Where Are You Now My Son?
Joan Baez Lyrics


Jump to: Overall Meaning ↴  Line by Line Meaning ↴

(Words and Music by Joan Baez)

It's walking to the battleground that always makes me cry
I've met so few folks in my time who weren't afraid to die
But dawn bleeds with the people here and morning skies are red
As young girls load up bicycles with flowers for the dead

An aging woman picks along the craters and the rubble
A piece of cloth, a bit of shoe, a whole lifetime of trouble
A sobbing chant comes from her throat and splits the morning air
The single son she had last night is buried under her

They say that the war is done
Where are you now, my son?

An old man with unsteady gait and beard of ancient white
Bent to the ground with arms outstretched faltering in his plight
I took his hand to steady him, he stood and did not turn
But smiled and wept and bowed and mumbled softly, "Danke shoen"

The children on the roadsides of the villages and towns
Would stand around us laughing as we stood like giant clowns
The mourning bands told whom they'd lost by last night's phantom messenger
And they spoke their only words in English, "Johnson, Nixon, Kissinger"

Now that the war's being won
Where are you now, my son?

The siren gives a running break to those who live in town
Take the children and the blankets to the concrete underground
Sometimes we'd sing and joke and paint bright pictures on the wall
And wonder if we would die well and if we'd loved at all

The helmetless defiant ones sit on the curb and stare
At tracers flashing through the sky and planes bursting in air
But way out in the villages no warning comes before a blast
That means a sleeping child will never make it to the door

The days of our youth were fun
Where are you now, my son?

From the distant cabins in the sky where no man hears the sound
Of death on earth from his own bombs, six pilots were shot down
Next day six hulking bandaged men were dazzled by a room
Of newsmen. Sally keep the faith, let's hope this war ends soon

In a damaged prison camp where they no longer had command
They shook their heads, what irony, we thought peace was at hand
The preacher read a Christmas prayer and the men kneeled on the ground
Then sheepishly asked me to sing "They Drove Old Dixie Down"

Yours was the righteous gun
Where are you now, my son?

We gathered in the lobby celebrating Chrismas Eve
The French, the Poles, the Indians, Cubans and Vietnamese
The tiny tree our host had fixed sweetened familiar psalms
But the most sacred of Christmas prayers was shattered by the bombs

So back into the shelter where two lovely women rose
And with a brilliance and a fierceness and a gentleness which froze
The rest of us to silence as their voices soared with joy
Outshining every bomb that fell that night upon Hanoi

With bravery we have sun
But where are you now, my son?

Oh people of the shelters what a gift you've given me
To smile at me and quietly let me share your agony
And I can only bow in utter humbleness and ask
Forgiveness and forgiveness for the things we've brought to pass

The black pyjama'd culture that we tried to kill with pellet holes
And rows of tiny coffins we've paid for with our souls
Have built a spirit seldom seen in women and in men
And the white flower of Bac Mai will surely blossom once again

I've heard that the war is done
Then where are you now, my son?





© 1973 Chandos Music (ASCAP)

Overall Meaning

Joan Baez's "Where Are You Now My Son?" is a powerful anti-war song that reflects on the devastating effects of the Vietnam War on the Vietnamese people. Baez sings about the heartbreaking scenes she witnessed during her visit to Vietnam where she met with families who had lost their loved ones in the war. She also observed the resilience and spirit of the Vietnamese people who were able to find hope and continue to rebuild their lives despite the destruction around them.


The song starts with Baez describing her emotional state when she visits the battleground and how she is moved by the people's willingness to sacrifice their lives. She then goes on to describe the pain of a grieving mother who lost her only son in the war. Baez also highlights the plight of the elderly and children who are caught up in the war and its aftermath.


The song continues to touch upon themes of loss, survival, and hope as it weaves together different narratives of the war's impact on both sides of the conflict. Overall, the song's poignant lyrics and haunting melody serve as a reminder of the devastating consequences of war and the human cost of conflict.


Line by Line Meaning

It's walking to the battleground that always makes me cry
The mere thought of going to war brings Joan Baez to tears.


I've met so few folks in my time who weren't afraid to die
Joan Baez laments the universal fear of death she has encountered in her life.


But dawn bleeds with the people here and morning skies are red
The sky is tinted to represent the violence and bloodshed in the land below.


As young girls load up bicycles with flowers for the dead
In spite of tragedy, children gather flowers to honor the fallen.


An aging woman picks along the craters and the rubble
An older woman wanders through devastation to find any remnant of her son.


