


What if the velvet curtain had to be taken down
What if the romantic aspect of our relationship came to an end


What if the clowns couldn't be clowns
What if the happy, playful aspects of our relationship no longer existed


And all those painted smiles gave in to plaintive frowns
The happy expressions we shared together would become sad and regretful


What if no show ever happened again
What if we were unable to continue our journey together in any capacity


No Seven, no 8 1/2, no Nine, and no "10"
No memorable moments together


All numbers and no mystery
We would only have empty actions with no deeper meaning


No promise of eternity
We would no longer have our lifetime commitment to each other




Lyrics © ROUGH TRADE PUBLISHING

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found

More Versions