A piece of cloth, a bit of shoe, a whole lifetime of trouble
Even small items remind the woman of her son's life and how he lost it in this war.


A sobbing chant comes from her throat and splits the morning air
The woman is in so much anguish that she can't help but vocalize her grief.


The single son she had last night is buried under her
The woman has lost her one and only child.


They say that the war is done
Rumors circulate that the conflict has ended.


Where are you now, my son?
Joan Baez is searching for answers as to the whereabouts of this grieving mother's son.


An old man with unsteady gait and beard of ancient white
An elderly man, disheveled and frail, is introduced to Joan Baez.


Bent to the ground with arms outstretched faltering in his plight
The man is struggling to maintain any sort of stability as he bends over.


I took his hand to steady him, he stood and did not turn
Joan Baez helped this man regain balance and he didn't turn away from her for assistance.


But smiled and wept and bowed and mumbled softly, 'Danke shoen'
The man was grateful for Joan Baez's kindness even though he was crying and struggling.


The children on the roadsides of the villages and towns
Joan Baez is observing the children who remain untouched by war.


Would stand around us laughing as we stood like giant clowns
Even though Joan Baez and others are adults, the children giggle at their attempts to be lighthearted in the face of overwhelming turmoil.


The mourning bands told whom they'd lost by last night's phantom messenger
Messages brought by an unknown carrier reveal which families have lost loved ones recently.


And they spoke their only words in English, 'Johnson, Nixon, Kissinger'
The people blame these powerful men for the war and the associated deaths.


Now that the war's being won
The war is far from over, but the tide may be turning.


Where are you now, my son?
Joan Baez still seeks an answer to the mother's unanswered question.


The siren gives a running break to those who live in town
Sirens indicate that attacks are imminent and people take shelter in underground bunkers.


Take the children and the blankets to the concrete underground
Families flock together and huddle under the false protection of concrete walls.


Sometimes we'd sing and joke and paint bright pictures on the wall
Even amidst danger, people do their best to maintain hope and happiness through songs and artwork.


And wonder if we would die well and if we'd loved at all
The possibility of their own death makes them ponder their own legacy and the ultimate value of love.


The helmetless defiant ones sit on the curb and stare
Some soldiers defy authority and refuse to wear protective gear.


At tracers flashing through the sky and planes bursting in air
They watch as planes and bombs paint a destructive picture in the sky.


But way out in the villages no warning comes before a blast
Many people in rural areas have no way of anticipating bombs and other attacks.


That means a sleeping child will never make it to the door
The harshest consequence is that children may never have a chance to reach the safety of a bunker.


The days of our youth were fun
The innocent memories of their youth are in sharp contrast to the bleakness of their current lives.


Where are you now, my son?
Joan Baez has not forgotten about the mother and son and continues to search for the missing man.


From the distant cabins in the sky where no man hears the sound
Pilots in the sky, removed from the sounds of war, have an aerial view of the destruction they cause.


Of death on earth from his own bombs, six pilots were shot down
The pilots who thought they were safe from harm were also brought down by the conflict.


Next day six hulking bandaged men were dazzled by a room
Despite their injuries, the pilots are led to a room filled with journalists and adoring well-wishers.


Of newsmen. Sally keep the faith, let's hope this war ends soon
Joan Baez encourages Sally, among others, to maintain hope for the end of the war.


In a damaged prison camp where they no longer had command
Even at the prison camp, the damage from the war is palpable, and the commanders lack control.


They shook their heads, what irony, we thought peace was at hand
The irony of their situation leads to a sense of hopelessness.


The preacher read a Christmas prayer and the men kneeled on the ground
In a moment of shared humility, the men in the camp observe the religious holiday and take a moment to be grateful and humble.


Then sheepishly asked me to sing 'They Drove Old Dixie Down'
They look to Joan Baez for comfort and ask for a familiar song.


Yours was the righteous gun
Joan Baez draws attention to the fact that this war is not won through righteousness or moral superiority.


Where are you now, my son?
Again, Joan Baez searches for answers to the fate of the missing soldier.


We gathered in the lobby celebrating Chrismas Eve
A group comes together to celebrate Christmas, united in the need for companionship and warm feelings in uncertain times.


The French, the Poles, the Indians, Cubans and Vietnamese
The group is diverse in nationality and brings their various experiences of war to the table.


The tiny tree our host had fixed sweetened familiar psalms
A small tree helps maintain a sense of familiarity and warmth through traditional religious hymns.


But the most sacred of Christmas prayers was shattered by the bombs
The religious moments of the celebration are brutalized by the violence of the war.


So back into the shelter where two lovely women rose
To escape the violence, the group returns to the shelter where two women's spirits inspire hope in everyone else.


And with a brilliance and a fierceness and a gentleness which froze
These women showcase powerful and gentle spirits, freezing everyone with their strength and resilience.


The rest of us to silence as their voices soared with joy
In response to the beauty of the women's voices, everyone else is left silent and in awe.


Outshining every bomb that fell that night upon Hanoi
Their voices managed to overpower the physical and emotional damage sustained from bombs that fell that very same night.


With bravery we have sun
Even in the face of terror and tragedy, these women show strength and courage.


But where are you now, my son?
Despite everything else in her life, Joan Baez cannot ignore the burned mother's suffering and loss.


Oh people of the shelters what a gift you've given me
Joan Baez appreciates the shelter and the people within it, who have given her a new appreciation for life.


To smile at me and quietly let me share your agony
The people in the shelter welcome others and allow them to share in the struggles they face.


And I can only bow in utter humbleness and ask
Joan Baez is humbled by the compassion and generosity she's encountered.


Forgiveness and forgiveness for the things we've brought to pass
The people in the shelter forgive Joan Baez for her part in the war and the harm it has caused.


The black pyjama'd culture that we tried to kill with pellet holes
Referring to the color of the Viet Cong's clothing, Joan Baez acknowledges how they have been dehumanized and unfairly targeted.


And rows of tiny coffins we've paid for with our souls
Joan Baez recognizes the senseless loss of life caused by the war.


Have built a spirit seldom seen in women and in men
Their struggle has given birth to a spirit of resilience that is rare in people everywhere.


And the white flower of Bac Mai will surely blossom once again
Hope remains that something beautiful will come from this conflict.


I've heard that the war is done
Despite what people say, Joan Baez still sees evidence of violence and turmoil all around her.


Then where are you now, my son?
Her search for the woman's missing son continues to weigh heavily on her mind.




Lyrics © Downtown Music Publishing
Written by: JOAN C. BAEZ

Lyrics Licensed & Provided by LyricFind
To comment on or correct specific content, highlight it

Genre not found
Artist not found
Album not found
Song not found
Comments from YouTube:

L. Campos

I confess that this, among dozens and dozens of precious gems that I had the privilege of sharing with so many others, offered us by Joan Baez, this is one specially deeply touching and revealing of this utterly beautiful soul. Very difficult to find words to discribe this rare, rare human being named Joan Baez. She keeps more than sixty years of a deeply coherent and loving journey , offering her immense talent and heart to , in her own words , give voice to the ones that don´t have one . Today on her 77 years of an inspirational and fruiiful life, the ORGANIZED LOVE remains the sacred label she honors , with unshakable commitment. Lucky us having her still among us.

Naomi McClarrinon

Sang and spoken with such conviction. We could hear the sounds of war and feel that Vietnamese mother wailing in pain. It could be anyone -- war gets you nowhere. Peace is the answer.

Protest Songs

What an amazing album, thanks for sharing this part. It's an impressive mix of journalism and spoken word/music. How timeless the message: "Yours was the righteous gun. Where are you now, my son?"  

AccurateCrabLegs

Someone put this on at a party once and everybody stopped dancing to listen. By the end, we were all sitting on the floor holding hands and comforting each other. Thank you.

Reto Hofmann

What a great timeless song on a great great album...!

Renee Hatch

I remember my Momma playing this on 8 track and it stuck with me all these years! Hauntingly beautiful.

Thorsten Czub

We all love Joan Baez. For the peace movement and the many important things she had done. I was born 1966. but she heavily influenced me. I went into the DFG-VK, the german peace movement. I refuted german army.
I listened her songs and adviced people who wanted to refute the german army with my own experience.
I became a pacifist. All because of joans marvellous fight for peace, black power, womens liberation and a better world. Joan Baez, may you feel all our love. You deserve to be blessed. Your live. Given to peace and love.

John Cu

Damn as Vietnamese it was chilling to hear 1:56, pretty much a conversation about dead and missing people, then one woman's griefing in misery of loss.

Uxxxysz

I was on the ship that provided air traffic control for the battle that night - December 24, 1972. I didn't hear this song until several years later. To those of us on board that ship it was just a busy night of doing our jobs. It didn't seem real to us that there were people who were affected by what we were doing that night. I was the supervisor in my department that night.

M Tyer

Still brings me to tears after all these years. Will men ever learn?

More Comments

More Versions